You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

Beautiful Things

T Clark January 07, 2018 at 17:28 22950 views 428 comments
Some things I think are beautiful.

I'd like for others to participate. I'd like to keep this to visual beauty. Not wonderful, beautiful. Grandchildren and cats are welcome, but only if they are beautiful, even if it's only to you.

Let's keep it to very few words. Let the beauty speak for itself. Captions would be nice, but optional.

I intend this as serious, so no snark. Playful or even funny is good, as long as it's beautiful.

Incan architecture. Machu Piccu:
User image

By Martin St-Amant (S23678) (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

Cusco:

User image

By Martin St-Amant (S23678) (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

Comments (428)

T Clark January 07, 2018 at 17:43 #140923
Cher in "Moonstruck"
User image

Clare Danes in "Romeo and Juliet."
User image

T Clark January 07, 2018 at 17:48 #140925
W.S. George Petalware

User image

Roger's Brothers Oval Thread silverplate

User image
TimeLine January 07, 2018 at 19:10 #140959
I find so many things beautiful. I have a lot of little personal ones, like the way a friend of mine stiffens up before laughing at his own joke. There are so many visuals captured in my mind.

The Australian sky at night when there is no light pollution.

User image

Sunrise at Wadi Rum in Jordan. Blew my mind away.

User image

Evie Hammond from V for Vendetta.

User image

Street art in Tel Aviv

User image

Agustino January 07, 2018 at 19:16 #140962
Quoting TimeLine
Sunrise at Wadi Rum in Jordan. Blew my mind away.

Very powerful (Y)

Quoting TimeLine
Street art in Tel Aviv

*shakes head*...
T Clark January 07, 2018 at 19:18 #140963
Reply to Agustino

Show us some of your own.

TimeLine January 07, 2018 at 19:19 #140964
Quoting Agustino
*shakes head*...


The liberals in Tel Aviv are beautiful to me in what would otherwise be an intense demographic.
Agustino January 07, 2018 at 19:21 #140965
Quoting T Clark
Show us some of your own.

:’( I really don't have any. Almost never take photos, except crappy ones lol.
T Clark January 07, 2018 at 19:23 #140967
Quoting Agustino
I really don't have any. Almost never take photos, except crappy ones lol.


Crappy is fine, as long as it is crappily beautiful. Or beautifully crappy. Also - none of the pictures I showed are my own. I took them off the web and tried to attribute them if I could.
praxis January 07, 2018 at 19:29 #140968
A few aesthetic selections from my phone. Prepare to be blown away.


User image
Our new pup Redi. Adorable, right? and so conscientious about his food.

User image
Weird bird I saw at the beach the other day. Check out that pecker.

User image
I’m guessing this guy’s a plumber. Not classically beautiful, I grant you.

User image
California wildfire smoke last month.

User image
Wildfire smoke as seen from county line (near Malibu).
T Clark January 07, 2018 at 19:49 #140974
Quoting praxis
A few aesthetic selections from my phone. Prepare to be blown away.


[s]Very nice.

How do you get photo files from your computer or phone to load as visible images on a post rather than as files you have to click on to see? Sometimes I can get it to work. Sometimes not.[/s]

Edit - Figured it out.
Cavacava January 07, 2018 at 19:52 #140977
User image

User image
T Clark January 07, 2018 at 20:01 #140979
Quoting TimeLine
I have a lot of little personal ones


Not pushing, but personal is fine if you want. For example.

My grandfather's farm on the Chesapeake Bay near Easton, Maryland, USA, where I was born. Sold in mid-1980s. From Google Earth:

User image

If she finds out I posted this, it will end 50 years of friendship:

User image

Noble Dust January 07, 2018 at 20:14 #140984
Reply to T Clark

How? Lol, I'm the most tech illiterate millennial of all time.
T Clark January 07, 2018 at 21:08 #140999
Quoting Noble Dust
How? Lol, I'm the most tech illiterate millennial of all time.


Start the post.
Click the paperclip at the top of the box.
Use the box that opens to go to the directory where the picture file is.
Double left click on the file.
The file should now show up at the bottom of the post.
Click "insert" next to the file.
Ta Daaaa.

I think you have to be a subscriber for it to work. Not sure.
praxis January 07, 2018 at 23:09 #141036
Non-subscribers don't see the paperclip for attachments, I believe. Need to upload images to photo hosts like Flickr, copy a link to the image, and then paste the link here.

From the archive.

User image
Art project debacle.
Noble Dust January 07, 2018 at 23:30 #141039
Quoting T Clark
think you have to be a subscriber for it to work. Not sure


Oh man, pay to play, eh?
Noble Dust January 08, 2018 at 06:07 #141157
Old book covers:

User image

My roommate Carl:

User image

This drop of water:

User image

Walking On Water, by Makoto Fujimura:

User image

Noble Dust January 08, 2018 at 06:18 #141163
Reply to praxis

Redi is adorable. I'm slowly, begrudgingly, becoming a dog person. I still could never own one, though.
Noble Dust January 08, 2018 at 06:20 #141164
Reply to Agustino

Surely you can think of something beautiful to contribute. :)
ArguingWAristotleTiff January 08, 2018 at 12:56 #141231
NicK and I met in the woods that look over the Oak Creek Canyon in Sedona, which is where we were married 4 yrs later. My parents believed and I believed in a 4 yr engagement which was satisfied and we have been going ever since.
User image

Ever wonder what it looked like to live back in the Hay Day!
User image

Hell Freezes Over at the Ranch
User image
T Clark January 09, 2018 at 00:16 #141406
Quoting Noble Dust
Old book covers:


What are these "books" of which you speak?
Hanover January 09, 2018 at 02:38 #141452
Trail option in Whitefish, Montana:User image
Found it. Finally!
Hanover January 09, 2018 at 02:47 #141454
My dog in Xanadu traipsing the River Alph:

User image
T Clark January 09, 2018 at 03:23 #141470
Quoting Hanover
My dog in Xanadu traipsing the River Alph:


Holy smokes. I looked up River Alph and Xanadu - that's bullshit, it says it's in Antarctica. Those are trees and flowers. Then I read down and it says it is in an ice free area. That's amazing. I never knew such a thing existed. Thanks.
Hanover January 09, 2018 at 03:25 #141472
Reply to T Clark From a drug induced poem, not real.


www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/43991/kubla-khan


T Clark January 09, 2018 at 03:38 #141477
Quoting Hanover
From a drug induced poem, not real.


Then why is it in Wikipedia?
Noble Dust January 09, 2018 at 05:21 #141520
Reply to T Clark

They're strange little curiosities which I purchase regularly for the sole purpose of beginning but never finishing. There's a fine line between ambition, masochism, and denial.
T Clark January 09, 2018 at 23:29 #142066
Orange does something to me. You talk about favorite colors, but it's something more. It makes me feel at home. It calms me down. It feels like part of me. My soul is orange.

When my children ask me what I want for Christmas, I tell them "something orange." These are gifts from my younger son.
User image

I bought this for my wife a long time ago. She didn't care for it. I love it.
User image

It makes me feel good just to look at these things.
praxis January 09, 2018 at 23:47 #142069
Reply to T Clark

Cool frog but it looks hazardously positioned.
T Clark January 10, 2018 at 01:57 #142093
Quoting praxis
Cool frog but it looks hazardously positioned.


I just asked her to sit there for the picture.
BC January 10, 2018 at 03:37 #142112
ART DECO, decidedly beautiful.

Beautiful steam engine
User image

Beautiful radio
User image

Beautiful table lamp
User image
T Clark January 10, 2018 at 03:47 #142115
Quoting Bitter Crank
Beautiful steam engine


Beautiful orange steam engine. Love, love, love, love, love. May I please have it.

Yes, the others are beautiful too.
T Clark January 10, 2018 at 03:50 #142117
I love this thread. I hope you will believe me when I tell you I feel like crying. I am crying. No irony.
Hanover January 10, 2018 at 03:57 #142118
Reply to Bitter Crank I'm disappointed in the USB ports and earphone plugs on the front of the radio. It's faux retro. I like the hum of real vacuum tubes.
BC January 10, 2018 at 06:19 #142147
Reply to Hanover I didn't like that either, but it sort of looks like vintage legit.
BC January 11, 2018 at 03:09 #142446
Reply to Hanover This is better. All knobs, no USB ports, no female phono plugs. Cloth over the speakers. Beautiful.

The RCA Skyscraper model 115.
User image
BC January 11, 2018 at 03:24 #142447
executed by deletion
TimeLine January 11, 2018 at 04:58 #142472

When I had a serious car accident several years ago, my situation worsened physically and mentally months after I actually had it and by lucky chance through the transport commission, I was given the opportunity to fly out to Italy. It was after visiting Cafe Florian, the Dolomite mountains, Florence and San Gimignano that I slowly started healing again and it has taken me a good two years to really bring myself together again. Seeing Caravaggio (in particular St. Jerome writing) who is one of my favourite artists at the Villa Borghese (also Bernini and Titian) and everything about my time in Italy is beautiful to me for that reason.

User image

User image

User image
T Clark January 11, 2018 at 05:26 #142482
Reply to TimeLine

Your photos of Italy made me think about the trip to Europe I made with my brother in 2014. On the trip, after 10 days together, sharing rooms most nights, I found out that, after 67 years of being brothers, it turns out we are also friends. Whoda thunkit.

My favorite photo. Lunch in the Black Forest. I'm not scenery person, but I could feel the Black Forest in by my gut. In Europe, the food looks beautiful and tastes wonderful. Ich mochte einen trockenen Weißwein, Bitte. 45 year-old college German.

User image

The Mosul River in Germany before it becomes the Moselle in France. Vineyards and fortresses. You can feel the history while people go about their business as if it were normal:

User image

Tilted shale deposits on the Meuse River in Germany. Some of the worst fighting of World War I took place in this area.

User image
TheMadFool January 11, 2018 at 05:38 #142489
Noble Dust January 11, 2018 at 05:38 #142490
Reply to T Clark

The Mosel wine region is home to the steepest slopes with vine plantings in the world; some of the worst vineyard accidents occur there.

Please tell me you drank some Mosel riesling while you were there.
T Clark January 11, 2018 at 05:42 #142491
Reply to TheMadFool

Pretty amazing. The most beautiful part is when they are unfurling.
T Clark January 11, 2018 at 05:50 #142493
Quoting Noble Dust
The Mosel wine region is home to the steepest slopes with vine plantings in the world; some of the worst vineyard accidents occur there.

Please tell me you drank some Mosel riesling while you were there.


The slopes were amazing - almost 45%. There were old men 100 feet up the slopes cultivating and picking grapes. They had small monorails to transport people up the slopes and people and grapes down. I didn't take a picture, so here's one I got off the web. Probably not Germany.

User image
T Clark January 11, 2018 at 05:52 #142494
Quoting Noble Dust
Please tell me you drank some Mosel riesling while you were there.


As I said in my post - Ich mochte einen trockenen Weißwein, Bitte. I would like a dry white wine please.
TheMadFool January 11, 2018 at 05:54 #142495
Quoting T Clark
Pretty amazing.


Glad you liked it.(Y)
Noble Dust January 11, 2018 at 06:00 #142497
Reply to T Clark

I'm glad you enjoyed some dry Mosel riesling, but the secret is that German riesling runs the gamut from bone dry to dessert-level sweetness, and, from a good producer, they're all world-class wines. It just takes a little bit of homework to decipher the labels.
T Clark January 11, 2018 at 06:14 #142501
Quoting Noble Dust
I'm glad you enjoyed some dry Mosel riesling, but the secret is that German riesling runs the gamut from bone dry to dessert-level sweetness, and, from a good producer, they're all world-class wines. It just takes a little bit of homework to decipher the labels.


The wine we drank was from the grapes growing right near where we were. No labels. No choices. Just Weiswine - troken or susse (dry or sweet). Dry was not real dry, which is the way I like white wine.
Noble Dust January 11, 2018 at 06:19 #142504
Reply to T Clark

I'm jelly.
Noble Dust January 11, 2018 at 06:29 #142506
Quoting T Clark
Dry was not real dry, which is the way I like white wine.


Ah yes, the beauty of German wine. Trocken is a loose term.
TimeLine January 11, 2018 at 09:29 #142577
Quoting T Clark
Your photos of Italy made me think about the trip to Europe I made with my brother in 2014. On the trip, after 10 days together, sharing rooms most nights, I found out that, after 67 years of being brothers, it turns out we are also friends. Whoda thunkit.


It also took me 10 days in Italy to become friends with me. It is those memorable stories, the relationship between you and the experience that makes something beautiful. The rug you liked, the orange bowl, these are fragments of your existence that I am thankful you are sharing, an image with an essence. I find that abovementioned statement beautiful.

When I was younger, I went on a school excursion to the rainforest and the smell of the wet ferns remains pierced into my senses that till this day I love trekking through rainforest. I loved going on school excursions as a child (and excursions as an adult!); I remember going on one and seeing a giant opal encased in a stone. Till this day, I am entranced by opal gemstones.

User image

User image
Sunshine Sami January 11, 2018 at 10:03 #142610
I wonder how much a role composition plays in the way we view beauty....
Noble Dust January 11, 2018 at 10:09 #142613
Reply to Sunshine Sami

Why not wonder about the role perception plays in the way we view beauty?
TimeLine January 11, 2018 at 10:27 #142638
Reply to TheMadFool What guys do to get the girl :D
TheMadFool January 11, 2018 at 11:07 #142657
Quoting TimeLine
What guys do to get the girl


I know...:D
T Clark January 11, 2018 at 16:30 #142705
Quoting TimeLine
When I was younger, I went on a school excursion to the rainforest and the smell of the wet ferns remains pierced into my senses that till this day I love trekking through rainforest. I loved going on school excursions as a child (and excursions as an adult!); I remember going on one and seeing a giant opal encased in a stone. Till this day, I am entranced by opal gemstones.


My wife and two eldest children went to Europe in the late 1980s to visit my brother and his wife who were working there. We went to Paris, the Netherlands, Belgium, and Luxembourg. The Netherlands is wonderful. A country built by engineers. Civil engineers. I still think about that trip all the time. It's like a bank account. Everything's stored away but right there whenever I want it.

My family went to Rehoboth Beach Delaware on our summer vacations for about 10 years. That's about 45 minutes from the town I grew up in. Atlantic Ocean beach with waves and a boardwalk. French fries, greasy subs, ice cream. Then my kids got older and my wife didn't want to make the 8-hour trip any more, so for the last 6 or 7 we've gone to Cape Cod. Much more quaint than Rehoboth. No boardwalk. Great fried scallops though. No waves at the beach though. What's the point of a beach if you don't get knocked down?

I have all those memories stored. They get jumbled up and mixed together - Which year was that? I think vacations are as much for later as they are for when you're there.
T Clark January 12, 2018 at 05:31 #142899
I hope everyone will be tolerant of what is becoming, if not an obsession, at least a preoccupation for me. As I think people can tell, I find this thread deeply satisfying. I keep thinking of more things I want to hold up and show people. Show myself. This process has made a dramatic change in my understanding of what beauty is. Beauty is signaled by this feeling I get - peace draping itself over my shoulders, a weight, fullness in my chest. No, @Bitter Crank, I'm not having a heart attack.

These are glasses I bought for my daughter as a Christmas present year before last. Now I've bought them for everyone I can think of. When I look at them, I can feel them in my hand, against my teeth and tongue. They're made of very thin glass.

User image
Noble Dust January 12, 2018 at 06:16 #142913
What about music? This is, to me, one of the most beautiful pieces of music I've heard. The combination of logical progression of rhythmic structure plus the mysterious, emotional weight of the harmonies is..

Sunshine Sami January 12, 2018 at 06:27 #142914
Reply to Noble Dust Perhaps because somehow our perception of beauty always seems to be framed, somehow we seem to need a frame.
Noble Dust January 12, 2018 at 06:28 #142915
Reply to Sunshine Sami

What do you mean by framed?
ArguingWAristotleTiff January 12, 2018 at 12:53 #143002
Svínafellsjökull behind Hotel Skaftafel photo by: Sean Parker
User image
praxis January 12, 2018 at 23:37 #143145
T Clark January 13, 2018 at 00:13 #143177
Quoting ArguingWAristotleTiff
Svínafellsjökull behind Hotel Skaftafel photo by: Sean Parker


I went and visited on Google Earth. It's a pretty forbidding place. The photo is beautiful. Did you visit?
ArguingWAristotleTiff January 13, 2018 at 12:27 #143363
Reply to T Clark I love photography both amateur and professional but this man, Sean Parker, takes some of the most amazing pictures of where he goes and also offers small groups to take up there to photograph as well. He says it's a magical place, I can only imagine and go with him in my dreams~
T Clark January 13, 2018 at 16:43 #143398
Between TheMadFool's white peacock and TimeLine's magpie, I realized I have not included any birds. I love loud, raucous, aggressive birds. I have modeled my philosophical demeanor on them. All pictures from the web.

Crow in a tree. Here's what Bob Frost says:

The way a crow shook down on me
A dust of snow from a hemlock tree
Has given my heart a change of mood
And saved some part of a day I had rued.

Yes, I know it's not a hemlock tree.

User image

I remember watching a blue jay swooping and attacking squirrels. I don't know why it was doing it.

User image

I also remember a mockingbird driving a cat crazy by imitating a cat call. It looked like she was just doing it for fun.

User image

Sir2u January 13, 2018 at 20:24 #143491
As someone already posted a train, I will too. This one has very special meaning for me though, it was named after my great grand father.
User image
Cavacava January 13, 2018 at 20:33 #143498
Reply to Sir2u

Choo-Choo 2u?


Sunshine Sami January 14, 2018 at 00:26 #143660
Reply to Noble Dust
Apologies for delayed reply. By framed I mean we perceive beauty as some thing within borders, and by that therefore composed. In other words, we compose a thing of beauty. Some thing seen or heard is plain enough to have borders. I guess a smell might be more challenging, yet the same principle applies. A particular smell of beauty is composed within our brain by filtering out the other smells. Within our brain, we are composing beauty. We convert the chaos of signals received by our brain through composition into beauty. Artists simply (or not so simply) externalize this composing process.
TimeLine January 14, 2018 at 00:54 #143681
Reply to Sir2u Can you explain how that happened?


Sir2u January 14, 2018 at 01:00 #143687
Reply to TimeLine
He was the big boss in the coal gas company it was made for, so the named it after him. I only found out about it just before my dad died so there is not much I know about it except what is on line. When I get rich I might go take a ride on it.
Noble Dust January 14, 2018 at 01:01 #143688
For some reason the title of this thread always makes me think of Michael Bolton's chorus on this song...sorry...

TimeLine January 14, 2018 at 01:04 #143692
Quoting Sir2u
He was the big boss in the coal gas company it was made for, so the named it after him. I only found out about it just before my dad died so there is not much I know about it except what is on line. When I get rich I might go take a ride on it.


Do you know much else about him, about the coal gas company itself, his role, influence or was everything thrown on you when your father was unwell? And why do you need to be rich?
T Clark January 14, 2018 at 01:08 #143694
Quoting Noble Dust
For some reason the title of this thread always makes me think of Michael Bolton's chorus on this song...sorry...


Don't make me come down there. Do not mention that name in relation to this discussion!! I showed you my orange rug!!!
Sir2u January 14, 2018 at 01:12 #143696
Quoting TimeLine
Do you know much else about him, about the coal gas company itself, his role, influence or was everything thrown on you when your father was unwell?


A distant cousin of my fathers has dug up most of the family history as far back as about 1700. He has a local Yorkshire bigwig and politician. He was even the mayor in the city for a while.

There is more about the machine here http://www.south-tynedale-railway.org.uk/locomotives-stock/

Quoting TimeLine
And why do you need to be rich?


Traveling is expensive and I do not want to go back to England without having plenty of money to spend. That probably means I will never get to see it.
TimeLine January 14, 2018 at 01:14 #143697
I went wedding dress shopping with my friend yesterday (who is getting married) and she asked me to try on a dress I really liked because she thinks that she will lose enough weight over the coming months to be my size. I am not often gobsmacked, but I thought the dress was incredibly beautiful.

User image

Sir2u January 14, 2018 at 01:14 #143698
Quoting T Clark
Don't make me come down there. I showed you my orange rug!!!


Is it a magic flying rug? I want a ride too.
Sir2u January 14, 2018 at 01:15 #143701
Reply to TimeLine Is that you you wearing it?
TimeLine January 14, 2018 at 01:16 #143703
Reply to Sir2u Nope. Beautiful dress thought, right?
Sir2u January 14, 2018 at 01:17 #143704
Noble Dust January 14, 2018 at 01:23 #143708
Reply to T Clark

But this forum is full of so many "incredible thoughts"...
T Clark January 14, 2018 at 01:26 #143711
Quoting Sir2u
Is that you you wearing it?


It is well known that TimeLine looks exactly like Hermione Granger when she was 11.
T Clark January 14, 2018 at 01:27 #143713
Quoting TimeLine
Nope. Beautiful dress thought, right?


You are so coy.
Sir2u January 14, 2018 at 01:28 #143714
Reply to T Clark Maybe I can wait a few more years then. X-)
T Clark January 14, 2018 at 01:45 #143729
Quoting T Clark
Is that you you wearing it? — Sir2u
It is well known that TimeLine looks exactly like Hermione Granger when she was 11.


User image
Sir2u January 14, 2018 at 01:55 #143735
Reply to T Clark But she did turn out alright didn't she?
TimeLine January 14, 2018 at 02:03 #143738
Reply to Sir2u Reply to T Clark I still have the exact same look.
Sir2u January 14, 2018 at 02:07 #143740
Quoting TimeLine
I still have the exact same look.


Bewitching?
T Clark January 14, 2018 at 02:08 #143742
Quoting TimeLine
I still have the exact same look.


Those are the eyes I see whenever you loose your wrath on me.
TimeLine January 14, 2018 at 11:57 #143865
Quoting T Clark
Those are the eyes I see whenever you loose your wrath on me.


Correct approach.
TimeLine January 15, 2018 at 10:56 #144128
My dream home; a little cottage with a yellow door.

User image

And a little backyard greenhouse where I can grow flowers. Gosh, I hate being poor.

User image
Sir2u January 15, 2018 at 12:01 #144132
Quoting TimeLine
Gosh, I hate being poor.


Do not worry, you are in the very best of company.
T Clark January 15, 2018 at 18:04 #144191
I had been trying to think of graphic art which moved me as much as some of the other beautiful things that I've shown in this discussion, but I couldn't think of any. Then I remembered these. They're both from caves in France. The first is about 30,000 years old, the second 15,000 to 20,000 years old. There are older ones from Indonesia that are at least 40,000 years old.

Can you imagine what it took to paint one of these for the first time. The people who first drew these were geniuses; da Vinci, Gutenberg, Morse, Bell, Marconi, Edison, Turing, Jobs all rolled into one.

User image

User image
T Clark January 15, 2018 at 18:09 #144192
Quoting TimeLine
My dream home; a little cottage with a yellow door.


For me, your yellow door brings it all back to the beginning.

User image

ArguingWAristotleTiff January 16, 2018 at 11:39 #144509
User image
Prince "Bailey" Von Riesig
T Clark January 16, 2018 at 14:49 #144556
Reply to ArguingWAristotleTiff

I can hear it - here Prince "Bailey" Von Riesig, here boy. Sit Prince "Bailey" Von Riesig.

Do you have to make the quote signs when you call him.

I guess I shouldn't be discourteous to royalty.
charleton January 16, 2018 at 17:21 #144597
No botox; no surgery; no enhancement; just lips of perfection.


User image
praxis January 16, 2018 at 20:01 #144623
The eyebrows look a bit oddly artificial.
T Clark January 20, 2018 at 04:13 #145597
User image
ArguingWAristotleTiff January 20, 2018 at 12:57 #145653
Reply to T Clark Unity March?
T Clark January 20, 2018 at 13:51 #145663
Yes. With my daughter.
ArguingWAristotleTiff January 20, 2018 at 14:09 #145669
Quoting T Clark
Yes. With my daughter.

What an awesome event to attend together!
And btw you are a very good looking gentleman. Don't sell yourself short! ;)

T Clark January 20, 2018 at 16:07 #145686
Reply to ArguingWAristotleTiff

I just realized today is the anniversary of the march.

And thank you. She wanted to get the Capitol in the photo, even if it meant only getting half of me.
celebritydiscodave January 20, 2018 at 19:26 #145722
Reply to ArguingWAristotleTiff

Not very interesting philosophically however as beauty can be found in almost anything. Attractive is a more interesting term philosophically speaking. Beauty does n`t exist, it is a perception, however, I`d argue that attractive does exist. It is not an important commodity, perhaps, but I believe that it does at least objectively exist.
T Clark January 20, 2018 at 20:09 #145731
Quoting celebritydiscodave
Not very interesting philosophically however as beauty can be found in almost anything. Attractive is a more interesting term philosophically speaking. Beauty does n`t exist, it is a perception, however, I`d argue that attractive does exist. It is not an important commodity, perhaps, but I believe that it does at least objectively exist.


I disagree. If you've read all the posts in this thread, you can see it has had a strong effect on me. It's clarified what the word "beautiful" means. I hadn't really thought about it much until I began the discussion and started paying attention to the things I find beautiful. What I found is, for me, beauty reflects something that is deeply part of who I am. I look over the pictures I posted and each gives me the same sense of peace. A feeling of being home. What could be more philosophical than that.

I don't think anything has affected me more intellectually and emotionally since I began on the forum. That's not what I expected when I started the thread. I just thought it would be fun. And it has been.

Which isn't to say that a discussion of attractiveness wouldn't be interesting. Just to point out though, this is intended as a discussion where people show us things they think are beautiful, not discuss beauty and related ideas.
BC January 21, 2018 at 02:04 #145807
Quoting Noble Dust
Old book covers:


I like a good dust cover. What would you say the 'golden age' of book covers was? 1950s? 1960s?
Hanover January 21, 2018 at 05:04 #145827
User image

An instagram posting from a former friend or maybe way more than that. Real life American beauty:

Noble Dust January 21, 2018 at 05:12 #145829
Reply to Bitter Crank

I'm no expert, but the ones I posted are my favorites, and they're 60's/70's. The covers to the Lord of the Rings edition that I posted in that photo are probably my favorite book covers of all time. Those covers fueled my imagination as a kid long before my parents actually read the books to me for the first time. They come in a box set, and the box is equally amazing. I recently purchased my own copy on abebooks, but The Fellowship is already falling apart. I need to cough up the big bucks on a set that's in great condition.
TimeLine January 21, 2018 at 07:27 #145847
Reply to T Clark She really is beautiful.

Summit of Mauna Kea. Despite the difficulties with the climb and my inability to acclimatise properly to the high altitude, reaching it was just phenomenal. I also went to see the volcanoes and trekked back at dusk and the crunching sounds of my feet on the surface of the lava at night with the stars above and the milky way in a different position to what I see here in Australia actually gave me goosebumps.

These are mine.

User image

User image


celebritydiscodave January 21, 2018 at 13:47 #145876
So beauty no longer exists just in the eye of the beholder then, so these pictures prove substantively and beyond any reasonable doubt that beauty has an independent existence? Surely, they are just pictures, nothing to do with philosophy whatsoever. In any event, beauty suggests beyond attractive, (some of these pictures may perhaps be considered universally/philosophically attractive), to nature, it comprises nature, and all of those pictures which are inanimate definitely do n`t possess a transmitting of inner beauty facet. It is a stretch to consider any life form which is not human as being universally/philosophically beautiful because other than perhaps apes and dogs they do n`t tend to this radiating out of an inner attractive character, come nature. .Beauty of nature is possible to define, beauty of image is less so, and leaves it to chance as to whether that perceived beauty actually exists. These are incredible pictures though.
T Clark January 21, 2018 at 18:20 #145920
Quoting celebritydiscodave
So beauty no longer exists just in the eye of the beholder then, so these pictures prove substantively and beyond any reasonable doubt that beauty has an independent existence? Surely, they are just pictures, nothing to do with philosophy whatsoever. In any event, beauty suggests beyond attractive, (some of these pictures may perhaps be considered universally/philosophically attractive), to nature, it comprises nature, and all of those pictures which are inanimate definitely do n`t possess a transmitting of inner beauty facet. It is a stretch to consider any life form which is not human as being universally/philosophically beautiful because other than perhaps apes and dogs they do n`t tend to this radiating out of an inner attractive character, come nature. .Beauty of nature is possible to define, beauty of image is less so, and leaves it to chance as to whether that perceived beauty actually exists. These are incredible pictures though.


I disagree. I'd be happy to talk about it. Why don't you open a new discussion.
ArguingWAristotleTiff January 21, 2018 at 18:40 #145924
Reply to celebritydiscodave You too are a beautiful person. (L)
BC January 21, 2018 at 18:43 #145925
Reply to ArguingWAristotleTiff Let's not go overboard, here.
BC January 21, 2018 at 18:50 #145929
Reply to celebritydiscodave You seem to be on a "this isn't philosophy" kick. I agree with T Clark, you should start a thread on the issue of "what is not philosophy". Is "what is not philosophy" philosophy? Doesn't saying something is "not philosophical" make it a philosophical matter, like "What is" and "What is not"?

Sir2u January 22, 2018 at 00:38 #145990
Here's proof that we are all beautiful.

BC January 22, 2018 at 00:59 #145996
So, he was beautiful. So, so beautiful.

XanderTheGrey January 22, 2018 at 22:30 #146240



Mt. Lagazuoi, Italy

User image


Boulder, Co.
User image



Mt. Lemmon, Tuscon, Az.

User image
XanderTheGrey January 23, 2018 at 00:35 #146289
User image

User image

User image


User image
T Clark January 23, 2018 at 03:14 #146336
Reply to XanderTheGrey

I love these photos, are they yours. There is something about rock stratigraphy that moves me. It's one of the reasons I love the Inca structures I showed in my first post on this thread so much. They feel as if they were laid down in layers over millions of years.
Baden January 23, 2018 at 05:02 #146364
Hanover January 23, 2018 at 05:14 #146365
Reply to Baden Sinead O'Connoresque.
Baden January 23, 2018 at 07:34 #146393
I'm PMing answers to off-topic posts and then deleting them. The discussion is about beautiful things. Please carry on.
Noble Dust January 23, 2018 at 07:35 #146394
Quoting Baden
The discussion is about beautiful things. Please carry on.


Oh really? >:O
Akanthinos January 23, 2018 at 08:01 #146402
Jeez, just make more job for him, will ya. :P

I find that animals hold the most beauty for me. Mostly mammals. The grace and strenght of movement exhibited when higher quadrupeds enter in motion is my personal definition of the sublime.

User image

User image
Noble Dust January 23, 2018 at 08:07 #146404
Quoting Akanthinos
Jeez, just make more job for him, will ya


For who?
Shawn January 23, 2018 at 10:12 #146417
One of the most beautiful things that I hold dear is Kubrick films.
T Clark January 23, 2018 at 16:11 #146499
Quoting Akanthinos
I find that animals hold the most beauty for me. Mostly mammals. The grace and strenght of movement exhibited when higher quadrupeds enter in motion is my personal definition of the sublime.


I'm not really an animal person, but standing next to a large mammal, a horse or cow, and putting my hand on their flank. Feeling the warmth, muscles, size. Life. Like mine but separate and different. That is a feeling of beauty for me. It makes me feel a part of the world.
ArguingWAristotleTiff January 24, 2018 at 12:56 #146784
@Akanthinos These are for you. This was my horse Dasher whom I loved dearly and broke my back with but he is living a great life in Northern Arizona. Dasher was a true athlete.
User image
Amazing animals in their natural glory. We had just finished a work out and were doing exactly what every animal does after a good bath. They TOTAL it by rolling in sand, dust, dirt, whatever they can find.
[url=https://postimg.org/image/qzeqisflx/]User image
One more of Dasher because of the Beast he is and my youngest Indian who is now attending an Aeronautical University and kicking ass at it.
[url=https://postimg.org/image/x2wb27dg5/]User image
Hanover January 24, 2018 at 18:26 #146815
Reply to ArguingWAristotleTiff Dasher is a reindeer, not a horse. A good name for a horse would be Magic or Fred, although Fred is already taken as my dog's name. I'd name that horse Snowflake, Spot, or maybe Big Red. Those names make more sense than giving it a reindeer name.
Akanthinos January 24, 2018 at 20:22 #146829
Quoting ArguingWAristotleTiff
These are for you. This was my horse Dasher whom I loved dearly and broke my back with but he is living a great life in Northern Arizona. Dasher was a true athlete.


He's glorious. I have to admit, horses are one of the "higher mammals" that leaves me a bit like a cold fish. They are absolutely beautiful beasts, but I can't be near one and not feel like he is one moment away from caving my skull in.

I guess I might have been on the receiving end of too many cavalry charges in my previous lifes.

Also, quite obviously : women-so-gorgeous-they-appear-almost-unreal.

User image

User image

mcdoodle January 25, 2018 at 14:49 #146949
Quoting Posty McPostface
One of the most beautiful things that I hold dear is Kubrick films.


I think my present-day favourites in the movie genre are Haneke films. I recently saw 'Happy End' which naturally doesn't have such an eponymous finale. His movies do not follow the structure most Hollywood movies have, they unfold elegantly and at their own pace. Happy End closes on Jean-Louis Trintignant as a senile old man, which makes a rather beautiful arc in my mind, since the first French movie I remember loving was Un homme et une femme, starring Trintignant as a widowed young man. I saw it at the Academy 1 on Oxford Street in London in the mid-60's. (Both Happy End and Homme/Femme are unafraid of dealing with death, which is much on my mind lately owing to recent bereavements)

Perhaps this post is an oblique way of saying - sometimes life seems to show you, well me anyway, a beautiful shape all of its own, just for you/me - I hope this isn't cognitive distortion but an aesthetic sense :)
TimeLine January 26, 2018 at 01:32 #147020
Reply to Akanthinos Why just women and not men? I think women are beautiful, despite being a woman. Are you simply compelled instinctually? Funny that they happen to be celebrities. Nevertheless, I think TClark's daughter is very beautiful.

When you actually attempt to grow flowers from a seed or bulb and go through the process of germination until this, learning patience and protectiveness, it is the greatest feeling. I think the beauty in nature is this very process and it is a privilege to be able to work through the process directly.

My Stargazer Lily. The perfume is just the best.

User image





Sir2u January 26, 2018 at 02:17 #147026
Quoting Akanthinos
women-so-gorgeous-they-appear-almost-unreal.


Some of them actually are. Hate tats all over the place like that, ruins the rest of her.
TimeLine January 26, 2018 at 02:42 #147029
Reply to Sir2u You are quite the opposite of this thread right now.
Sir2u January 26, 2018 at 02:50 #147030
Quoting TimeLine
You are quite the opposite of this thread right now.


If beauty is in the eye of the beholder, all I need is a mirror to be happy.

What's your story?
TimeLine January 26, 2018 at 03:05 #147033
Quoting Sir2u
If beauty is in the eye of the beholder, all I need is a mirror to be happy.


That's pretty fucked up. :-!

j/k.. my story? Living in the moment. I am at the park, on a hot day, that happens to be a public holiday, listening to the sounds of people and kids, reading, writing on my computer and feeling completely relaxed. I think life is pretty beautiful right now.
Sir2u January 26, 2018 at 03:22 #147036
Quoting TimeLine
That's pretty fucked up.


Sure sign of jealousy there. X-)
BC January 26, 2018 at 04:13 #147043
Reply to TimeLine You call that remarkable?
User image
T Clark January 26, 2018 at 05:40 #147050
Have I mentioned how much I love this thread? I probably have. Every time I look it I want to cry.
TimeLine January 26, 2018 at 07:49 #147057
Reply to Bitter Crank My lilies in that picture were hand-reared and they have both spectacular colours and smells. Why they are beautiful to me is because of this connection I had through them with nature, I actually participated in the process. Very Tao. What is that species by the way?

I am trying to understand the biology of how to create a hybrid. I am planning on doing a plant breeding course; how transgenic flowers combine with my anti-GMO stance is going to be interesting and I am really eager to see whether genetic manipulation and plant breeding techniques can be achieved naturally. My neighbour showed me this amazing grafting technique where she was able to graft an eggplant and a tomato plant together.

This is wild Lily of the Valley. So subtle, beautiful, and smell wonderful. They are also poisonous, the floral femme fatale.

User image
Hanover January 26, 2018 at 14:34 #147090
Reply to Bitter Crank That's a weird looking flower. It looks like it has some evergreen needles on it, but then the flower. It'd probably be best if you stomped the shit out of it. It's fucked up and I don't understand it.
ArguingWAristotleTiff January 26, 2018 at 14:43 #147091
@Bitter Crank Hummingbirds Glory is what I see~ Beauty attracts beauty~
@TimeLine I have done some grafting with various flowers, some are easier than others. Orchids are one of my favorites~
Hanover January 26, 2018 at 14:47 #147093
User image
Nascent beauty.
ArguingWAristotleTiff January 26, 2018 at 14:51 #147095
@Hanover
Nuh huh, if that was you, you would have a Swcheppe hair do. Are you sure that isn't a young picture of Fred?
Hanover January 26, 2018 at 15:26 #147101
Reply to ArguingWAristotleTiff Yep, Hanover circa 1966.
BC January 26, 2018 at 18:51 #147160
Reply to TimeLine For an interesting genetic experience, try this at home: try breeding ever darker petunias. At some point, your two very dark, dark parents will produce a white off-spring. I don't remember what the genetic mechanism was, but something along the lines of "the plant rejected the final attempt and cut the color off altogether".

I don't know what the name of the lily is. I came across it on Tumblr, and thought at first it was some sort of plastic thing, because it looked so unreal. Apparently it is a real plant, Polyethylene pamalota.
Akanthinos January 26, 2018 at 19:54 #147180
Quoting Sir2u
Some of them actually are. Hate tats all over the place like that, ruins the rest of her.


I don't get the negative obsession with tattoes. Stephanie Cornelliusen is a woman of sublime grace and beauty, someone who actually causes me existential pain to look at, and you are going to tell me this is all ruined because of a few lines of text on her back and arms?

Quoting TimeLine
Why just women and not men?


I went with what makes me experience beauty in the most striking manner, so most likely my posting women before, let's say, old large librairies would have to do with the instinctual wiring that comes with mate selection aesthetics.

Men can be beautiful too, but they simply do not strike me as such like a beautiful woman does.

Quoting TimeLine
Funny that they happen to be celebrities.


That's only incidental, it's easier and a lot less creep to find and post pictures of celebs already online than it is to secretly take a picture of the beautiful women I met everywhere all day.
NobleDeep January 26, 2018 at 22:56 #147207
I find Dobermans to be amongst the most impressive specimens of fitness, discipline, and excellence.

User image

User image


User image

User image

User image
ArguingWAristotleTiff January 27, 2018 at 14:09 #147340
@NobleDeep I love Dobermans. Such loyal stoic animals that like the Rottweiler, they would fight to the death to keep you safe~ (L)
TimeLine January 28, 2018 at 03:25 #147481
Quoting Bitter Crank
For an interesting genetic experience, try this at home: try breeding ever darker petunias. At some point, your two very dark, dark parents will produce a white off-spring. I don't remember what the genetic mechanism was, but something along the lines of "the plant rejected the final attempt and cut the color off altogether".


Interesting, but I actually have a fondness for pastel colours, particularly pink that lightly streams though white with a gentle, fresh scent - hence peonies - along with lilies and I am even more impressed when such perfection exists in the wild. Even when I wear pink, people are always drawn to me as though the colour just works for me.

Like pastel pink cherry blossoms.
User image

Quoting Akanthinos
Men can be beautiful too, but they simply do not strike me as such like a beautiful woman does.


I think this is the point, about whether this 'striking' feeling enables something to be beautiful or whether you are merely projecting your instinctual desires to something fleeting. Rosa Parks is beautiful because she represents something more than just this fleeting appearance, but that honour, courage, compassion elevate her to something more than just our desires, to something eternal.
Hanover January 28, 2018 at 16:32 #147625
Quoting Bitter Crank
Of course men can be beautiful.
https://thephilosophyforum.com/discussion/comment/147591
ArguingWAristotleTiff February 01, 2018 at 13:08 #148773
Last nights' Super Blue Blood Moon from the university my son is attending. [url=https://postimg.org/image/z4okfmp51/]User image
Shawn February 06, 2018 at 10:03 #150489
The intro to Blade Runner 2049 is something marvelous.

Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 05:13 #153125
Does a bird know it's beautiful?

User image
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 05:22 #153130
[And what happend to Reply to T Clark ?]
BC February 15, 2018 at 05:23 #153131
Reply to Noble Dust I agree completely.

Reply to Hanover

Whoever decided that those three guys should go out on the runway looking like that should be taken away and not be heard of again.
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 05:24 #153132
Reply to Bitter Crank

I agree completely.
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 05:29 #153134
Reply to Posty McPostface

I agree that the images are beautiful, and the music actually contributes more to the emotional mood than the visuals do. It's a great opening sequence, and the following sequence [hide="Reveal"]where he retires the farming replicant[/hide] is incredibly done. Overall, though, the movie I thought was a let down; disappointing ending, and just a cash-cow milking of the original, which was a cash-cow milking of the PKD novel of another name.
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 05:31 #153135
Reply to Bitter Crank

Btw, what do you agree about? Do you think the bird knows that it's beautiful, or does it not know?
René Descartes February 15, 2018 at 05:35 #153138

[Delete] @Baden
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 05:37 #153140
Reply to René Descartes

If that was a solid joke I'd laugh along, but for real; does the bird know it's beautiful?
René Descartes February 15, 2018 at 05:51 #153143
[Delete] @Baden
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 05:53 #153144
Reply to René Descartes

Even further; how would a bird even know about "beauty"?
René Descartes February 15, 2018 at 05:56 #153145
[Delete] @Baden
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 05:58 #153146
René Descartes February 15, 2018 at 05:59 #153147
[Delete] @Baden
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 06:01 #153148
Reply to René Descartes

"Belief" and "beauty" suggest abstraction. There's no reason to suppose animals possess these things (thus abstraction); I guess they'd be able to paint cave paintings or construct obelisks otherwise.
René Descartes February 15, 2018 at 06:03 #153149
[Delete] @Baden
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 06:06 #153150
Reply to René Descartes

Maybe; but the nest serves a utilitarian purpose, or at least it serves our conception of what a utilitarian purpose would be for a bird. But even if the bird does derive, somehow, a metaphysical sense of aesthetics from the nest, how do we translate that? Does the bird know of it's own beauty, for instance, in the way that we know of it's beauty? The bird knows nothing of it's National-Geographic-potential beauty.
René Descartes February 15, 2018 at 06:11 #153153
[Delete] @Baden
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 06:14 #153154
Reply to René Descartes

The point I try to make is that the bird isn't aware of the beauty that we see in the bird. We see something that is categorically not apprehensible to the bird. We see something more beautiful in the bird than the bird's experience of beauty for itself. And, for myself, I like to ask whether this same principle applies to us humans. Maybe not. Maybe so.
René Descartes February 15, 2018 at 06:24 #153155
[Delete] @Baden
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 06:29 #153157
Quoting René Descartes
maybe other creatures think of us as uglier than we think of ourselves. For example, cockroaches find humans so disgusting they run away and if they are touched by humans they wash themselves.


That seems fanciful; I'm taking a simple experience of the beauty of a bird, and then magnifying it one "level" higher in my analogy; primitive philosophy, maybe, but simple. Your suggestion here just seems to be a joke.

Quoting René Descartes
how are you sure that
We see something more beautiful in the bird than the bird's experience of beauty for itself.
— Noble Dust


Because the bird doesn't see itself within the complex aesthetic system within which we see it.
René Descartes February 15, 2018 at 06:30 #153158
[Delete] @Baden
Noble Dust February 15, 2018 at 06:35 #153159
Reply to René Descartes

Simple observation. When I see a beautiful bird, my experience of beauty is formed by all my previous, human experiences of beauty; experiences of the beauty of birds, of music, of nature, of the opposite (or same) sex, or symmetry...these experiences of beauty are human; they aren't "birdian"; at the most, we could imagine a bird seeing a member of it's opposite sex (for pro-creation), or it's children, or nature itself as being "beautiful"; but this pales in comparison to the depth and complexity of beauty that we experience as people.

And on top of that, there's a self-evident hierarchy of beauty; the bird sees its's beautiful mate, we see the beautiful bird (and the beautiful wood, or weather, etc), and then, there's the possibility that a higher form of conciousness sees the beauty in us which we cannot see.
ArguingWAristotleTiff February 15, 2018 at 12:16 #153259
Quoting Noble Dust
Does a bird know it's beautiful?


This bird is not just beautiful but it is a bad ass for choosing it's lunch. :D
Shawn February 15, 2018 at 12:25 #153261
Quoting Noble Dust
I agree that the images are beautiful, and the music actually contributes more to the emotional mood than the visuals do. It's a great opening sequence, and the following sequence where he retires the farming replicant is incredibly done. Overall, though, the movie I thought was a let down; disappointing ending, and just a cash-cow milking of the original, which was a cash-cow milking of the PKD novel of another name.


Well, I would have to disagree with calling Blade Runner 2049 a cash cow. The director, Denis Villeneuve, made it abundantly clear that the movie wasn't made to make money. Besides the original Blade Runner was a box office flop too. Many people were spellbound with the sequel, by which I mean that it was worthy of a follow up on the original. I know I loved it at least.
BC February 15, 2018 at 13:36 #153274
Reply to Noble Dust I was agreeing with "deleted".
T Clark February 16, 2018 at 02:56 #153453
Reply to NobleDeep

I am not a big dog person, but these are really beautiful. Great photography too.
T Clark February 16, 2018 at 02:58 #153454
Reply to Noble Dust

I wonder if this is the most beautiful thing I've ever seen. A wren?
Noble Dust February 16, 2018 at 03:17 #153456
Reply to T Clark

I'm not sure. Btw, I like how your participation on the forum culminated with this thread; from philosophical enquiry to pure beauty.
T Clark February 16, 2018 at 03:19 #153457
Reply to Noble Dust

This thread has meant more to me than I can say. I don't even know why. It goes straight to my heart.
Noble Dust February 16, 2018 at 03:21 #153458
Reply to T Clark

(Y) your enthusiasm for beauty is inspiring.
Noble Dust February 16, 2018 at 07:20 #153511
Quoting Posty McPostface
Well, I would have to disagree with calling Blade Runner 2049 a cash cow. The director, Denis Villeneuve, made it abundantly clear that the movie wasn't made to make money. Besides the original Blade Runner was a box office flop too. Many people were spellbound with the sequel, by which I mean that it was worthy of a follow up on the original. I know I loved it at least.


Sure, the original was not a cash cow; but it turned into a cult classic. So, to make a sequel to a cult classic that is not based on any material from the author (vs. the original being based on Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?), is clearly a cash-in on a cult classic; a cash cow. And sure, the director (not the writers, producers, or, most importantly, exec producers) said that it's not about the money; it probably wasn't about the money for him; he was probably thrilled to make the movie. That doesn't mean it wasn't a cash cow.

If you loved the movie, more power to you. Visually, and mood-wise (the soundtrack), I thought it was well done. But the plot was severely lacking. I didn't read it as a great film.
Noble Dust February 16, 2018 at 07:21 #153512
Noble Dust February 16, 2018 at 07:21 #153513
Reply to ArguingWAristotleTiff

Sometimes lunch chooses you...especially when you're a bird...
Shawn February 16, 2018 at 07:45 #153517
Reply to Noble Dust

Yeah, but let's be realistic, it was a Hollywood movie.
Noble Dust February 16, 2018 at 07:46 #153518
Reply to Posty McPostface

Fair. But I've seen plenty of other Hollywood movies with better plots.
Kenshin March 25, 2018 at 16:38 #166444
User image
ArguingWAristotleTiff March 25, 2018 at 16:44 #166446
CuddlyHedgehog March 25, 2018 at 17:06 #166458
User image

Just a personal portrait..
ArguingWAristotleTiff March 25, 2018 at 17:07 #166460
Reply to CuddlyHedgehog See how easy it is to figure out the gender of a member? :halo: By the way, I adore peach!
CuddlyHedgehog March 25, 2018 at 17:08 #166461
T Clark March 25, 2018 at 17:12 #166463
Quoting CuddlyHedgehog
Just a personal portrait..


Torturing a hedgehog - I'm going to have to report you.
CuddlyHedgehog March 25, 2018 at 17:12 #166464
Reply to T Clark what are you talking about? It’s me!
T Clark March 26, 2018 at 20:28 #166691
Well, since someone re-opened this thread, I get a chance to put something else in. I can't believe I forgot these first time around.

User image

User image

Always rayon. Never cotton.
ArguingWAristotleTiff March 26, 2018 at 20:48 #166704
Reply to T Clark Rayon hangs so much better!
I love the colors of the bottom shirt!
T Clark March 26, 2018 at 21:56 #166719
Quoting ArguingWAristotleTiff
Rayon hangs so much better!
I love the colors of the bottom shirt!


I don't want to shock you, but I am not a fashionable person. Aloha shirts are the one place I allow color into my wardrobe. I used to wear them a lot. Now, not so much.

Yes. I love the feel of rayon.
BC March 27, 2018 at 05:00 #166771
Quoting T Clark
I don't want to shock you, but I am not a fashionable person.


Not to worry. Nobody who saw you in the aloha shirts thought that you were. Just joking, sarcastically, as is my wont.

Now, the second shirt reminds me of a popular style of wallpaper from the art nouveau / art deco period late 19th century, early 20th to the 1930s). The ground was black, and the figures were quite bright--think of things and colors that go into salad--carrot, red bell pepper, radicchio, radish, lettuce... Not that carrots would be the figure, necessarily. Or the figures were muted bright colors, like your rayon shirt.

It would be used in stair wells, bath rooms, hallways -- where it wouldn't overwhelm one.

Actually, I have had some shirts sort of like yours that I liked a lot. And I would definitely wear the rayon shirt. A guy at a party wearing a shirt very much like the rayon item said that it was his hot weather shirt, because he could sweat in it and it didn't show.

I like to coordinate color, like a bright red shirt, black pants, black shoes, and bright red socks -- but it doesn't add up to being fashionable. I like brightly colored clothing -- not all the time, just fairly often.

User image
CuddlyHedgehog March 27, 2018 at 12:05 #166823
Reply to Bitter Crank how terribly interesting
BC March 27, 2018 at 15:01 #166846
Quoting CuddlyHedgehog
how terribly interesting


Touché.
T Clark March 27, 2018 at 15:30 #166851
Quoting Bitter Crank
Not to worry. Nobody who saw you in the aloha shirts thought that you were. Just joking, sarcastically, as is my wont.


I'm shocked, shocked, that you would be sarcastic.
Ying March 28, 2018 at 22:16 #167353
Ying March 29, 2018 at 01:01 #167376
"Et in Arcadia ego" by Poussin:
User image

"Cardsharps" by Caravaggio:
User image

"Moses" by Michelangelo:
User image

Ceiling by Salvador Dali, located in his museum. Not sure what it's called:
User image
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 02, 2018 at 00:05 #168714
Mother Natures Moods
[url=https://postimages.org/]User image
T Clark April 02, 2018 at 00:10 #168719
Quoting ArguingWAristotleTiff
Mother Natures Moods


That's really amazing. I interpret it differently. She soothes us with the rainbow, then blasts us with the lightening!! Take that lowly human!! Or maybe it's just beautiful.
BC April 11, 2018 at 05:28 #171031
User image

Fort Peck Dam, picture taken by Margaret Bourke-White, 1936. MBW specialized in industrial photography and found great beauty in the built world.
BC April 11, 2018 at 05:32 #171033
Here is one of the most horrifying pictures, Margaret Bourke-White: Her sitting out on this Chrysler Bldg. gargoyle...ready to be blown off and plummet to the street far below...

User image
BC April 11, 2018 at 05:38 #171037
The George Washington Bridge -- under construction, I think... Margaret, again.

User image
T Clark April 11, 2018 at 22:34 #171200
Quoting Bitter Crank
Here is one of the most horrifying pictures, Margaret Bourke-White: Her sitting out on this Chrysler Bldg. gargoyle...ready to be blown off and plummet to the street far below...


In my job as an engineer, I would be forced to bring her in off the eagle until she put on a harness and lanyard in accordance with Occupational Safety and Health Administration regulations.

One thing I got out of this discussion and the Beautiful Structures one is how much of what I think is beautiful is tied up in structures like these. How important it is for people to design and build beautiful buildings, bridges, dams.... They are so public and have the ability to shape how people see their physical and social worlds.
BC April 12, 2018 at 01:11 #171217
Quoting T Clark
They are so public and have the ability to shape how people see their physical and social worlds.


Exactly. And the opposite is true too--neighborhoods of ticky-tacky dreck with too much traffic, dirt, and dilapidation, where decay is slithering in around the edges. Sinks. Places where one feels an urge to let loose a big berserker caterpillar to devastate block after block -- just chewing its way through the architectural manure pile.
Hanover April 12, 2018 at 01:33 #171220
I Googled "The most beautiful pictures in the world" (https://www.google.com/search?q=the+most+beautiful+pictures+in+the+world&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj_lJOyyrPaAhVnQt8KHb1WDRwQsAQIJg&biw=1366&bih=651) just to put an end to this discussion. You can see the results here.

It appears that the common elements are: (1) nature, (2) vivid colors, especially greens and purples, and (3) geometric designs. The colors and shapes seem to suggest some divine purpose. That's my take. Anyway, my goal is to create an algorithm that can generate beautiful images so that we can once and for all mechanize creativity and eliminate the final vestiges of humanity.
Baden April 12, 2018 at 06:10 #171253
Quoting Hanover
It appears that the common elements are:


...that they are horrible, over-processed crap.

(There is literally not one passable picture on that whole page.)




Hanover April 12, 2018 at 10:12 #171299
Baden April 12, 2018 at 10:22 #171302
Reply to Hanover

Phillystine!! If everyone doesn't hate your art, it's no good. I rest assured in my obscure unpopularity.
T Clark April 12, 2018 at 14:01 #171353
Quoting Baden
I rest assured in my obscure unpopularity.


Don't sell yourself short, your unpopularity is not obscure at all.
Baden April 12, 2018 at 16:29 #171385
Reply to T Clark

Thanks!... :grimace:
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 16, 2018 at 23:12 #172394
Antelope Slot Canyon, Page AZ User image
XTG April 17, 2018 at 00:24 #172405
User image

User image


User image


User image


User image

T Clark April 17, 2018 at 00:38 #172409
Quoting ArguingWAristotleTiff
Antelope Slot Canyon, Page AZ


Those canyons scare the crap out of me. One little storm miles away and you're dead. They are beautiful though.
T Clark April 17, 2018 at 00:41 #172410
Reply to XTG

I'm more of a Chutes and Ladders or Candyland player. I did recently beat a 7 year old at checkers.
XTG April 17, 2018 at 00:54 #172412
Quoting T Clark
I'm more of a Chutes and Ladders or Candyland player. I did recently beat a 7 year old at checkers.


I think I’d rather eat shit & die...

But I applaud you, you're a nice father.
TimeLine April 17, 2018 at 04:23 #172455
I got an email today from my manager allowing me to work from home two days a week, so now I can finally fill my days "working" designing objects around the house. I love sanding down wood and painting and making things look pretty, and despite not having my own place, i'm currently searching for rental properties just for me and far far away from where I am now so I can start fresh and fill it up with my handmade stuff.

Love the Scandinavian Farmhouse look ever since living in Denmark, but adding hints of Bohemian and Modern elements. I love quirky but within the boundaries of sophistication, as in, it need to be breathable and open, but I am not shy of colours. I'm not at home to take some pics, but this is what I am. Everyone that sees my style always thinks it is beautiful.

If only I had my own house!!!! :cry:

User image

User image

User image











ArguingWAristotleTiff April 17, 2018 at 12:26 #172506
Quoting T Clark
Those canyons scare the crap out of me. One little storm miles away and you're dead. They are beautiful though.


You are a very observant person. I personally could hike that Canyon, which is one of the easiest hikes but I am claustrophobic and I see a lack of Oxygen, so no for me. I am a strong swimmer and I have thought about what I would do if caught in a Flash Flood through the canyon and I think my best bet for survival is to tread water and let the water level rise and allow the current to carry me out.
Then again, those who have lost their lives in the flash floods, might have thought the same.
I need a game plan and a safe way out before I try anything. Silly huh?

I cannot tell you how many people get on horses, thinking they know how to ride and the first question they ask is "So to make him go I just kick with my heels right?" The first question is NEVER how do I make the horse stop in the event he takes off with me. Never, not once. People often get so excited that they forget to ask how to get the experience to stop but never how to get it started.
matt April 17, 2018 at 12:37 #172508
User image

User image

Musical cymbals & drums
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 17, 2018 at 13:12 #172510
Quoting TimeLine
I got an email today from my manager allowing me to work from home two days a week, so now I can finally fill my days "working" designing objects around the house


Congratulations! The commute is amazing! :wink:
XTG April 17, 2018 at 13:34 #172514
Reply to TimeLine

How about a geodesic dome?

User image

User image

User image

User image
XTG April 17, 2018 at 14:14 #172522
User image

User image

T Clark April 17, 2018 at 16:22 #172536
Quoting XTG
I applaud you, you're a nice father.


My family are all game players except me. They are more into cards and board games. I am too timid, afraid to make a wrong move, to be good or to enjoy games much.

Also - I wasn't playing checkers with my own child. My youngest is 28. It was a neighbor's grandchild.
T Clark April 17, 2018 at 16:26 #172537
Quoting ArguingWAristotleTiff
I am a strong swimmer and I have thought about what I would do if caught in a Flash Flood through the canyon and I think my best bet for survival is to tread water and let the water level rise and allow the current to carry me out.


The thing that bothers me is that something could be happening 10 miles away and you'd never know till it was too late. No, I don't think your skill at swimming would matter much. From what I've read, it's like a tidal wave.
T Clark April 17, 2018 at 16:28 #172538
Quoting XTG
How about a geodesic dome?


The building is beautiful, but with domes I'm always asking myself how I could stack all my boxes against a curved wall.
T Clark April 17, 2018 at 16:31 #172539
Quoting TimeLine
i'm currently searching for rental properties just for me and far far away from where I am now so I can start fresh and fill it up with my handmade stuff.


Let me know when you're moving in. I'll bring over a can of yellow paint for the front door.
T Clark April 17, 2018 at 16:33 #172540
I love the way this discussion keeps popping back up. Makes me smile every time.
Noble Dust April 17, 2018 at 19:01 #172569
Reply to matt

Mmmmmmm yes. Lovely.
Sir2u April 17, 2018 at 20:07 #172580
Quoting T Clark
The building is beautiful, but with domes I'm always asking myself how I could stack all my boxes against a curved wall.


By making curved shelves. The difference between one end and the other over a six foot shelf would not be too much. You would just have to learn to stack the big ones in the middle.
Hanover April 17, 2018 at 20:14 #172582
Quoting TimeLine
Love the Scandinavian Farmhouse look ever since living in Denmark, but adding hints of Bohemian and Modern elements.


Not sure about the mirror. The shape fits, but the wood looks too traditional. The little chair definitely doesn't fit, but it creates a storyline, redefines the room, so I'd leave it.
BC April 17, 2018 at 20:41 #172584
Reply to XTG Geodesic domes are of great interest, but I think they are not suitable for traditional decor. A style suitable to the dome hasn't been developed. Possibly something along the lines of Cardasian design (Deep Space Nine) would be more appropriate.

One would, of course, want comfy chairs, tables, beds, baths, sinks, kitchens, and so forth but we haven't found a way of using round space that really looks good. Most of our decor is designed to fit into spaces with flat parallel walls, ceilings, and floors.
Hanover April 17, 2018 at 21:24 #172587
Quoting Bitter Crank
One would, of course, want comfy chairs, tables, beds, baths, sinks, kitchens, and so forth but we haven't found a way of using round space that really looks good. Most of our decor is designed to fit into spaces with flat parallel walls, ceilings, and floors


An interesting factoid I heard while visiting a colonial village was that the use of barrels was for ease of movement of stored goods prior to there being forklifts and other lifting devices. Maybe they could make furniture that way and you could sort of tip and roll it wherever you wanted to. My understanding is that you have been working on the barrel physique so that you could be moved around if need be.
BC April 17, 2018 at 22:44 #172596
Reply to Hanover

No doubt you were thinking of this kind of barrel furniture.

User image

As for my physique... after a certain age it just doesn't much matter any more, as long as one can haul one's self around. The only thing that makes old bodies attractive is being stuffed with cash.
T Clark April 18, 2018 at 09:03 #172682
A few pages back, Bitter Crank and I briefly discussed his photos of monumental architecture - the George Washington Bridge, Fort Peck Dam - Reply to Bitter Crank. For him and me, these structures, in addition to their function, because of their function, provide the kind of public art that ties neighborhoods, cities, nations together. Forgive me for putting words in your keyboard BC.

That made me think of Christo and Jeanne Claude, who created art works that playfully forced people to see entire landscapes differently. You hear the idea - hey, we'll wrap the Pont Neuf Bridge in Paris in fabric - and you think, "Aah... more of that tooty-frooty modern art crap" Then you see it and BANG. You get it immediately.

User image

User image

User image
TimeLine April 18, 2018 at 11:53 #172695
Quoting ArguingWAristotleTiff
Congratulations! The commute is amazing! :wink:


From the bed to the office. About 10 steps. :yawn:
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 18, 2018 at 11:58 #172696
Quoting Bitter Crank
No doubt you were thinking of this kind of barrel furniture.


Hey! They sell those at the feed store! I can get you as many as you like but you might need a flame torch to cut them into those funky shapes that defeat the purpose of the barrel. Men. :confused:
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 18, 2018 at 12:00 #172698
Quoting Sir2u
By making curved shelves. The difference between one end and the other over a six foot shelf would not be too much. You would just have to learn to stack the big ones in the middle.


Lololol that would likely work!
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 18, 2018 at 12:01 #172699
Quoting T Clark
I love the way this discussion keeps popping back up. Makes me smile every time.


It's an awesome place to be! :heart:
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 18, 2018 at 12:03 #172701
Quoting TimeLine
From the bed to the office. About 10 steps. :yawn:


Glorious~ :cheer: :party: Gonna have to install a coffee maker at step 5 :yawn:
TimeLine April 18, 2018 at 12:41 #172707
Quoting Hanover
Not sure about the mirror. The shape fits, but the wood looks too traditional. The little chair definitely doesn't fit, but it creates a storyline, redefines the room, so I'd leave it.


Perhaps if the mirror had a detailed baroque gold leaf frame instead to bring out the colour. You need to check your teeth after dinner, surely.
Hanover April 18, 2018 at 13:00 #172710
Quoting TimeLine
Perhaps if the mirror had a detailed baroque gold leaf frame instead to bring out the colour. You need to check your teeth after dinner, surely.


How about a simple chrome frame to round out the stark, uncomfortable Scandinavian look you're going for? As long as you stack all your junk at right angles on open shelves, you can convince yourself that it doesn't look cluttered. Keep the little chair, though. It creates a warmth and thoughts of little feet pitter patting around on the uncovered wooden slats around the hard angular tables and chairs.
TimeLine April 18, 2018 at 13:01 #172711
Quoting Hanover
How about a simple chrome frame to round out the stark, uncomfortable Scandinavian look you're going for? As long as you stack all your junk at right angles on open shelves, you can convince yourself that it doesn't look cluttered. Keep the little chair, though. It creates a warmth and thoughts of little feet pitter patting around on the uncovered wooden slats around the hard angular tables and chairs.


:angry:
Hanover April 18, 2018 at 13:04 #172713
T Clark April 18, 2018 at 17:41 #172743
When I was younger and my wife and I lived in Cambridge MA, we used to go to the Mapparium at the Christian Science Church in downtown Boston. It's a stained-glass globe of the earth. You walk inside it on a bridge. Since it was built in 1935, the countries are interestingly out of date. Back then it was free. You just walked in and went there. Now it costs $6. I'm the kind of guy who wouldn't pay $6 for 10 minutes of activity, so it's a good thing I saw it 40 years ago. It is beautiful and interesting. Added feature - since it's spherical and made of hard material, the acoustics are unusual. If you stand in the focal point on one end of the bridge and whisper, people on the other end can hear you.

Notice that Australia isn't even shown. It hadn't been discovered yet.

User image

User image
Sir2u April 19, 2018 at 03:08 #172865
Quoting T Clark
Notice that Australia isn't even shown. It hadn't been discovered yet.


It is down in the right hand corner. Hiding like all shy Aussies. :wink:
Hanover April 21, 2018 at 19:25 #173236
My new antique clock. It tick tocks and gongs in an otherwise silent room. User image
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 26, 2018 at 13:12 #174186
Quoting T Clark
I'm walking in unfamiliar territory.

From where I stand, this is a beautiful thing to read, from a beautiful soul I am just getting to know.
Hanover April 26, 2018 at 13:30 #174195
Quoting ArguingWAristotleTiff
From where I stand, this is a beautiful thing to read, from a beautiful soul I am just getting to know.


Oh stop your touchy feely talk and tell me how much you like my new clock. Pretty sweet, huh?
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 26, 2018 at 13:41 #174199
Quoting Hanover
Oh stop your touchy feely talk and tell me how much you like my new clock. Pretty sweet, huh?


I am a really light sleeper so anything that makes a timed ticking drives me crazy, fortunately I learned it early on by stopping the hands and by default the weights of an Antique clock my Step Dad has and got very angry every time I stopped it. So I know that a clock like yours or his and me just don't get along.
Now show me a Cuckoo Clock with the little dancing ladies and gentlemen? I might woo a little.
Baden April 27, 2018 at 12:00 #174363
User image

By Harry Gruyaert.

Deleteduserrc April 28, 2018 at 06:16 #174473
two i keep coming back to over the past couple years:

User image

User image
Deleteduserrc April 28, 2018 at 06:22 #174475
and also the drunk would-be philosopher comforting himself to sleep:

User image
Noble Dust April 28, 2018 at 06:59 #174479
Reply to csalisbury

What is that second painting?
Noble Dust April 28, 2018 at 07:00 #174481
Reply to Baden

There's so much here.
T Clark April 28, 2018 at 09:11 #174490
Reply to Baden

Where? Is Lenin supposed to look diabolical?
T Clark April 28, 2018 at 09:13 #174491
Quoting csalisbury
two i keep coming back to over the past couple years:


Like the first. Love the second. Drunk philosopher? No opinion.
Baden April 28, 2018 at 09:13 #174492
Reply to T Clark

Headquarters of the Indian communist party. Somewhere in India... Lenin was diabolical but I think masterful is more what they are going for here.
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 28, 2018 at 13:44 #174512
@Sir2u
Would this work on the dome home walls?
[url=https://postimg.cc/image/4cucvo71p/]User image
T Clark April 28, 2018 at 13:47 #174513
Quoting ArguingWAristotleTiff
Would this work on the dome home walls?


Quick, take another picture, I want to see what it looks like on the other side of the wall.
Hanover April 28, 2018 at 13:56 #174515
Reply to ArguingWAristotleTiff The wallpaper, wooden chairs, cool kitschy shelf, true Americana.
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 28, 2018 at 14:02 #174516
Quoting Hanover
The wallpaper, wooden chairs, cool kitschy shelf, true Americana.


True but ack.

Here is my dream home- a studio small enough but has everything.
[url=https://postimg.cc/image/5iycu5xtp/]User image
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 28, 2018 at 14:07 #174517
A cabin just outside of Prescott within our price range to purchase (not necessarily to maintain), is zoned for a B&B and a student rental but does not have the connectivity that NicK needs to run our business.
Some one bought either a money pit or a money maker, it will be interesting to see what the new owners do with it.[url=https://postimages.org/]User image
Deleted User April 28, 2018 at 20:09 #174556
This user has been deleted and all their posts removed.
Sir2u April 29, 2018 at 01:45 #174613
Reply to ArguingWAristotleTiff Probably not so well, but they do look kind of cool don't they?

I have a flat wall in an place that I am going use for a TV area, that would look nice around a flat screen.
TimeLine April 29, 2018 at 09:00 #174658
Reply to ArguingWAristotleTiff A couple of weeks back, I stayed in this beautiful cottage with the open sea out the front and lush rainforest behind, I thought I was in heaven. Only a walking distance from the local (and quaint) township with everything that one would need, the crackling sounds of a woodfire and the birds outside :cry:

Imagine sitting outside all snug with a hot drink, talking about endless somethings that make you feel good, later checking out the stars with your Saxon 8 inch. I'm so sad today.

User image
ArguingWAristotleTiff April 29, 2018 at 11:47 #174666
Quoting TimeLine
Imagine sitting outside all snug with a hot drink, talking about endless somethings that make you feel good, later checking out the stars with your Saxon 8 inch. I'm so sad today.


I can only imagine as I am in desperate need for a mental get away. :shade:
TimeLine May 03, 2018 at 10:57 #175664
Reply to T Clark

Look what I stumbled upon on my way to an inspection of an ugly apartment. :groan:

User image
BC May 04, 2018 at 03:22 #175818
This is the Eads Bridge, completed in 1874, over the Mississippi between St. Louis and East St. Louis.

User image
ArguingWAristotleTiff May 04, 2018 at 13:19 #175927
The view I had of Heaven from the back patio of a ranch I was caring for this week

[url=https://postimg.cc/image/nsed3uhbh/]User image

[url=https://postimg.cc/image/i5i063c59/]User image
Baden May 04, 2018 at 13:49 #175941
T Clark May 04, 2018 at 14:20 #175943
Quoting Bitter Crank
This is the Eads Bridge, completed in 1874, over the Mississippi between St. Louis and East St. Louis.


I think my favorite bridges are those old late 1800s early 1900s industrial looking ones. Here's a picture of the Pulaski Skyway in northern New Jersey. I drive under it whenever I take the NJ Turnpike on my way south. That area is full of rivers, roads, houses, factories. I can just see some public works guy 100 years ago saying "Screw it, I'm just putting a bridge across the whole f...ing thing."

User image

T Clark May 04, 2018 at 14:35 #175949
Reply to TimeLine

My wife is partial to blue.

User image
Sir2u May 05, 2018 at 02:11 #176114
Reply to T Clark I agree with here, blue is my color.
Noble Dust May 05, 2018 at 03:52 #176154
Reply to T Clark Reply to Bitter Crank

All y'alls love for architecture is strange to me. I like certain structures, but the ones I like are more connected to personal experiences and specific life scenarios. Is that not the case for you all? For instance, I still love many different views in NYC because they remind me of when I first visited, and subsequently first moved here. But it's not an objective aesthetic standard; it's deeply personal, and architecture otherwise isn't something I'm drawn to. And back in my hometown in the midwest, the house I grew up in in which my parents still live is deeply beautiful to me, but for obvious reasons. Likewise, every time I drive past a Swenson's when I'm back home, my heart flutters a little.

Really, it's just that I have a hard time being objective or rational with something like architecture, because I find a lot of architecture oppressive rather than aesthetic. Is that just because I grew up in the midwest??
BC May 05, 2018 at 04:43 #176180
Quoting Noble Dust
Is that just because I grew up in the midwest??


I live in the midwest; I have always lived within 100 miles of where I was born (except for 2 years in Boston).

I also like buildings and places with which I have a personal connection. There are barns, small houses, school buildings, streets, etc. that I grew up with that are very meaningful to me. The house I was born in is now gone; it was old and decayed; it was time for it to go. It was nothing special to look at but it is a part of me.

I love large structures too, like the bridge above, for their structural features out of which comes a beauty.

Compared to a Roman arch, this one is very recent but there are not many bridges around that are almost 150 years old (because this part of the world hasn't been building bridges that long).

Quoting Noble Dust
architecture otherwise isn't something I'm drawn to


Well, that's all right. You don't have to find architecture fascinating. It's a fairly recent interest to me. It isn't just monumental buildings I like. The Student Union building at the University of Wisconsin in Madison has a small terrace in the back overlooking Lake Mendota. It is a lovely shaded area, just outside the rathskeller where one can get a beer. (I haven't been there recently, I hope it's still the same.) My small back yard is a pleasant place, also an inelegant, weedy affair. I like it, sort of.

There are sleazy bars I liked as spaces; book stores, cafes, department stores. All personal connections.

I'm not a well educated person. True, I got a couple of degrees, but there is a hell of a lot I don't know jack shit about. I've been filling in some of the more manageable holes from my previous educational efforts. Architecture is one of the things I want to know more about.

History too. And an old bridge combines history and architecture both.

Furniture design is another one. My personal taste in furniture is extremely pedestrian or maybe proletarian. But I like looking at nicely designed objects, too.

Like this art deco Zemeth Tombstone radio
User image

or this gorgeous art deco Conoco gas station

User image
Noble Dust May 05, 2018 at 04:58 #176187
Quoting Bitter Crank
It was nothing special to look at but it is a part of me.


I think I feel the same thing, maybe, at least to some extent. I'm working on the finishing touches of an album that uses some architectural aspects of the house I grew up in as a jumping-off point for metaphorical content. That's something architectural that I seem to get.

Quoting Bitter Crank
I love large structures too, like the bridge above, for their structural features out of which comes a beauty.


See, this to me is really the meat of it. It's just that love you have for large structures; you see it as a beauty. That's fascinating to me. I don't "not" get it, but I don't fully get it, either.

Quoting Bitter Crank
Well, that's all right. You don't have to find architecture fascinating.


Yes, I know, I'm just trying to suss out what makes it fascinating to you. Because your fascination is fascinating to me. I'm always fascinated by the fascinations of others that don't fascinate me. EDIT: the fascinations being the things that don't fascinate me, not the "others". Tried to make that poetic and failed.

BC May 05, 2018 at 05:15 #176199
Quoting Noble Dust
I'm just trying to suss out what makes it fascinating to you. Because your fascination is fascinating to me.


That seems like a genuinely generous attitude toward other people's interests.
Noble Dust May 05, 2018 at 05:18 #176200
Reply to Bitter Crank

Eh it's really not, I'm just genuinely interested in other people's aesthetic interests; I'm a terrible person otherwise.
T Clark May 05, 2018 at 05:42 #176203
Quoting Bitter Crank
I live in the midwest; I have always lived within 100 miles of where I was born (except for 2 years in Boston).


Strikes me that architecture is a mid-western kind of thing. It's social. It's art that expresses a sense of community. Midwesterners believe in working things out together. Good old civic virtue. Lion's Club. Bowling. Street signs you can actually read. Wasn't Frank Lloyd Wright a midwesterner?
Noble Dust May 05, 2018 at 06:15 #176213
Reply to ?????????????

Noted. I'm not sure anyone's ideas will or wont' "get me closer to getting it" (getting what?), but I'll look into it.
Noble Dust May 05, 2018 at 06:19 #176214
Reply to T Clark

Eh, sounds like you're romanticizing us. We're not all that. Midwesterners just have a chip on their shoulder. That's the legitimate stereotype.
Noble Dust May 05, 2018 at 07:02 #176217
Quoting ?????????????
Get you closer to what you said you "don't fully get". To me it doesn't seem much different than say music.


I envy the fact that music and architecture seem close to you. Music is a world to me; architecture is a foreign entity that I like, but don't understand. I file dance, for instance under the same heading. It doesn't mean I haven't encountered structures or dances that have moved me; I have. But they're foreign. If anything, as a composer, I should "get" dance, but I absolutely don't. All Iget is music, literature, and plastic art (to a lesser extent). Speaking broadly, with exceptions.

Quoting ?????????????
There are musical structures, kinds of melodies, rythms etc, that I find beautiful or pleasing, without them being "connected to personal experiences and specific life scenarios". In many cases, it is their pleasing nature that leads me to connect them with personal experiences that enhance my appreciation for them. The opposite can happen too.


Hmmm. I know for a fact (via self-reflection, because I'm a hopeless nerd when it comes to music) that the music I love the most is connected deeply with my personal experiences and specific life scenarios. For instance, I've posted this piece several times on the forum. I could literally write a dissertation on why this piece means so much to me on a personal level. Steve was a drummer first and foremost...me too! He didn't like the 12-tone guys...same here. He wanted to re-introduce beauty into music. Same! Turns out, as a kid, I was exposed to a "Noah's Ark" short film that was soundtracked by Stewart Copeland, which, looking back, was heavily influenced by Reich, and even this specific movement of this piece. Deeply personal? That's an understatement.



My point being...for me, personal experience always dictates my perception of aesthetics. What does that mean philosophically? I don't know. All I know is that aesthetics is not universal.

Quoting ?????????????
I don't know, it might be the case that my aesthetic appreciation for such features (either musical or spatial) is based on personal experiences and life events, so the latter always precede, but if that's so, it's too subtle to notice.


That's the thing, I don't think it's too subtle to notice; or, per my own selfish perspective, for me, it's not too subtle. Noticing the personal aesthetic is intuitive. That doesn't mean it's not universal.
Noble Dust May 05, 2018 at 07:22 #176218
Reply to ?????????????

Reading back through your post...I don't mean to say that I don't think it's possible to "like" or have a pleasing aesthetic experience without a deeply personal experience. I may have reacted too strongly, initially. There's stuff I like that isn't deeply personal. Here's a track that my co-workers have recently turned me on to. Is it profound? No. I like it, though. But I have no personal connection to it. Is that what you're referring to? Edit: what do I like about that track? Hooks. Great hooks. Are hooks philosophically useful? Who knows?
Baden May 06, 2018 at 12:48 #176335
Not sure about architecture per se, but I like man-made structures that appear in context in interesting patterns like below:

User image
BC May 06, 2018 at 13:27 #176340
Quoting ArguingWAristotleTiff
The view I had of Heaven from the back patio of a ranch I was caring for this week


Surely there are no cacti in heaven! Hell, yes.
Hanover May 06, 2018 at 13:49 #176342
Reply to Baden It's not just interesting similar patterns, but a political statement comparing religious symbols to capitalist ones. You're philosophical when you don't mean to be.
Baden May 06, 2018 at 13:52 #176343
Reply to Hanover

:victory:
ArguingWAristotleTiff May 21, 2018 at 17:00 #180710
[quote=unenlightened] Not a transaction, not a deal, but a gift. Love is what it's all about, it is an overflowing, it is a passion, the passion. Love is taking pains, and giving without consideration, it is not counting, and so unaccountable. It is what you need, and all you need. Don't expect to catch it in a thread, or limit it to definition.[/quote]

This is beautiful~ This I love~ :heart:
Hanover June 27, 2018 at 02:38 #191405
User image
Edward Hopper - Room in New York.
ArguingWAristotleTiff July 10, 2018 at 12:40 #195591
Watching your child set a lifelong goal and achieving it!
Heads up Amsterdam! Tiff's kin are headed your way! :party:
Shawn July 10, 2018 at 12:42 #195592
Reply to ArguingWAristotleTiff

Congratulations Tiff!
ArguingWAristotleTiff July 10, 2018 at 12:44 #195595
Reply to Posty McPostface Thank you Posty! I am so excited for him!
ArguingWAristotleTiff July 17, 2018 at 12:16 #197589
Europe through my child's eyes

User image

If anyone can tell me what the church looking building is? I believe it is France but I could be wrong.
User image

France's street shortly before winning the World Cup.
User image

I am not really convinced that this is not a California beach...

User image

User image
T Clark March 04, 2021 at 05:27 #505475
This thread hasn't been open for a while. I have something I tripped across a couple of months ago I wanted to post here.

This is the most beautiful thing in the history of the universe.

User image

User image

Orkney Island, Scotland, UK. Skara Brae. More than 5,000 years old. Can you believe that? Do you think these people didn't care about beauty?
Anand-Haqq March 04, 2021 at 11:08 #505555
. Everything in Life is beautiful ... Everything in Life is a celebration ...

. You just have to recognize the beauty of Life and stop be miserable ...

. Small things can become so beautiful ... A little caring ... A little sharing ... That's what Life is ...

. You don't need to go to Machu Picchu, my friend ... To see the splendor of Life ... To see the fragrance of Life ... To see the poetry of Life ...

. The journey is back to you ... Inside you ... Not in Machu Picchu ...

. You don't need to go anywhere to become someone ... You're already that ... What you're looking for ...
T Clark March 04, 2021 at 16:30 #505652
Quoting Anand-Haqq
You don't need to go to Machu Picchu


I've never been and have no desire to go. It pleases me that we live in a world where such a beautiful thing exists.
Pinprick March 04, 2021 at 19:28 #505714
Slawec Gruca paintings:

User image

User image

User image
Gus Lamarch March 04, 2021 at 19:52 #505725
If there is anything that makes me get as close as possible to the abstraction of what is "Beautiful" and its substance. It is the romanticist, idealistic, and classicist art of the 18th and 19th centuries:

User image

User image

User image

User image

"Apotheosis In Man; Apotheosis Is Man."
Noble Dust March 05, 2021 at 04:23 #505941
User image

Georges Mathieu - Composition (1986)
Jack Cummins March 05, 2021 at 10:54 #506015
Reply to Gus Lamarch
These are beautiful paintings. I have never seen them before, even though I have studied a certain amount of history of art. The two pictures of the women seem very contemporary, with the whole presence of light, and the two men are very unusual looking, almost like characters from gothic fantasy.

One of my funny experiences was how when I was about 19 I had a book by Nietzsche, with a romantic painting of a naked woman on the cover. My Catholic mother thought that it was not right for me to be reading a book with this picture on the cover. She went out and bought a piece of wrapping paper and insisted I cover the book.
Heracloitus March 05, 2021 at 11:44 #506022
Reply to Jack Cummins Your Catholic mother should've been more worried about the content of the book than the cover. Lest ye be corrupted.
Jack Cummins March 05, 2021 at 12:11 #506027
Reply to emancipate
Yes, I guess this is strange, and it sometimes seems that Catholics, and I am sure other groups of religious people, tune into aspects of religion but not in their entirety. I feel that I have questioned Catholic views in many ways. I have chosen to keep that from my parents, partly to protect them and partly to protect myself because I need private space to explore ideas freely.
Gus Lamarch March 05, 2021 at 19:53 #506194
Quoting Jack Cummins
These are beautiful paintings. I have never seen them before, even though I have studied a certain amount of history of art. The two pictures of the women seem very contemporary, with the whole presence of light, and the two men are very unusual looking, almost like characters from gothic fantasy.


The innocent idealization of the human being is something incredible to me. The greatest virtue of art is to rationalize our instincts in such a way that we can contemplate "Beauty" while not driven by "Desire". This is something that has been lost.

Jack Cummins March 05, 2021 at 20:00 #506197
Reply to Gus Lamarch
Yes, I think that you have a point. We can perceive beauty and admire it but perhaps stand back in awe. Perhaps the idea of desire, especially in the realm of sexuality, creates a problem in the way we can see it as addressing our own physical pleasures. A detached sense of beauty may exist as a form of inspiration.
Gus Lamarch March 05, 2021 at 20:23 #506198
Quoting Jack Cummins
We can perceive beauty and admire it but perhaps stand back in awe. Perhaps the idea of desire, especially in the realm of sexuality, creates a problem in the way we can see it as addressing our own physical pleasures. A detached sense of beauty may exist as a form of inspiration.


I believe that we have consciously abandoned our ability to act and think consciously, rationally and logically over our instincts.

We exist constantly with the shadow of our wild past influencing us. The apotheosis that I refer to at the end of the images I had posted, is our ability to feel our instincts, and, by simple and mere conscious will, deny it.

What is desire, becomes beauty; what is hate, becomes honor; what is fear becomes courage, etc...

But that had been lost...
Jack Cummins March 05, 2021 at 20:46 #506204
Reply to Gus Lamarch
I might be a bit of a romantic philosopher but I feel positive about what has been lost. Perhaps I grew up listening to too much music by INXS and the Doors, but I came to the conclusion that instincts are best sublimated in the form of artistic creativity. I am unsure of ideas such as hate and honour, having some experience of them, but trying to go beyond attachments. Ultimately, I see creativity as the main point which stands out beyond instincts and social goals, but I am not sure if I could justify this philosophically.
scientia de summis March 06, 2021 at 13:17 #506539
I just love any true British countryside
scientia de summis March 06, 2021 at 13:20 #506541
Although having said that, I'm struggling to get any onto a message
scientia de summis March 06, 2021 at 13:21 #506543
A Guide To Hiking The Scottish Highlands – https://wanderlusters.com

I don't know if this has worked?
scientia de summis March 06, 2021 at 13:21 #506544
User image
matt March 06, 2021 at 14:30 #506569
scientia de summis March 06, 2021 at 14:31 #506571
Reply to matt
Yes that's one of the pictures, thank you!
javi2541997 March 31, 2021 at 17:20 #517048
It could be so random but I want to share with you friends this beautiful castle near in my hometown: Madrid.

The castle is called Manzanares el Real.

User image[/img]

Aryamoy Mitra March 31, 2021 at 17:45 #517051
Variant Reinterpretations of Interstellar's Gargantua

User image

User image

It's unfathomable how curved geodesics, metric tensors and differential geometry can render an artistic truth as serene, and visually incalculable.
T Clark March 31, 2021 at 17:55 #517056
Reply to scientia de summis Quoting scientia de summis
I don't know if this has worked?


To get a picture to show up, copy the URL into the post. Then highlight it and click on the icon of a picture at the top of the comment. That should work. If it is a picture of your own, there is a button for uploading files - a box with an up arrow. There is also one for videos at websites - a video camera.
T Clark March 31, 2021 at 17:59 #517059
Reply to javi2541997

As I told you, my brother and I went to Europe in 2014. One of the things that struck me was the large numbers of castles and other fortresses. It seemed like there was one every couple of miles. They were the Starbucks of the 15th through mid 20th centuries. Just goes to show what a hard place to live Europe has been over the centuries.

Not random at all. If you've looked at the rest of this thread, you've seen lots of buildings, old and new.
T Clark March 31, 2021 at 18:01 #517063
Reply to Aryamoy Mitra

This thread pops back up every so often. It's probably my favorite one on the forum. Thanks for contributing.
javi2541997 March 31, 2021 at 18:24 #517068
Reply to T Clark

Interesting! Exactly as you remember is full of castles. Fun fact: Spain in the Middle Age was called “Castilla” which it comes from literally for the big number of castles built in the country :smile:
Here is another one I like:

It is called Buitrago de Lozoya.

User image[/img]


User image[/img]

javi2541997 August 21, 2021 at 12:19 #582449
Madrid. This oil was painted by Antonio López in 1994. It is so beautiful despite the city changed a lot since then because there are some towers that do not appear. They way this artist represents urbanism is so accurate. It is weird to express but this paint gives me sensations both of nostalgia and uncertainty because in a big city of Madrid you will not know what will happen but I promise you will remember it forever :flower:


User image
TheMadFool August 21, 2021 at 14:16 #582481
Beauty, for me, is an attractive force. I suppose that's the reason why attractive is synonymous with beauty. I guess we could view/define beauty as a gravity analog operating through our senses and minds. Ugliness then would be a force that counters attraction, repulsive in essence.

Given this, what might I infer from the scientific reports of an expanding universe with each galaxy moving away, faster and faster, from every other galaxy? The universe, it seems, on the whole, is really, really ugly.
T Clark August 21, 2021 at 15:56 #582507
Quoting javi2541997
They way this artist represents urbanism is so accurate.


I like it too. When you said it was beautiful, I wasn't sure I agreed. I wouldn't call it a beautiful view, but it does give you a visceral feel for how cities become cities.

When I fly over cities like this, I think to myself - "How many people down there are eating oysters. How can there possibly be enough oysters? How can they possibly get all the oysters to everyone who wants them." It gives a feel for the weight, the density, that civilization brings to the world.
T Clark August 21, 2021 at 15:57 #582508
Reply to javi2541997

Also - thanks for keeping the thread alive. It's my favorite.
javi2541997 August 21, 2021 at 16:19 #582514
Reply to T Clark

You are welcome and thanks for the feedback about the painting :up:
Gus Lamarch September 10, 2021 at 00:49 #591543
User image

[i]"That Sultan of generosity is the Master of Reason;
He is Sanctity and the light of the eyes.
In the path of the Shah,
Khata'i sacrifices his soul.
For the kingdom, property, gold, and silver:
- Of the people!"[/i]
Pinprick September 10, 2021 at 22:14 #592096
Joel-Peter Whitkin- “The Kiss”

User image
T Clark September 10, 2021 at 22:41 #592108
Quoting Pinprick
Joel-Peter Whitkin- “The Kiss”


Serious question - Do you really find that beautiful?
Pinprick September 11, 2021 at 01:06 #592172
Reply to T Clark

Umm… it kinda depends. I mean, if I saw that in real life I’d probably puke, but I find beauty in it more so in how I interpret its meaning than just its aesthetics. I guess it’s similar to how people find stories beautiful. It has nothing to do with the way the words look. It’s about their meaning.
praxis September 11, 2021 at 01:46 #592202
Reply to Pinprick

What does that image mean to you.
T Clark September 11, 2021 at 03:22 #592231
Quoting Pinprick
Umm… it kinda depends. I mean, if I saw that in real life I’d probably puke, but I find beauty in it more so in how I interpret its meaning than just its aesthetics. I guess it’s similar to how people find stories beautiful. It has nothing to do with the way the words look. It’s about their meaning.


Just to be clear, I didn't mean to suggest that I don't think it belongs in this thread.

It does kind of remind me of those old Monty Python graphics.
Pinprick September 11, 2021 at 17:52 #592529
Reply to praxis

In case anyone isn’t familiar with Whitkin’s work, he is a photographer and often uses corpses and/or body parts for his photographs. In order to do this he made arrangements with local morgues who would essentially give him any bodies that went unclaimed/unidentified. So, he never really knew what he would be getting. With this particular image, so the story goes, he was lifting this head out of the box it came in, and dropped it. He didn’t realize that it had been dissected vertically, and when it landed it came apart and landed pretty much how he ended up photographing it. I mention this to show that I don’t think there was much intent involved on the part of the artist to create something with a specific meaning.

To me, I associate the image with Narcissus, or vanity. He is literally kissing himself. Couple that with the fact that this is a dismembered head and it brings about the contrast between “loving life” and “death.” Were this picture taken of two living people, it would appear very tender and loving. So, to me it kind of captures both tenderness/love on the one hand, and disgust/death on the other. There’s something I find fascinating about the ability to transform something that’s typically, or stereotypically, beautiful and lovey-dovey, like a kiss, into something darker. And just the ability to capture these different juxtapositions in one image is kind of awe inspiring for me. But it could be read into as a sort of warning about the perils of vanity, like Narcissus. Or you could interpret it as showing that most likely this person loved his life before he died, which again brings tenderness into an otherwise morbid image. But anyway, that’s my long winded explanation.
Pinprick September 11, 2021 at 17:52 #592531
Quoting T Clark
Just to be clear, I didn't mean to suggest that I don't think it belongs in this thread.


No worries. I didn’t take your comment like that.
praxis September 11, 2021 at 18:12 #592535
Reply to Pinprick

Wow, thanks for explaining. I was missing context, and admittedly too put-off by the image to give it more attention. I thought it was twins or trick photography or something.
Pinprick September 14, 2021 at 18:00 #594558
T Clark August 15, 2022 at 16:31 #729557
A couple of wonderful, beutiful adds. I think they're from the early 2000s. Neither is made with computer generated images.



Tom Storm August 15, 2022 at 21:13 #729660
Quoting T Clark
A couple of wonderful, beutiful adds. I think they're from the early 2000s. Neither is made with computer generated images.


Interesting. To me the first one seems like barely suppressed or symbolic violence and is striking but not beautiful, especially linked with Rossini's music, so well associated for some of us with the urban violence in A Clockwork Orange. And clowns are creepy. But that's the nature of beauty, it's very personal. I am generally unaffected by artworks, but I do enjoy antiquities. I am more likely to find music or prose 'beautiful' not so much visual works.
T Clark August 16, 2022 at 00:53 #729710
Quoting Tom Storm
me the first one seems like barely suppressed or symbolic violence and is striking but not beautiful, especially linked with Rossini's music, so well associated for some of us with the urban violence in A Clockwork Orange. And clowns are creepy.


It surprised me that you said violence, that never crossed my mind. Now that you say it, it makes sense. For me it was just joyful. I find myself moved by big public works of art. Things that get in the way and change the way people think about their everyday world and lives. I've always loved Christo's stuff. For me, that's art that doesn't need an expert to explain it. I can feel it in my bones. Apparently people in the locations where the commercials were filmed really enjoyed the process.
BC February 27, 2024 at 22:43 #884094
When I saw this image on Tumblr, my first thought was 'very realistic painting". The fineness of the detail quickly persuaded me otherwise. Still, it seems a very 'painterly' photograph. It also is a bit difficult to place in time -- the station looks like something from the early 20th century, give or take a couple of decades, but the man, the suitcases, and the transmission poles in the background look much more recent. There is a Petersburg station in western Canada on the CP or CN railroad.

It's a very nice composition.

User image
Paine February 27, 2024 at 23:04 #884103
Reply to BC
Interesting image. The angle of the shadows changes for different objects. The light source is lower when striking the cowboy. The infrastructure visible to the left of the station is absent to the left of it. The station does not cast a shadow beyond the platform on the right.

I like how the cowboy is a Marlboro Man gone to seed when zoomed in upon.

Deleted user February 28, 2024 at 00:16 #884117
The crowning of Holy Mary in heaven, in tapestry, Strassbourg cathedral. Picture by me.

User image
BC February 28, 2024 at 00:52 #884127
Reply to Paine OK, should there be a shadow to the right of the station? But the suitcase and cowboy shadow seem consistent with the bench shadow, the lamp shadow hanging on the left side of the station. and so on. The man in the window seems more like an added image--he's too close to the window glass and too short. Also, I see that the station belongs to the Grand Trunk line. Don't know much about the GT.

The photo certainly seems composed (not a snap shot) and perhaps manipulated. I still like it, particularly the grey/beige/slightly green palate.

Marlboro cowboy gone to seed... He doesn't appear to be old enough to be a seedy Marlboro cowboy, though I see what you are talking about. The cigarette mascots tended to be mature men with deeply weathered faces, from years of riding, roping, and smoking. He is lanky, though, like a cowboy ought to be. Do cowboys travel with luggage? No saddle bags?

Apparently Grand Trunk is not a double rail system out west. Side tracks are used to allow for passing trains.
Hanover February 28, 2024 at 01:18 #884134
User image
User image

Reply to BC

Yes, something very Edward Hopper American Realism about the photograph.
BC February 28, 2024 at 02:10 #884140
Reply to Hanover There is something 'Hopperish' in his selection of topics. A difference though is that the colors in Hoppers paintings tend to use fairly saturated colors. The second one you posted, for instance.

The photograph I posted was by Dean West at Saatchi Art. Here's another Dean West photo; this one reminds me of David Hockney (painter) based on the subject matter and colors.

Palm Springs # 2, 2015 [LAST ONE] Artist Proof 2 of 296 W x 60 H x 0.1 D inDean West

Saatchi is asking $90,750 for the pool photo.

User image
Paine February 28, 2024 at 02:20 #884143
Quoting BC
OK, should there be a shadow to the right of the station?


Given the angle of the other shadows, yes, there should be a bit of darkness to the right. There is no shadow of the fence either but that could be written off as the platform being too high. If one looks at the angle taken from the height of objects to the shadow cast, the cowboy's angle is greater than the others. And what is with the lantern casting a more washed-out shadow than the others?

I think there is an Escher thing underway along with the Hopper vibe.

Beverley February 28, 2024 at 02:27 #884149
User image

‘My’ Agios Nikolaos, as I call it. I am greedy. It is the town in eastern Crete, Greece, where I lived for 11 years, met so many friends— and my husband— the place that stole my heart, and so many others’ that I know.
I left in 2011. Funnily enough, I do not ever recall talking about philosophy whilst there. I didn’t even know what philosophy was until I discovered it in 2021 in Canada, of all places!

Hanover February 28, 2024 at 02:32 #884150
Reply to BC This is different to me, although realism, it's more modern and hipper, with an older gay vibe.

Quoting BC
Saatchi is asking $90,750 for the pool photo.


I shall buy two then. One for my bayside parlor. The other for my conservatory.
Hanover February 28, 2024 at 02:38 #884151
Here's my living room, offering a glimpse into the Hanoverian House of Curiosities. The artwork is a discounted Hopper reproduction. User image

Consider the wifi modem the perfect anachronistic touch.
Deleted user March 04, 2024 at 18:36 #885334
The human body taken to the extreme:
User image
Steve Reeves, posterboy of the silver age of bodybuilding.
Deleted user March 04, 2024 at 18:41 #885335
Reply to BC It is a great picture, it reminds me of the times past when we were not glued to our phones, staring into the horizon at a pool side while smoking a cigar and worrying about nothing was something easy to do. But now with the world on our fingertips, there is always an article to read, a movie to watch, news to catch up on, a stock to watch, someone to reply to... Ironically, the picture is not from those times.
The contrast of the cool blue sky with the emerald pool water is beautiful, and the palm trees sticking out give a nice assymmetry to the composition. 10/10
BC March 08, 2024 at 04:33 #886235
Reply to Deleted user Reply to Deleted user Body building has a history, of course. 19th century circus acts (strong men lifting very heavy objects) popularized having musculature that was outside the norm. (There were, of course, very strong ag and industrial workers whose physiques were not celebrated.). In the US, Bernarr McFadden promoted "health and fitness". Himself a raw vegetarian, there are something of a "religion" about him.

How defined one's muscles will be depends on type and duration of exercise, amount of sub-cutaneous fat, muscle flexing during posing, and so on. Here's a picture of McFadden as a young mn, already practicing what he preached:

User image.
Bernarr McFadden

Raw vegetables and weight lifting worked for him. He was 87 when he died in 1955.

A lot of men who post pictures of themselves on Tumblr (and elsewhere) look pretty fit, but often their musculature does not appear with sharp definition. It isn't that they haven't done the work -- I suspect they are not starved enough to get very fine resolution of every vein, follicle, muscle, tendon, and bone

I'm not criticizing them -- I'd be grateful to look half as buffed. In the summer of 92 I did a lot of training for a series of 100 mile bike rides. I had the endurance and strength but not much definition. I was too well nourished, for sure.

Most men probably do muscle building for sex appeal. Most of them are not doing it as "art", even if they achieve beauty. Ballet and modern dance performers maintain their bodies for their art -- as do some other artists--musicians for instance.

Deleted user March 08, 2024 at 13:19 #886307
Quoting BC
Most men probably do muscle building for sex appeal. Most of them are not doing it as "art"


That is true if we are being realistic, though perhaps sex appeal is an art in itself.
BC March 08, 2024 at 22:28 #886435
Quoting Deleted user
perhaps sex appeal is an art in itself


Some people seem to be just naturally saturated with sex appeal, while others can take what they've got and make what they want, or what they think other people want. There is definitely an art to this. There are a few unfortunates who are (to most other people) sexually repellant. Usually this is not something they bear responsibility for. I'm thinking of 2 guys: one was short, had some skeletal / bone problems, very bad teeth, and had a speech impediment. He was a tax accountant. He was reasonably likable, but had zero sex appeal. The other guy was tall and very thin with wild grey hair and a long unkept beard. His nickname was Bicycle Mary -- he rode his bike to the main gay bar in all weather. In addition to looking like a crazy man, his behavior was a little crazy too. Zero sex appeal.

Those were two people out of a thousand.

Tattoos are a popular enhancements. They have come a long way since the days of the classic drunken sailor getting a tattoo he will regret in the morning. Many men are buying tattoos that are artful designs executed with skill (and quite costly). I would prefer people keep their face and neck free of tattooing, but... no accounting for taste.

Vestus virum reddit, the Romans said -- clothes make the man. The well-put-together outfit goes a long way to enhance one's appearance and presence. The guys who show up in black leather and chains are not doing anything different than the guys who show up in Brooks Brothers suits. A jacket and tie can be good bait, just as jeans with holes and a ripped sweatshirt can be.

It's all art, lower case 'a' and quite essential to human interaction.
BC March 08, 2024 at 22:34 #886437
Reply to Vaskane It's a very intriguing figure.
javi2541997 March 10, 2024 at 07:28 #886712
I want to share in this thread a painting by Lars Hertervig. It is an oil on canvas. Hertervig was a magnificent and talented artist, but he suffered from schizophrenia, and he spent most of his life in a mental sanatorium. The doctors banned him from keeping painting because it produced in him a violent sexual desire. Nonetheless, I disagree with this. The practices of old times were not as precise as we know today.

The landscapes of Hetervig are always dreamlike. He was a boy full of melancholia, missing his parents when he was a student at Düsseldorf Arts Academy. I relate to him a lot.

By the way, I know this artist thanks to Jon Fosse. A great writer whose work I have already discussed with @Metaphysician Undercover and @Ø implies everything, for example.

User image
Metaphysician Undercover March 10, 2024 at 11:21 #886752
Thanks for showing me that
Reply to javi2541997
javi2541997 March 10, 2024 at 13:23 #886777
Reply to Metaphysician Undercover No worries, mate. It is always a pleasure to share my ideas with you. :up:
Deleted user March 10, 2024 at 20:56 #886841
Cantino planisphere, the earliest surviving world map to portray America, it was a copy of the Padrão Real:
User image
Followed by Nícolo di Caverio's planisphere, also adapted from the Padrão Real, now lost to time:
User image
They would be the basis for Waldseemüller's map, where the continent is named for the first time:
User image
Deleted user March 16, 2024 at 19:09 #888485
Another very beautiful mapa-mundi, by Johannes Ruysch (1507):
User image
javi2541997 April 29, 2024 at 16:30 #900009
@Deleted user

Our home irmão.

User image
Deleted user April 29, 2024 at 16:48 #900013
Reply to javi2541997 Lisbon is looking like pastel de nata.
javi2541997 April 29, 2024 at 17:00 #900017
Reply to Deleted user Yeah, Lisbon looks like a pastel because there are sugar beets there. :up:
Deleted user May 07, 2024 at 18:14 #902196
User image

Top of Monumento a Vittorio Emanuele II, by me.
javi2541997 May 07, 2024 at 18:32 #902202
Quoting Deleted user
Monumento a Vittorio Emanuele II,


We now know a bit more about Lionino... You live in Rome! - or in an Italian city -

A sublime Neoclassical monument. It makes me sad that it shows a figure that no longer represents the Italian folk: A king...

If the Italian Monarchy was a symbol of unity, why did they get rid of this honourable institution? :cry:

Ah... Politicians and historians are always making our beautiful Europe feel (let's say) disoriented.

Deleted user May 07, 2024 at 18:34 #902203
Quoting javi2541997
We now know a bit more about Lionino... You live in Rome! - or in an Italian city -


I don't know, Rome is one of top tourist destination of the world.

Quoting javi2541997
If the Italian Monarchy was a symbol of unity, why did they get rid of this honourable institution?


At the end of fascism and the Allies [s](of Satan)[/s] putting their boot on the boot-shaped peninsula, there was no chance anything but a semi-presidentialist republic would be put in place.
javi2541997 May 07, 2024 at 18:43 #902207
Quoting Deleted user
semi-presidentialist republic


When the incest kicks in. :vomit:

Quoting Deleted user
I don't know, Rome is one of top tourist destination of the world.


Ah, true. You are just a random tourist enjoying the privilege of being a member of the Schengen area!
Cool! Have fun, mate.
Jamal May 09, 2024 at 08:59 #902627
Quoting Deleted user
Monumento a Vittorio Emanuele II


Nice photo, but I don't like the building. I think it's a bombastic and insensitively located monstrosity, and it reminds me of Stalinist architecture: impressive, sure, but totalitarian and tasteless.

I took this a couple of winters ago:

User image

I don't think the building (Moscow State University) is a beautiful thing, and yet it's magnificent and photogenic. It's on Sparrow Hill, a high bank of the river, and can be seen far and wide. Looking in the other direction at the point where the photo was taken, you get a great view of the city.
javi2541997 May 09, 2024 at 18:52 #902714
Quoting Jamal
I don't think the building (Moscow State University) is a beautiful thing


You are right. The building is not beautiful, but sublime. I would have extra motivation for studying law if my university looked like that formidable architectural design.

Ma! I want to study there! Like my friends, the Brothers Karamazov! :up:
Jamal May 09, 2024 at 20:02 #902728
Quoting javi2541997
Ma! I want to study there!


I have spent time in one of the other Stalinist skyscrapers, the Hotel Ukraine. They’re not made to be good places to study or live or work, but just to project the power of the state. Magnificent, but inhuman—downright horrible.

But yes, I guess the prestige of the institution, embodied in the building, is surely an attraction to students.
Outlander May 09, 2024 at 21:01 #902745
Quoting Jamal
I don't think the building (Moscow State University) is a beautiful thing, and yet it's magnificent and photogenic.


Quoting Jamal
Stalinist skyscrapers


Quoting Jamal
They’re not made to be good places to study or live or work, but just to project the power of the state. Magnificent, but inhuman—downright horrible.


I find these statements curious. What makes a building "Stalinist"? Surely he wasn't the first person to come up with such an elementary style of architecture, that style being essentially a lack of one and laying bricks as they are in the simplest way? What makes a structure "beautiful"? You find these buildings "magnificent" and "photogenic", but lacking in something, "humanity" you refer to. Could you show some buildings that do quantify what you would call "beautiful" or "human"?

It seems the main difference is there types are "blocky" and squarish, lacking rounded curves such as Greco-Roman architecture incorporates. Curves are a bit pleasing aesthetically for a few reasons I could imagine. I heard once "there are no straight lines in nature" or something of that effect. Do the former-style of buildings therefore invoke a sense of uneasy artificiality, an alien structure that seemingly does not belong and exists only out of forced necessity? It seems, at least in my mind, the most stark contrast between the two types of buildings are those with rounded curves or more "personal touches" reflect the human effort, intelligence, and craftsmanship that went in them as opposed to mere angular blocks that could have been placed there by a machine without any human involvement whatsoever.

Just trying to better understand.
Jamal May 09, 2024 at 23:29 #902777
Reply to Outlander

Start here:

https://www.rbth.com/arts/336582-stalinist-empire-style-architecture
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stalinist_architecture

You make a good and important point about curves, and it might be significant specifically with respect to Stalinist architecture, which (a) is curveless (aside from arches), and (b) replaced constructivism, which could be quite curvy.

A brief explanation…

Before the Stalinist style took over in the 1930s, a lot of Soviet architecture was part of a movement called constructivism, which was Russia’s early and influential form of modernism. It was experimental and progressive, and motivated by social concerns.

During Stalin’s rule, the priority was to build grand, imposing buildings like wedding cakes: buildings that took classical elements and then inflated and mixed them up to achieve the correct blend of popularity (by which I do not mean popularity with the people who lived and worked in the buildings but with patriotic people in general), power, and propaganda.

Then after Stalin’s death, architects were able to return to modernism again.

I should note that what I’ve said here is a big simplification.
javi2541997 May 10, 2024 at 04:56 #902824
Quoting Outlander
What makes a structure "beautiful"? You find these buildings "magnificent" and "photogenic", but lacking in something, "humanity" you refer to. Could you show some buildings that do quantify what you would call "beautiful" or "human"?


Those are very good questions.

Are the beauty and greatness of a building dependent upon our appreciation?

Could it be a possibility to value an architectural design objectively?

Most of the designs of government buildings were not really thought of sharing with the people. I mean, they were built to show the greatness of a dictator to the world. Nothing else. We could agree that Tiananmen Square is actually pretty, but its lack of humanity makes it 'ugly' or sordid. Then, we are judging Tiananmen Square subjectively.

I think I came to the conclusion that it is hard to have an objective opinion on a building. If I see a Soviet building I will think of Stalin, and if I see the Coliseum I will have the bloody fights of gladiators in mind, etc.

Quoting Jamal
During Stalin’s rule, the priority was to build grand, imposing buildings like wedding cakes


Interesting.

I search on Google 'Wedding Cakes' buildings in Spain, and then it showed this one as the most famous: HH Cielomar

Tom Storm May 10, 2024 at 05:17 #902827
Reply to javi2541997 This house, once owned by a Catholic gambling czar and alleged petty-criminal here in Melbourne, was always referred to as a wedding cake. Decades ago, I used to smoke cigarettes on the balcony. I'm not ordinarily a fan of the grotesque mansions of the nouveau riche, but this one has some classical appeal.

User image
javi2541997 May 10, 2024 at 07:06 #902834
Reply to Tom Storm I am not a big fan of grotesque mansions either. I think it is unnecessary to live in a large building, but rich folks tend to be 'pompous'...

It has some classical appeal, yes. It seems that the Catholic gambling czar had good taste regarding architecture.

It is very interesting that we could make a 'first impression' on people depending on the buildings they live in.
We could say that the Catholic gambling tsar was pompous and showy.

What should we think about the people who live like sardines in a tin in buildings like this one?

User image
Jamal May 10, 2024 at 07:48 #902838
Quoting javi2541997
What should we think about the people who live like sardines in a tin in buildings like this one?


I'll wager the apartments in that building are far more spacious and varied than most of today's apartment blocks. It's a famous example of organicism--and this goes back to what @Outlander was saying--in which curves are an important element. Since it's an example of serious, thorough, imaginative architecture, the design carries through to the interiors, i.e., it's not a matter of a decorative facade with a boxy interior as in other styles of architecture.

User image

(although it has to be admitted that this is probably the penthouse)

And here's a better image of the exterior:

User image

https://jaimevalcarce.es/casas-de-autor-edificio-torres-blancas-en-madrid/
Jamal May 10, 2024 at 08:24 #902840
Reply to Tom Storm

No image is showing up for me. I'm guessing it's this one:

User image

It reminds me of the rich houses of the US South (Louisiana?) Maybe the appeal is its simplicity. It is not over-decorated or showy.

Why were you smoking at this house?
javi2541997 May 10, 2024 at 08:35 #902841
Quoting Jamal
I'll wager the apartments in that building are far more spacious and varied than most of today's apartment blocks


Absolutely. The flats are very spacious and the prices per m² are expensive there. The building is located at both Avenida América and Corazón de María, which are one of the 'top' and rich neighbourhoods of Madrid.
Oiza - the architect - said that his plan was to build a building that looked like a tree with its branches. It is one of the most iconic constructions in Madrid nowadays.

Note: I checked in the land registry and it says that each flat has an average of 127 and 200 m²

Quoting Jamal
It's a famous example of organicism


Some say it is Brutalist too, but I don't have enough knowledge of architecture. :sweat:

Quoting Jamal
And here's a better image of the exterior:


Yeah, it is iconic. But that wall made of concrete reminds me of all the buildings built on Franco's era. :lol:
mcdoodle May 10, 2024 at 09:59 #902842
User image

Casa Mila, Gaudi. Curves :)
Jamal May 10, 2024 at 10:15 #902847
Quoting javi2541997
Some say it is Brutalist too


Yes, I'd say it fits in that category too.

Quoting mcdoodle
Casa Mila


La Pedrera, a masterpiece. :up:
Deleted user May 10, 2024 at 11:42 #902854
Reply to mcdoodle I love Gaudí.
User image
My favourite architect.

Reply to javi2541997 Wanna see some soul-crushing, ugly building?
User image
Edifício Copan, São Paulo. Fitting for such an ugly city. I remember watching a documentary on it years ago, subtitles are not that bad.

Niemeyer, one of my most disliked architects.
Tom Storm May 10, 2024 at 11:58 #902860
Quoting Jamal
Why were you smoking at this house?


Yes. Oh, the owner died in the 1950's. It was just a big house near where I lived back then, attached to a school. I used to walk past it a lot and sometimes stop by.
javi2541997 May 10, 2024 at 13:16 #902871
Quoting Deleted user
Wanna see some soul-crushing, ugly building?


Ugly? Soul-crushing?

I get it. Brutalist architecture is not your cup of tea. But I would not call those buildings or structures ugly but unique, and this is what makes them special, at least to me.

For example, wouldn't you feel delighted living here?

It gives me a feeling of calm and chill. The neighbours say 'good morning' and everything is quiet when you come back home after a long day at the office...

User image

***
And what do you tell me about this bus station? The trip to nowhere that we will all take one day. :heart:

User image
Count Timothy von Icarus May 10, 2024 at 13:57 #902876
A beautiful image of philosophy as transcendence and ascent. Reminds me Dante getting to talk to all the Pagan philosophers in the early Cantos.

User image


A lot of star power in this picture, like an NBA superteam of thinkers!
Jamal May 10, 2024 at 14:38 #902885
Reply to javi2541997

Good choices. The second one is the bus station in Preston, Lancashire. The first one looks like the UK too.

But I’ll have to side with Lionino regarding the building in Sao Paolo. It’s not Brutalist, anyway, I don’t think. I do appreciate its sheer monumentality, though.
javi2541997 May 10, 2024 at 14:51 #902886
Quoting Jamal
The second one is the bus station in Preston, Lancashire.


Oh! Wow! Thanks for telling me it is actually a bus station. I promise I thought it was an airport the first time I saw the picture!

Quoting Jamal
The first one looks like the UK too


Yes. :smile: It is located at Park Hill, Sheffield.

https://parkhill.estate/#gallery


Jamal May 10, 2024 at 14:54 #902887
Reply to javi2541997

Ah yes, the Park Hill Estate is quite famous in Britain. Well, at least among those of us who are nostalgic for utopian social housing.
Count Timothy von Icarus May 10, 2024 at 15:16 #902890
Which makes me think, who would you draft for your five man starting lineup for your philosophy super team?

Nietzsche has the will to power, and would be a great, aggressive scorer. But he's also sort of like a Kyrie Irving, a bit of a lose canon who is going to pick up a lot of ad hominem fouls and might not play the best defense.

Socrates is clearly going to be the best guy up in the paint, engaging in close range dialectical, but you also need shooters who can drop way into the back court of abstraction and sink threes like Hegel.

Then you have Aristotle and Aquinas. They don't have the flashy prose dribbling of a Nietzsche or an Augustine. However, they are good all around, playing great D, slowing the offense down with definitions. They're not going to be exciting like a Nate Robinson, more like an Al Horford, picking up rebounds, crashing the offensive glass—but that's what wins games in the end!

You also need to consider verticality. If you don't have players like Plato and Plotinus who can ascend, you're going to get killed in the paint and on the boards.
ENOAH May 14, 2024 at 00:59 #903789
Quoting praxis
I’m guessing this guy’s a plumber. Not classically beautiful, I grant you.


Luminous with beauty.
javi2541997 June 28, 2024 at 04:54 #912725
Falkirk Wheel (Scotland).

User image
javi2541997 April 29, 2025 at 18:34 #985072
As I previously shared in the 'currently reading' thread, I am reading Mircea C?rt?rescu. He is from Romania, and he was born and raised in 1960s Bucharest. The two parts of his novel (Blinding) are a mix of dreams, memories, surrealism and nostalgia in the neighbourhood of his childhood. It also appears a red windmill that seemed to be very big, and the size of this construction impressed Mircea a lot and shows up in his dreams (and nightmares).

I tried to search on Google for the locations, and the results were fascinating.

"Stefan cel Mare" is the neighbourhood of Mircea. A brutalist Soviet-like building, but I like it. I feel positive vibrations, and the neighbourhood seemed to be vivid and full of joy:
User image

It is very hard to find the red windmill on Google. Mircea says that it is located in 'Dambovita'.
Yet I guess it looked like this but red coloured:

User image
Banno April 29, 2025 at 21:29 #985103
Reply to javi2541997 Power back on, then?
javi2541997 April 30, 2025 at 04:06 #985194
Reply to Banno Sí.

I am ready to talk about 'Divine Simplicity' with you again.

:wink:
javi2541997 July 15, 2025 at 04:51 #1000528
The Banffy Castle—the main location where the Transylvanian trilogy is taking part. I am really enjoying these volumes written by Miklos Banffy.

In that period of time, early 20th century, the territory where the castle is located belonged to Hungary, and it was called Kolozsvár. But now belongs to Romanian territory, and it is called Cluj-Napoca.

User image
Tom Storm July 15, 2025 at 05:51 #1000536
Reply to javi2541997 Whenever I see an old pile like that all I can think of is how hard it would be to heat the bloody place! Probably my latent Calvinism.
javi2541997 July 15, 2025 at 06:01 #1000540
Reply to Tom Storm :rofl:

Well, at least when Miklos Banffy was alive, it was sufficient to chop pieces of wood from the closest forest. But now I can't imagine how expensive the gas or power bill could be! Crazy!
javi2541997 September 15, 2025 at 07:18 #1013113
This painting is beautiful, sincere, delicate, pleasant and with hints of melancholy.

[i]Girl with Peaches[/I] by Valentin Serov.

User image


It is (probably) one of the best paints I have ever seen, and it has become my favourite now.

Banno September 15, 2025 at 07:33 #1013114
The anemones are quite good this year.

T Clark September 15, 2025 at 18:48 #1013228
Reply to javi2541997

User image

Thanks for keeping this thread alive.
T Clark September 15, 2025 at 18:51 #1013230
Quoting javi2541997
Girl with Peaches by Valentin Serov.


I was thinking about it some more. Maybe the girl was playing by herself, engrossed, and then someone, maybe one of her parents, came in and she became self-conscious.
javi2541997 September 15, 2025 at 19:42 #1013234
Reply to T Clark Good point, Clarky.

I thought something similar: The girl seemed polite, and she felt self-conscious about wanting to eat the peaches in front of the person looking at her.

It is interesting that you and I perceived the same -- The girl felt self-conscious about something. I guess the expression of her eyes and the innocent position of her hands caught our attention.
T Clark September 15, 2025 at 20:05 #1013241
Quoting javi2541997
It is interesting that you and I perceived the same -- The girl felt self-conscious about something. I guess the expression of her eyes and the innocent position of her hands caught our attention.


Collingwood says the purpose of art is to express the artist’s experience. Our goal in looking at art is to try to share that same experience with them.
Hanover September 15, 2025 at 20:56 #1013249
Quoting T Clark
Collingwood says the purpose of art is to express the artist’s experience. Our goal in looking at art is to try to share that same experience with them.


My view of art is that it is a form of language, and the expression through painting is just another way of speaking, writing, or grunting.

The above comment therefore is a work of art, hopefully acheiving the goal of your sharing the experience I had of thinking it.
T Clark September 15, 2025 at 21:31 #1013261
Quoting Hanover
My view of art is that it is a form of language, and the expression through painting is just another way of speaking, writing, or grunting.


I’m not being particularly facetious when I say maybe it is language that is a form of art.
Tom Storm September 19, 2025 at 06:03 #1013881
Quoting T Clark
I’m not being particularly facetious when I say maybe it is language that is a form of art.


Language itself or how language is used? Do you have a favourite aesthetic experience out of poetry, painting, architecture or nature?
Hanover September 19, 2025 at 12:26 #1013913
Quoting Tom Storm
Language itself or how language is used? Do you have a favourite aesthetic experience out of poetry, painting, architecture or nature?


That's right, there was some ambiguity there. My position was that language is any form of communication and that all forms of communication are representative, metaphoric, non-specific, and infused with personal perspective. That is, the line between what we designate as poetic and literal is arbitrary and that all is poetic at some level.

That's what I meant.

Maybe that's what @t clark meant as well, although he could just be saying that certain linguistic forms (but not all) are artistic, like poetry, music or the like.

But to your question asking whether one might have a favorite aesthetic experience, I think that's a valid question, but I would go as far as to say that everything provides an aesthtetic experience. Of course, this theory of mine isn't entirely developed and it could make no sense at some level, but that's my instinctive response.

I did find these quotes from Wittgenstein, where he apparently disagrees with my analysis:

"Do not forget that a poem, although it is composed in the language of information, is not used in the language-game of giving information."

Ludwig Wittgenstein, Zettel

"Philosophy ought really to be written only as a form of poetry. (Philosophie dürfte man eigentlich nur dichten.)"

Ludwig Wittgenstein, Culture and Value

This suggests a poem, in being for a different purpose, is a different sort of language game. I can accept that different sentences might be for different purposes, but I can't see where the poetic game must be different than the literal game in all instances. That is, a poem can be used to give information, and I don't know how to work through what counts as "information" and what doesn't.

That is, there can be more beauty in an analytical essay than a limerick.
Tom Storm September 19, 2025 at 12:28 #1013914
Quoting Hanover
That's right, there was some ambiguity there. My position was that language is any form of communication and that all forms of communication are representative, metaphoric, non-specific, and infused with personal perspective. That is, the line between what we designate as poetic and literal is arbitrary and that all is poetic at some level.

That's what I meant.


I can get behind that. Nice idea.
T Clark September 19, 2025 at 14:46 #1013943
Quoting Tom Storm
Language itself or how language is used?


I must admit it was just a passing fancy and I haven’t put much thought in it. I guess that means I don’t know.

Quoting Tom Storm
Do you have a favourite aesthetic experience out of poetry, painting, architecture or nature?


Hard to pick just one. For poetry I’ll say “The Black Cottage” by Robert Frost. For architecture — Machu Picchu.
T Clark September 19, 2025 at 14:49 #1013944
Quoting Hanover
That is, there can be more beauty in an analytical essay than a limerick.


I have made the argument that there is beauty in a set of construction specifications.
Hanover September 19, 2025 at 15:42 #1013962
Quoting T Clark
I have made the argument that there is beauty in a set of construction specifications.


I find beauty in the diversity of personalities, including those so boring they find beauty in blueprints.
T Clark September 19, 2025 at 16:24 #1013968
Quoting Hanover
I find beauty in the diversity of personalities, including those so boring they find beauty in blueprints.


For what it’s worth, I’ve also found beauty in well thought out and well written legal decisions.
Hanover September 19, 2025 at 21:10 #1014009
Quoting T Clark
For what it’s worth, I’ve also found beauty in well thought out and well written legal decisions.


I just wrote what I consider a most beautiful work of art. It argued that the condominium covenants did not bind the association to protect against water heater leaks from individual units, but that obligation rested entirely with the individual unit owners. It was a work so maginficent, it made the Sistine Chapel look like a steaming pile of cat shit.
T Clark September 19, 2025 at 21:19 #1014011
Quoting Hanover
I just wrote what I consider a most beautiful work of art. It argued that the condominium covenants did not bind the association to protect against water heater leaks from individual units, but that obligation rested entirely with the individual unit owners. It was a work so maginficent, it made the Sistine Chapel look like a steaming pile of cat shit.


But seriously, don’t you ever read a legal argument or decision that you think is beautiful, wonderful? I do.
Hanover September 22, 2025 at 12:38 #1014398
Quoting T Clark
But seriously, don’t you ever read a legal argument or decision that you think is beautiful, wonderful. I do.


As if all you have to say is "but seriously" and that will somehow keep me on task?

But seriously, I think you're using the term "beautiful" here in a pretty broad way, so maybe a legal argument could be beautiful, but not like a sunset. This issue isn't a small one because the definition of "beauty" is obviously central to aesthetics and this whole conversation.

So, define "beauty" so that the term makes sense in claiming a legal brief is beautiful in some way as is a sunset beautiful so that the term can be applied to both. I would think the similarity would rest somewhere in the feeling evoked from both, but I'm not really sure.

What saith Collingswood on it?
Outlander September 22, 2025 at 13:01 #1014401
Quoting Hanover
But seriously, I think you're using the term "beautiful" here in a pretty broad way, so maybe a legal argument could be beautiful, but not like a sunset


Really? So, of all people, it is you who is the one who reduces such a wide and ever reaching concept to something so primal. "Visually satisfying or enjoyable." That's what beauty is now.

So a blind person can never experience something beautiful. It's just an alien concept exclusive to those who have perfect or otherwise functional vision. For shame. Hanover. For shame. And I looked up to you as a great mind, legal and otherwise. Thankfully I discovered my idol had feet of clay before it fell atop me. Note the circular ellipsis or whatever you spout on about.

Quoting Hanover
My view of art is that it is a form of language, and the expression through painting is just another way of speaking, writing, or grunting.


For some reason in this thread I have this post of yours quoted, so I'll include surely it only ages to show my point. For shame!
Hanover September 22, 2025 at 13:14 #1014403
Quoting Outlander
It's just an alien concept exclusive to those who have perfect or otherwise functional vision


I don't see how you derived that from what I said. The blind can have feelings of beauty, but obviously not from what they see. The question was what was consistent within the term "beauty" that makes it apply across all uses of the term beauty (which could include written essays, sunsets, music, or whatever). Quoting Outlander
For some reason in this thread I have this post of yours quoted, so I'll include surely it only ages to show my point. For shame!
I really don't follow how I've been incosistent is arguing that all language offers some degree of metaphor and then in my asking for a definition of beauty that allows it to apply across diverse experiences. I might generously read in that you're suggesting if art is omnipresent in communication than beauty must also be (which might be true if all art must contain beauty), but that hardly is contradicted by my asking for a definition of art.

Outlander September 22, 2025 at 14:00 #1014406
Quoting Hanover
I don't see how you derived that from what I said.


Quoting Hanover
a legal argument could be beautiful, but not like a sunset.


Well, now you do. Or at least should.

This seems to suggest speech cannot ever amount to something visual. Which, sure, the old saying goes "a picture is worth 1,00 words." So you have that on your side. But as an absolute? Well, perhaps it's simply nothing those of us sighted can truly imagine, now is it?

Quoting Hanover
The question was what was consistent within the term "beauty" that makes it apply across all uses of the term beauty (which could include written essays, sunsets, music, or whatever).


Sure, if we dictate that beauty means "that which one [perhaps greatly or transcendentally] appreciates [over what is common, if not to the individual's experience or perspective]." This is a simple (albeit crude and lacking) term that would seem to cover all. So, if this is true, how am I incorrect?

Quoting Hanover
I really don't follow how I've been incosistent is arguing that all language offers some degree of metaphor and then in my asking for a definition of beauty that allows it to apply across diverse experiences.


Quoting Hanover
My view of art is that it is a form of language


See, this is where I take offense (not really, just hypothetically in an intellectual "debate for debate sake" kind of way). You first claim "art" is a form of language. Meaning it can be fully, or at least sufficiently experienced by those who are limited to such (say, the blind). Yet, people who can see enjoy art and visual experiences, they consider this a staple of the human experience. Do you disagree? Regardless, art is a billion dollar industry. Visual experience is what most people consider to be fundamental to the human experience. So, unless all these people are just wasting their money and the world is full of basically adult children gazing into a simple machine like a kaleidoscope, mistaking art and visual perception as a sort of "empty nothingness" that could easily be replaced by,language, I see a bit of inconsistency. That is to say a bit of lack of thoroughness.
Hanover September 22, 2025 at 14:08 #1014407
Quoting Outlander
You first claim "art" is a form of language. Meaning it can be fully, or at least sufficiently experienced by those who are limited to such (say, the blind). Yet, people who can see enjoy art and visual experiences, they consider this a staple of the human experience. Do you disagree?


What I mean is that all language is a form of poetry to the extent it is an abstraction of reality highly influenced by perspective and comparitive evaluation (i.e. metaphor). Along with this expansive view of language, I accept art as language, as being a form of communication formed through symbolism to communicative thought.

Your need to isolate visual art as being of some special category of art that needs to be discussed is elusive as is your need to protect the blind from what you envision are attacks on their limitations.

Outlander September 22, 2025 at 15:35 #1014425
Quoting Hanover
Your need to isolate visual art as being of some special category of art that needs to be discussed is elusive as is your need to protect the blind from what you envision are attacks on their limitations.


Well hey, who's to say the sighted (non-blind) aren't the truly limited ones, as far as knowledge and the true depth of the universe is concerned. Sure, it's a physical world, we need to see, to eat, basically.

My "need" or rather point expressed is that, as a sighted, non-blind person, you don't know the world they experience. I thought that was the whole point of idea of philosophy in regards to qualia. Sure, the sighted people have overtaken the world, and so find blind people as relatively low priority, with nothing to offer, teach, or learn from. We look at them as some sort of pariah or outcast, masquerading as sympathy or pity or "right from wrong" since they are effectively more vulnerable than those who can see. But what of it?

Also, as a fellow lawyer-in-practice let's not ignore the fact it was you who first intended to isolate visual art with your statement "a legal argument could be beautiful, but not like a sunset". I don't know what it is you're trying to do, but you're not doing it very well. Which is out of character for you.
Hanover September 22, 2025 at 17:30 #1014452
Quoting Outlander
My "need" or rather point expressed is that, as a sighted, non-blind person, you don't know the world they experience. I thought that was the whole point of idea of philosophy in regards to qualia.


I'm sort of wondering why you're discussing qualia about right now, with it not having to do with anything we were talking about. I don't have a problem with tangents or even distant associations of one concept with the other, but this is entirely unrelated, like you just wanted to start arguing that the blind people are missing certain qualitative states that non-blind people are. But I'll agree, to the extent qualia exist, I would agree blind people would be missing the qualia of non-blind people, namely the stuff of seeing.

Quoting Outlander
we look at them as some sort of pariah or outcast,


Now we're flying over the cuckoo's nest. No one is telling blind people they are pariahs, but if you know someone who is, you ought tell them to stop bullying the blind.

Quoting Outlander
Also, as a fellow lawyer-in-practice let's not ignore the fact it was you who first intended to isolate visual art with your statement "a legal argument could be beautiful, but not like a sunset".


My objective, which is not that hard to decipher, was to point out the varying ways "beautiful" might be defined, which isn't terribly controversial because it forms the better part of aesthetics, which is to define beauty.

Quoting Outlander
I don't know what it is you're trying to do, but you're not doing it very well. Which is out of character for you


I will try to better do what you don't know what I'm trying to do so that I can do it the way you have come to expect.
T Clark September 22, 2025 at 18:15 #1014458
Quoting Hanover
But seriously, I think you're using the term "beautiful" here in a pretty broad way, so maybe a legal argument could be beautiful, but not like a sunset. This issue isn't a small one because the definition of "beauty" is obviously central to aesthetics and this whole conversation.

So, define "beauty" so that the term makes sense in claiming a legal brief is beautiful in some way as is a sunset beautiful so that the term can be applied to both.


It’s a feeling I get when I read poetry or fiction. My primary aesthetic medium is the written word. I like music and visual arts, but my relationship to them is not as close. The feeling I’m talking about is the same one I get when I read anything well written—poetry, fiction, technical documents, legal documents, construction documents, philosophy, history, letters, emails, posts here on the forum. It’s the same feeling. Competence is beautiful.

Quoting Hanover
What saith Collingswood on it?


I’m not sure what Collingwood would say about beauty and I’m too lazy to go check. What he says about art is that it is a way for the artist to express their experience and share it with an audience.
Tom Storm September 22, 2025 at 22:37 #1014504
Quoting T Clark
But seriously, I think you're using the term "beautiful" here in a pretty broad way, so maybe a legal argument could be beautiful, but not like a sunset. This issue isn't a small one because the definition of "beauty" is obviously central to aesthetics and this whole conversation.

So, define "beauty" so that the term makes sense in claiming a legal brief is beautiful in some way as is a sunset beautiful so that the term can be applied to both.
— Hanover

It’s a feeling I get when I read poetry or fiction. My primary aesthetic medium is the written word. I like music and visual arts, but my relationship to them is not as close. The feeling I’m talking about is the same one I get when I read anything well written—poetry, fiction, technical documents, legal documents, construction documents, philosophy, history, letters, emails, posts here on the forum. It’s the same feeling. Competence is beautiful.

What saith Collingswood on it?
— Hanover

I’m not sure what Collingwood would say about beauty and I’m too lazy to go check. What he says about art is that it is a way for the artist to express their experience and share it with an audience.



This raises an interesting question: what the hell is beauty supposed to be anyway? I see it in women, but not much else. I occasionally see landscapes in nature that strike me as "visually arresting," but I wouldn’t personally call them beautiful. I am mostly indifferent to scenery. Most of the pictures on this thread, to me, are just images of striking things, some of which I find unappealing. Maybe it’s my problem, I’m not quick to find things beautiful. Perhaps music is the only exception. But I am quick to notice when something looks interesting or arresting in some way. Maybe beauty is just whatever draws your attention and gives you pleasure, which makes it a rather somewhat ambiguous, emotional category.
Outlander September 23, 2025 at 12:13 #1014600
Quoting Hanover
No one is telling blind people they are pariahs


Of course they're not. But they live as such, only were it not for that one nagging social order we call "being a good person." If there were but one meal to eat, and it were you and a blind man, you'd eat that meal yourself fully. Yes, I know your type. Of course, not with other people around. So you'll convince yourself you might share otherwise. Yes, in mixed company, indeed you shall.

What is a man who cannot see who has nothing for you to gain if under your responsibility under punishment of suffering? A treasure. Otherwise, he is but another fixture in this world, a non-human who your ego and false sense of virtue may wish the best aloud, hoping someone would hear it. But short of that, a nobody.

Quoting Hanover
My objective, which is not that hard to decipher, was to point out the varying ways "beautiful" might be defined, which isn't terribly controversial because it forms the better part of aesthetics, which is to define beauty.


And someone else clearly did. A poem or "legal ruling" can be beautiful. But you insist "not like a sunset." So we come back to the root of the issue here. Can someone blind or perhaps unable to feel the warmth on their skin of said sunset for whatever reason know the beauty of a sunset like any normal, able-bodied person can?

These are your own words, Hanover. Not mine.
Hanover September 23, 2025 at 13:10 #1014608
Quoting Outlander
Yes, I know your type. Of course, not with other people around.


You're ridiculous.

Quoting Outlander
. A poem or "legal ruling" can be beautiful. But you insist "not like a sunset."


The reason I said that the beauty of a sunset and a legal ruling are different is because they are. You think that's because I hate blind people and that you're going to expose that hatred regardless of my efforts to conceal it. I'm somewhere between appreciating your schtick if it's intended as nonsense and wondering whether you can think straight.

In any event, I've grown tired of the nonsense, but do enjoy the rest of your day.
Outlander September 23, 2025 at 14:44 #1014615
Quoting Hanover
You think that's because I hate blind people and that you're going to expose that hatred regardless of my efforts to conceal it.


To the contrary, I'd bet life and limb you don't have a hateful bone in your body. Not one that was placed there by your own will or volition, at least.

I merely sought an explanation so as to alleviate my apparent ignorance. I have a problem and look to you for a solution. I didn't mean to if such endeavors are inappropriate in your eyes. Surely you can forgive me.

Quoting Hanover
The reason I said that the beauty of a sunset and a legal ruling are different is because they are.


Well, explain how. Once more. Not everyone is as quick to logic and fact as you are. Surely this is the beauty of life, no?

Clearly multiple people here think (or at least remain uniformed) otherwise. Why not enlighten us instead of pejorati. It's clearly within your capacity to explain. I've seen it. And how.

Of course things are different. No different than saying every person's life is unique. I simply wished to ask how a non-visual form of (perceived) beauty is irreconcilably different from a visual experience of such. Perhaps this is self-evident. But it's not to me. It's not to many. I merely assumed someone or your wit and knowledge would be able to explain such. We look toward those whom we respect or otherwise find have qualities that are respectable to gain greater insight into the world around us. That's all. Nothing more, nothing less. I'm sorry if this upsets you, it certainly wasn't meant as such. I didn't wake up this morning, or any morning for that matter, wishing to be ignorant of things, facts or understanding you take for granted as second nature. Surely you can believe that. :confused:

Perhaps I'm merely barking up the wrong tree, so to speak. Out of my league. Is that such a crime? Surely, you yourself have been in such a position, at some point. I just thought you'd have a bit more to say is all. My fault?

At least one other person recently participating in this discussion aside from myself believes beautifully written words themself can be either equal or equivalent to a visual scene of beauty. If this is false, and the other person has received adequate proof or explanation from your words as such, that's all there is to it.

Let's start over. If one was non-sighted (I.E. blind), that person would never know the beauty of a sunset, nor that it is different from an otherwise beautiful arrangement of words or rulings. This to me, leads it to believe that blind people can never experience true beauty. Is this true or false? The idea of a "difference" is obvious, no different than one drink being flavored citrus and another being flavored non-citrus, but my question is, regardless of whether one is able to detect such flavoring or not, is inability of such truly defining of the overall experience?
Hanover September 23, 2025 at 15:32 #1014619
Quoting Outlander
I have a problem and look to you for a solution.


As you should. Quoting Outlander
Surely you can forgive me.


You must work harder for atonement than simply asking for forgiveness.Quoting Outlander
Let's start over. If one was non-sighted (I.E. blind), that person would never know the beauty of a sunset, nor that it is different from an otherwise beautiful arrangement of words or rulings.


I think you're likely right that a blind person would not know the beauty of sight, much like a non-thinking person would suffer from being unable to appreciate the beauty of thought. Quoting Outlander
The idea of a "difference" is obvious, no different than one drink being flavored citrus and another being flavored non-citrus, but my question is, regardless of whether one is able to detect such flavoring or not, is inability of such truly defining of the overall experience?


Ah, yes, the age old question of trying to decipher the difference between essays and sunsets that has troubled mankind since the cave dwellers. Let's see, a sunset is natural, an essay man-made. A sunset is sensory, yet an essay intellectual. A sunset might be temporary and fleeting, yet an essay enduring. An essay requires some cultivation, the product of learning and culture, yet a sunset fairly universal (unless you're blind or perhaps wearing a sleeping mask). One is linguitic, doubtfully appreciated by dogs, cats, and mice, but it's potentially possible they would enjoy a lovely sunset. My cat does enjoy the hottest spot in the room, typically within the sun's rays. But is my cat's appreciation of a carefree day at all like my appreciation? It's hard to know what Gumbo thinks.

The question then is what does an essay and sunset have in common that might allow us to call them both "beautiful." This question, I did not realize when first posed, was deeply insulting to the blind (i.e. non-sighted), so I reask it with much trepidation. But that, all along, was the question.