Sounds cool. Will drink. My point exactly. Please read the context. This is obvious, but is also what lulls people into the sleep from which this cons...
By 'an experience' do you mean 'a conscious experience'? I was going to add: ... or the kind of experience a sock can undergo?... but I gather that cu...
Feel consciously, I'm prepared to doubt. Not firmly. Just casting a preliminary vote. If it might elicit a vote from you (because you weren't a panpsy...
Excellent question. My vote, FWIW... where human infants acquire competence in pointing symbols (including samples) at things, so that a red thing is ...
Ok, well I did my best to get you to notice where I think your argument tricks you into thinking it is deflationary while it is anything but. Somethin...
Your position is about studiously having it both ways, so that's hardly surprising. No, you admitted that an eliminativist (usually a physicalist) wou...
Not really. I merely want to establish whether the panpsychist does need after all to take ownership of as I alleged, and not pretend that they are ti...
I must admit I did a slight double take the first time I read this: ... introducing an analysis that concludes, with apparent satisfaction: Could this...
And no photographing. No creation of internal representations from which further on or later on to extract information. Just learning to respond appro...
Yes, good point, and a good example: was the article even committed to or advocating some positive doctrine called direct or naive realism? I gathered...
Talk of thoughts being "about" things, in a sense needing subsequent unpacking, can too easily become talk of the thoughts "representing" the things, ...
Dreams are off-line thoughts: thoughts unaffected by the normal requirement of their having to somehow answer to each other and to the organism's pres...
That was one of several (prior to @"tim wood"'s) where expertise of the reader had caused unconscious correction (and hence ignoring) of the mis-state...
No, and neither would you assume that we have multiple bananas to be correlated with some number of subjective first banana experiences. ... or, would...
My emphasis, and probably not the OP's, in which case apologies for going off topic. Anyways... Something often missed is a variety of advantages whic...
Sure, a poem why not... but, given the title, should you be calling it a chair, already? And then, the adjectives... are they wise? Don't they sound a...
:up: :cool: I was quite happily sampling Ground Zero in ten or 15-minute "bleeding chunks" (which I believe is the musicological term). Probably that ...
Haha, I'm rubbish at deadlines. (I asked for an extension, but not so you would notice - my bad.) Anyway, I reckon we might be interested in each othe...
I'm stretched on the carpet and purring... Hang on, though... not to be ungrateful but, is "the above" the OP? So you are agreeing after all with the ...
Cool, not sure I was even aware of the SEP article, so you've returned the favour in kind :up: Did you find the article on his aesthetics, specificall...
Good point. Being exposed to a stimulus isn't always noticing it. And 'hear' can mean notice. (As well as be-exposed-to: my preference in the OP.) Eve...
Decide whether the question is about whether or not we have encountered a complete and genuine instance of the artwork, or is instead one of any numbe...
:ok: For notational music, we potentially care about and often prize the differences between sound events that hang on "small" differences between not...
I think I speak for both myself and @"TheMadFool" when I say we already agreed absolutely with all these implications of your OP for art and music, vi...
Except for the single un-scored pause, yes. To put it differently, you heard an entire piece differing (from the one you planned to hear) by one pause...
It's more that I don't trust "information" to facilitate communication in a discussion like this, and would rather gloss it in other terms. In the con...
Not sure why "brain" is in quotes, but no matter. "The information in your brain", though... are we back to internal images, data, words, symbols? I'm...
Well, the view from my window could (in one sense) mean my back garden, or it could mean an image of said garden created at said window. A photo, for ...
"Scribble", "refer" and "eyes", I think I understand. Not even sure about scribble, though. Do you mean the actual image on the screen, or something m...
Haha, difficult. Working on it. :nerd: "Have"? They relate to them, sure. I am keener than you (apparently) to avoid implying that a dreaming brain li...
Comments