It may be worthwhile to look at the Strauss objection to Nietzsche claiming that "historicism" cancelled the specifically "human" as a measure of thin...
The love part suggests a way to live as a lover. When you love someone, you make them stronger. You build them up. That is why all the Greek tradition...
I don't know about that book. I will check it out. I am rereading Ethics presently. I am influenced by the various interpretations I have read. They h...
reply="Statilius;412814"] Yes. But the examination of emotions and their relation to personal effectiveness needs to be included if one is to cite "in...
I am confused. You want to talk about stuff and also control the discussion by assuming stuff that people still argue about is what you say it is. I h...
Your response underlines how difficult it is to see the world through Spinoza's eyes. The notion that we have just two tools when the world is made up...
The soul refers to an agency of choices but also to what makes it possible to make them. The arguments about free will versus determinism are interest...
Yes. A set of conditions that makes ones life possible but are not "your" conditions if you accept the premises of the explanation. One has to give up...
That is a really interesting observation. The association of militias to an idea of being in a a location gets mixed up with misunderstandings of powe...
The whole shooting other people idea has not actually been a part of a set of rights as much as it has been a license to kill certain people. If I am ...
It is interesting how the results of the "enlightenment" are claimed by one school of thought or another. Perhaps you could start by saying what you t...
I am not following your logic. If everything that exists is the substance of God, the modes are not a subset of something existing under a different s...
Your questions go in many directions. I am just another fool on the internet. One way to think about it is how difficult it is to connect our experien...
reply="Shawn;411160"] You presented the idea that punishment is an elective on some level. It could be not selected. All the serious attempts to advan...
Who is this we? And what is wrong? And this desire to punish, is that the only reason it happens? Life punishes us. The choices we make come back to u...
Yes, other people. But who are these other people? It is fun to be on the winning team and imagine all the crappy stuff that happens to others. What d...
That is pretty much the song I sing to rise up each day. But all these other factors crop up. I do see the effective result of accepting the world upo...
I am not sure what this brings to the party but if someone has an experience that does not fit into available narratives, then the discomfiture become...
Your question about happiness is interesting. I read Spinoza as speaking as a happy person. He certainly resisted the dour premises of many of his con...
The distance between the Tractatus and the Investigations is worth noting. Who else has gone so far from one point of view to another? And if the poin...
One element that is mentioned in most "mystical" narratives is that you are alone while learning the ropes. Or you are alone afterwards. Anyway, a lot...
I don't think the anticipation is bad. But, as you say, it is wrapped up in how we understand ourselves as humans. For myself, the matter of what is p...
My friend was saying that the: "fear comes from the fact, that I won't ever experience anything after I die" is an anticipation of the future. We anti...
I am also afraid. I have lost a number of dear friends in the last few years and it is weird how they still live inside me. Years ago, one of those fr...
This is not true. Most of the plays deal with guilt. Plato's Republic chooses culpability over freedom from it. You really have no idea what you are t...
That is intriguing. It makes me think of her description of the Boers starting to resemble their enemies after fighting for a while (in the Origins of...
Aristotle presented the process as a mirror of a kind. Whatever worked to allow you to perceive the world must be connected somehow to how those thing...
I have read a lot of Gnostic texts, including the Gospel of Thomas. I have a different view of it than yours. I am not sure how to go there from your ...
The toxic element I was referring to was the description of your experience when you said: "Many Christians have not only expressed hate for what I am...
I wasn't saying that you were subscribing to any intention. The point I wish to make, without regard to what I may think is/was the case, is that mixi...
Toxic is well represented by the long tradition of destroying communities because they did not belong to a larger one. So, all the terrible moves to r...
There is something toxic in what you observe. But it ultimately is not about what happens to you or me because we say stuff. The only thing is what is...
I am not sure history is something that can be discussed as a fact like what you and I are able to claim happened to us. I recommend not looking at it...
You are using various accounts of what happened against various accounts you question. Fine. But what will separate your preferred narrative from what...
Before you get to something like considering whether something happened or not, there is all this work relating to accounts of what happened or not to...
It seems you want to stand on both sides of a divide. Say that science is not something or another but also use its language to lodge your complaint a...
One kind of disagreement is whether "Debate about the conclusion is then parlayed into debate about a premise or an inferential step." is bug or a fea...
The way time is treated in Kant is something a person is experiencing in the context of being a person experiencing things. Einstein is claiming that ...
One thing to wonder about is how much "freedom" is happening before the alarm clangs and we are all called to carry buckets of water. Most of us don't...
Evil can be defined or not by various means and for different purposes. Different ways to approach it as an experience are inextricably joined with wh...
Ortega y Gasset took a dim view of Descartes and the German Ideology thing. I don't have the books with me any more (they were not returned after loan...
Comments