The quote you selected is not talking about language, it is talking about the LLM not making its own moral judgement about Trump in the conversation y...
We both are. The alternative is to find new language to describe something else doing the same thing. You also are "producing a piece of text that is ...
It sure seems to. Your poll specifically asks "Should we try to stop LLMs from making moral judgements?" which implies that you feel it is making them...
The LLM is not passing a moral judgement. It is simply echoing your judgement. Your questions are incredibly biased, and it quickly feeds off that, as...
Keep in mind that time dilation is a coordinate effect, not something observed. So yes, the OP's request about observing this other person, while not ...
Many of the posters are presuming absolute frames: Not sure if RogueAI is one of them since he at least added 'relative to me'. Nothing has a travelin...
Normal means what the first postulate of relativity means: All the normal laws apply in any inertial frame, which means there cannot be a local test f...
@"EnPassant" gave a terse but entirely correct reply. Yes. That's dilation, a coordinate effect. It means that from their frame, your mental song woul...
I argue with all of them. It's the whole point of open mindedness. First of all, definitions are not clear at all in you axiom. The usage of 'You' see...
My point was that it is presumptuous of you to suggest that everyone holds the same personal beliefs as you. I agree with neither 1 nor 2 of the new i...
Well, that would be a 5th person then. Perhaps you don't really mean 'in addition'. You obviously have a very dualistic & anthropocentric way of think...
This topic seemed to have gotten totally off track, quickly devolving into the workings of baby brains and individual nerve cell, the relevance to the...
Did they really think there was nothing that couldn't eventually be understood? Or does it only mean 'partially understood' or 'sufficiently understoo...
From the 1st link: "To defeat the threat of tomorrow, we cannot afford to be reactive." It's not a thread of tomorrow. Way too late for this. Everybod...
I think the deleted comments are the difference. I've made some comments in topics where the entire topic has been deleted. 29847 posts includes those...
I cringe at calling those abilities 'mental' since there's such a strong connotation of both life-form and dualism with that word. Let's just say I am...
OK, re-reading, I think I see your point. Never mind the friend, since with enough friends, counting becomes base ?, which reduces to simply tally mar...
You did know what the numbers were since you had the answer. You just didn't know the base-10 representation of that answer any more than you knew the...
OK, but the roomba acts on the knowledge, and it couldn't do that if it lacked awareness of the knowledge. Contrast that with a book, which contains i...
What is being demonstrated ('proven' as you put it) is an implication of the assertion that "being consciously aware is prior to the knowledge of any ...
Been traveling, and the topic has once again run away from me. You do think so. By this very idealistic definition, this particular universe is the ac...
That I am. "The aroma of coffee" does not reference a particular public reaction to it. It is bending the meaning considerably to suggest so. It is no...
I've kind of stayed out of this exchange, but I have to agree here with you. I do not follow any argument that leads to how Banno sees things, and thu...
I am currently away visiting family for holidays, which is why replies are not always prompt. You're right. For instance, I presumed memory is physica...
Relevance noted. Trying to see if it solves anything, especially since the universe is seemingly not composed of true statements. The context is typic...
OK, It seems pretty obvious that indexical truth does not follow from non-indexical truth. Not sure how to apply that here. For one, most indexical st...
Alright, since you've been using 'consciousness', are you saying that you cannot detect your own consciousness? That it has no physical effect? Funny ...
Not what you said. I was responding to you suggesting "we should consider the possibility that there is something we can't detect." and Relativist's b...
Are you saying you can't detect the mental? That seems odd for somebody pushing it as a separate fundamental thing. Of course it has physical properti...
It isn't the Turing machine that's going to have feelings, it will be the simulated person. I said as much in the OP. So its that simulated guy that h...
As I recall, PF was bought by somebody for more than it was worth, but then almost immediately abandoned by its new owner, as if it was for a school p...
I don't know, but it seems to be the dualists that are claiming this knowledge in the absence of understanding. I never made such a claim. Perhaps you...
Good. Just checking. Earlier in this topic, somebody (not you) suggested almost exactly that, as if a computer could feel pain if it executed a 'feel ...
That's like asking which transistor state change is Tomb Raider. Subjective experience is not one neuron event (and 50k is way short). It's a parallel...
You're talking about the identity of a performance of a song, vs the identity of the script of the song. Both have pragmatic identities, and they're o...
We have lost Harry Hindu. I'm quite distressed by this. This is oft quoted, and nobody seem to know where it comes from or the context of it. But Schr...
Purely speculative maybe, but they're relevant in an important way sometimes. I do keep such ideas in mind. BiV is a form of solipsism. Some external ...
OK, from this I gather that your statement that you're asserting an ontological distinction, a distinction in the mode of being, you're merely express...
I thank you all for your input, and for your patience when I take at times days to find time to respond. Most choose to frame their guesses as asserti...
Not my problem if I don't use that reasoning. I feel free to use the same word to indicate the same thing going on in both places. I didn't say 'creat...
I echo that Welcome back! Much to digest in the posts that resulted. I'm slow to reply to it all. This depends on how you frame things. I'd say that f...
Firstly, welcome to tPF. Without looking up the definition, I'd say it was relying on something other than yourself to attain a goal of your own. Keep...
You know what? So do I. I hunted around for that distinction and got several very different ideas about that. Some are more ontic like I'm suggesting ...
Fine, but it was especially emergence that I was talking about, not science. For instance, the complex structure of a snowflake is an emergent propert...
One's current experience can be of somewhere other than where you are, but OK, most of the time, for humans at least, this is not so. My mental map (t...
Careful. It factorizes the measured state into dynamically autonomous subspaces. That means that only the systems that have measured the decohered sta...
You've been leveraging the word now for many posts. Maybe you should have put out your definition of that if it means something other than 'able to be...
The terminology grates with me, but more or less I agree. The universal state vector cannot differentiate since there is but only one of them, so it e...
Doing science is how something less unintelligible becomes more intelligible. OK, that's a lot different than how I read the first statement. I don't ...
Everett interpretation does not hold to CFD, so unmeasured events effectively are not part of any specific worlds (they're not 'real': scientific defi...
Comments