Wow. That's a good question. The One is an idea that goes on to haunt philosophy all the way down to Schopenhauer. It's hard to address Parmenides be ...
I agree, we fill in the blanks. I think Aristotle agreed with your assessment of Parmenides: that he thought things are one in essence, but plural in ...
There are a number of theories about what Parmenides actually believed, centered around whether he truly believed that the plurality our senses seem t...
Could be. I just told you that it doesn't really matter much who you vote for, not wrt fundamentals. If you really understood that, then why are you u...
The question is:. can you accept that American democracy has been subverted to create a super wealthy class? Can you accept that the US military has b...
The two are closely linked. For metaphysical possibility, you can just posit a god that makes it happen. Physical possibility is trickier. That's whet...
I can start a thread tomorrow and try to make an introduction. I haven't read Parmenides, and I've heard it's thick, so unless a more experienced phil...
I think we usually start a thread, read portions, discuss, derail, get back to the text, derail again, ask a moderator to tell somebody to shut up, go...
I don't think it's just about philosophical discussion. Chomsky demonstrated that language acquisition has to be an innate ability. Innate abilities l...
In the Iliad we're watching a conflict among the gods and this plays out in human life as a bloody war. MI Finley says the early Greeks took this lite...
Imagine you tell a friend about a headache and she asks, "Did you know you had a headache at 3:00? It isn't gibberish, but you'd still probably ask fo...
That's because we're geniuses. Or not. The protocol broadcast by monotheism includes projection and shadow, all that stuff Jung was all over. The mono...
I wasn't speaking metaphorically. Ancient people didn't own the elements of the human psyche the way we do. They thought a divinity created fire and g...
Moses Finley says they're the same (pretty much). We think of the psyche as something an individual owns. Ancient people saw the psyche plastered over...
There was a study about how people behave when they're sick. About 50% seek to be cared for by others, and 50% want to go off alone. That's kind of ho...
:grin: I think the wolf is a symbol of wildness. We're domesticated dogs, but we never lose our wild roots, and in fact everything we are springs from...
They can tweak the virus fairly easily. That's what's great about thus kind of vaccine. But yes, we just had a delta wave where I am. We're now expect...
Stability comes and goes in human social groups. Humans make large scale groups that can last for centuries. It's usually most stable near urban cente...
I agree and never said otherwise. The world won't be unlivable during the worst part of the warming. I'm astonished that you put so much energy into t...
100,000 years isn't permanent. I don't think it's picky to say so. The fact that warming will come in a dramatic spike (the size of which we don't kno...
Because basically what it means is that a source you trusted was really really wrong, as in must have made up the stuff about permanent global warming...
Comments