Do you deny he had contempt for slave morality? Can you explain in your own words what you think suppose he meant by master slave morality? Surely we ...
What makes it “truth”? It seems a category error to apply “truth” to a process. You haven’t explained how this term is meant to be used in this contex...
I'd also like to argue that this simplistic ideology is simply reductive and doesn't account for all the times in history when collectivist government...
I mean, Nietzsche seems to be seething with resentment for the "slave morality" which is pretty equivalent to Rand's "collectivists" not letting the e...
Ok, so you are trying to pose a hypothetical scenario and treat it like a "meme" that gets phased out. But the problem is the same as the naturalistic...
I mean that can take up volumes and volumes about Republican resentment. It arguably started with Barry Godwater's 1964 campaign and before him with t...
Ok got it, you meant the latter definition I asked about- evolution, the biological mechanism. Well, this to me just stinks of the naturalistic fallac...
And yesterday's. It's been their true north for a while.. Although, with the populism that laid out, it's taken on different seasonings. More culture ...
Yes what fdrake said, please. Evolutionary as in truth is evolutionary? In what way? how does it fit in that schema of truth? Evolutionary as in the b...
Suicide is multifaceted. My point was how it’s not entailed with antinatslism. We can discuss peoples reasons for suicide but the quote was to point t...
That strengthens Ciorans point in suicide. We are put in an impossible situation. The nostalgia for “unbirth” can never be attained. It doesn’t negate...
Can you explain your objection? At the end of the day my point is antinatalism doesn’t entail promortalism, whatever the reasons great or small for su...
That is answered from where the premises are being framed. Most AN arguments are about notions of starting or imposing suffering onto others. Not star...
So I’ll repeat for the apparently less informed how it got this way once again: No they want Israel’s destruction and to kill as many Israelis as they...
So then I can use that argument for why Israel kept voting in right wing parties. That seems naive. Gaza was given to them and the gesture was “fuck y...
Well shit, isn’t that part of their strategy? If you are run by a leadership with a death cult mentality that provokes a more powerful neighbor, bette...
Haha, I don’t know why but this right there is so oddly obvious, in its characterization of Hamas and its rhetoric, it is oddly out of place. Like cal...
If you looked on the thread I’m not endorsing this heavy handed approach either, I’m just not calling it a genocide. It’s a debate about how hard to h...
If people are more informed on the history, they couldn't just use the latest headline as their newest political cudgel. That would mean a nuanced und...
Ok well, Im saying what is relevant is the causal-historical event whereby if there was any slight change to that event, there could not in any possib...
Ok good question. Let me ask another question, if anything changed even a tiny bit prior to conception, would even the possibility of you actually hav...
Ok, well, we can just drop this line of argument I think. I was trying to make a point about using semantics to then fit the case into the semantics, ...
So this focuses solely on the gametes, and not the causal-historical aspect. That event (not another one, even in another possible world), necessitate...
Define something however you want to fit your case, man. I'm just giving you the other side regarding that usage in this case. Gaza is an "open air pr...
I see you skipped this post, which I believe the strongest against your case: https://thephilosophyforum.com/discussion/comment/866645 Would it be "of...
\ Also, I brought up to another poster that in WW2, 2000+ (mostly military) personnel were killed in Pearl Harbor. At the end of the conflict, two ato...
It does matter, because now you are making someone "defend a genocide" rather than a war, and being this is a philosophy forum, people are just going ...
I would quibble over this, as after the Invasion of Normandy, the Western front became overwhelmingly successful. But yes, the turning point were the ...
over 2,000+ people were killed at Pearl Harbor. It ended with the dropping of two atomic bombs, and now a prosperous Japan. What's your point? Am I ju...
I mean dude, these are the terms the people actually fighting often think in, so stop being so dismissive. The far right in Israel think in terms of r...
I mean, I think this is all you need for your arguments to have some merit. Generals tend to go right to the hammer, without considering other tools. ...
Well, the Labor Party with Ehud Barak was voted in previously, and right after Netanyahu, so there has been a model in the past for such things! Yes. ...
Just curious when is there a distinction between genocide and simply the consequences of war itself? Was the carpet bombing of North Vietnam genocide ...
I’m not going to go out on a limb here and say that most extreme factions of Palestinians (which are a majority), in absence of an army, use terrorism...
:up: Yep, and I think this is all related. To clarify, I think my theory has a causal-theme running through it, that happens to involve substance, and...
Comments