if you would like, you can make a supernatural description of something you call an Easter bunny, and depending on how you describe its actions or cap...
no I am saying there IS EVIDENCE, scientific evidence, that we know what bunnies are. I am also saying there is scientific evidence that we know the c...
it was in P1 I believe - it was defined as a belief in a supernatural entity In hindsight I would have been better of just having a proposition that t...
but let us please please get back on track - i am being very generous in entertain all these diversions. you contest P3 - " it is not a fact that god ...
no - as I said it is a fact that such things as bunnies exist, it is a fact we know the capabilities of these things we call bunnies, it is a fact tha...
i would say if we can agree on what a bunny is - and not go off into some definition argument and we can say we know something factual about the capab...
please now sum up where we are on your objections to my argument on P3 - what is your current objection, and its basis onP,4-7 I think you have alread...
I would say the only thing factual that can be said on the lack of empirical evidence, is that it is a lack or empirical evidence. there is however al...
I agree completely with that statement If you go back to the beginning I never propositioned all 3 - all three were thrown in by those trying to argue...
No - that was a argument - if you remember way back to the first time - my argument back was - the lack of empirical evidence is a very good reasonabl...
second aside - I have no clue what so ever is so hard about an acknowledgement that there is no knowledge that we can elevate to fact to say that God ...
because you have yet to supply any reason whatsoever behind you statement - i even tried to do it for you on the last one. You need to support your st...
maybe easier if i make this point about unicorns. P1 - it is not a matter of fact that unicorns exist on earth P2 - it is not a matter of fact that un...
because - - - - - -- that is just one more declarative statement without support - what i imagine you are saying here is a noseeum argument - " i have...
to recap you challenge P3 - due to lack of empirical evidence I challenge that lack of empirical evidence does not elevate to fact you challenge back ...
No, I would just say that it's either a fact that God is, or it's a fact that God is not. And the issue as a whole, i.e. whether or not God exists, is...
un basically - that is again - just opinion - which is fine - but one can not defeat a proposition in an argument simply because it is your opinion it...
back to the original argument - I challenge your objection to P3 - due to lack of empirical evidence in support of P3. There was not empirical evidenc...
your point is just where exactly on the good - evil continuum you want to draw the line - meaningless. If memory serves, statement in the AFE is - Evi...
this is an aside - this is just the same old - lets argue about definitions and not the concept in question. Very very tiresome and unproductive. Espe...
unsupported - that is just opinion - fine - than using that definition i still say P4 - P7 stand unless you can make an argument they "unreasonable" a...
so using YOUR own understanding of MATTER OF FACT - you cant say either God is or is not a matter of fact ?? because: I have no idea at all what any o...
i agree with that - go on don't stop there - using your understanding of "matter of fact" can you say either god is a matter of fact, or can you say G...
wondering what you think of this as a workable definition of truth - truth is something one believes and tries to act in accordance with. I want to li...
that may be the heart of our disagreement - I do not find that inconsistent at all. I think there can be competing reasonable arguments for the same p...
let me see if this helps - I am about to flip a fair coin It is a matter of fact that the result will be a head or a tail It is not a matter of fact t...
Condolezza Rice, Colin Powell, John Kasich, Will Hurd, Rex Tillerson, General Mttis, John Kelly - more probably if I though more- But the more importa...
I am using reasonable as based on reason. - not sure what you mean by " that is not evaluative" - can you explain. and not sure what any of that has t...
maybe we are having a semantic argument: let me try an example - I find the argument from evil a reasonable argument. the logic is good, the preemies ...
how about we try it out in specific - here is my full argument - P1. There exist such things as Theists – defined as human beings who believe in some ...
Completely objective reasonableness may be an unreachable standard. However the concept of reasonableness being nothing more than an individual judgem...
opinions are your right - your belief in specific that a position is unreasonable - does not make the belief unreasonable in the general. and all your...
Not really i believe it is possible to have reasonable arguments on both sides of an issue. And if one feels compelled to take a position on the issue...
You left out my answer back here Which as far as I know Isaac has not responded to. It is systematic of you entire argument, variable, illogical, and ...
Comments