@"Bartricks" Here my feedback: - No I do not subscribe to a static view of time, this is why I explicitly wrote “I myself do not believe that the russ...
@"Joshs" I can see how we could easily parse such ‘emotions’ into subtler and subtler versions of themselves. This is why I mentioned the psychologica...
@"Joshs" I would be inclined to consider sadness, anxiety, trepidation , uneasiness, concern, satisfaction as emotions because they can be easily desc...
@"Mww" Then as a starter I said that emotions (e.g. fear, joy, anger, disgust, surprise) are occurring sudden and spontaneous (non-deliberate) bodily/...
@"Mww" indeed I limited myself to draft some ideas on how I would distinguish thoughts and emotions. Or at least where I would start with. The problem...
@"Joshs" if we are talking about "emotions" and emotions are considered "more intense variations in the affective attunement" while "Attunements are n...
@"Bartricks" you keep putting your wording in my mouth. I never wrote that "something goes from being future to being present". There is no "going". A...
@"Joshs" I'm not sure how you understand Heidegger''s remarks wrt what I wrote. The first observation is that H. is talking about mood, attunements, a...
@"Bartricks" I don't get your question. Until you rephrase, I limit myself to stress that the russellian definition I was referring to does not talk a...
@"Bartricks" For the umpteenth time, read carefully before commenting. You wrote: "A change in temporal properties is.....wait for it......a 'change'"...
@"emancipate" I disagree with the following statement: "Propositions are the bearers of these truth values." And therefore with what ensues. I'm reluc...
@"emancipate" > Your proposed pre-rendered belief states are impossible to communicate without language. So what? You can have it backwards, without p...
@"emancipate" yes indeed, I put my cat's beliefs in propositional form. That doesn't mean that my cat's beliefs were originally in propositional form ...
@"emancipate" exactly? I don't know. Broadly speaking I might render the cat's belief as "my cat believes there is an intruder in our yard" or "my cat...
perceptual beliefs are the ones your cat has while staring at the window. And you form when looking at the road while driving your car and listening t...
@"Banno" perceptual beliefs are not identical to beliefs that such-and-such, yet they can often be more or less broadly rendered as beliefs that such ...
@"Bartricks", according to the russellian conception, change is possessing different properties at different times. Read carefully and you'll see that...
I tend to agree with @"creativesoul" and disagree with @"Banno". The latter claims: "beliefs are always about what can be put in propositional form. A...
@"Bartricks" > What on earth does that mean? What work is the word 'ontologically' doing? The question “what is change?” may mean that one want to kno...
I disagree, it tells us what change ontologically amounts to. So yes it does tell us what change is. Indeed there can be different properties at diffe...
In this line of reasoning there seem to be 2 assumptions that do not make much sense to me: 1.“Having options” is equated to pondering options simulta...
Comments