let me help you, don't take my word for it...just google "General relativity , everyday applications" The Downtown ReviewThe Downtown Review Volume 5 ...
Seriously you are the one who ignores science and you accuse me for being a professional fiction writer????? You do understand that General relativity...
...If it is unvalid... Never accused you for an argument. I don't even know what you are arguing about because your responses are short and irrelevant...
- No it isn't. Its a scientific theory that ticks all boxes. It provides a sufficient narrative, hasdescriptive power non extreme conditions and it of...
-How such a generalization can ever be helpful in figuring out what the brain does?? My motor bike does more than taking me to my work and back....doe...
Again you are confusing two different meanings of the word. In real life ONLY claims and Arguments can be true or not. (Oxford Un.Logic 101). Changes ...
I will suggest Paul Hoyningen's Lectures(philosophy of science) on the Nature of Science where he explains why there isn't a specific method (set of s...
You will need to quote that part if you want me to accept your objection. If not, I can only assume you are trying to dodge a corner there. Please cop...
-Wll there is a way for accurately representing how someone should philosophize or reason whether he is a scientist or not. This is what it means to s...
You need to provide evidence for your accusations. Declaring them to be "propaganda" and trolling is not enough and its not civilized behavior. In one...
why are you condescending? You accused me for arguing in favor of Materialism and I had to inform you about my position(MN) and how it conflicts with ...
I haven't made any claims on the topic yet , so how can you say that I am right about "everything"??? I only raised some red flags on the quality of a...
I am a Methodological Naturalists. That means I would never argue in favor Materialism or non materialism or any other pseudo philosophical worldview....
No he isn't. He is a Methodological Naturalist (Scientist) and I don't know what "reality is mind" means. I mean I know the meaning of the words reali...
-You are talking about a claim saying that particles posses a specific High level feature. That needs to be demonstrated independently from the aesthe...
Its a critique on the topic and how people approach it. -Fundamental for survival? Sure, but not fundamental in a mystical way(ontology of reality). M...
There aren't any good ontological arguments. In fact all Major General Advances in Philosophy are against all idealistic principles. i.e. Naturalism (...
Well the Huge big grey elephant in the room is to have a "scientist" argue against an indefensible metaphysical worldview and promote another. As a Sc...
I check all these threads on Consciousness and Mind and they all seem to ignore or to be in direct conflict with the latest epistemology from all rela...
Mark Solms,the founder of Neuropsychoanalysis and the author of the most important paper on Dreams, explains his theory on consciousness in the book "...
ok thats good to know. So your point was that consciousness is a property of particles. How can you demonstrate that? Well in science we have ways to ...
lol why they are magical when those properties are quantifiable. You need to do better man.... Can you offer us a method by which you can demonstrate ...
You literally stated that particles molecules and chemicals are conscious...that isn't magical for you? Can you explain the Ontology of Consciousness?...
Whether we are right or wrong is irrelevant or better...meaningless. What we should all value is whether our positions are in agreement with current a...
-" From a philosophical point of view, they kind of realize one cannot defend materialism." -Materialism , Idealism, Occasionalism, Solipsism,Bananism...
I don't really understand your question so I think an Academic Mooc on consciousness is the best way to find your answer. https://www.futurelearn.com/...
The study of consciousness is an Interdisciplinary case. You can observe consciousness like any other property in nature (conductivity, combustion, li...
Emotions (reasoned in to feelings)are the basis of our conscious state (Mark Solmes- Theory of consciousness). A stimulus caused by a particle (odoran...
It depends from your definition. Basic conscious states are enabled by the Ascending Reticular Activating System. A damaged ARAS is the end for your c...
its not a matter of what you "think" but what you can observe and verify. ITs a matter of reasoning, and to reject an existential claim until you are ...
(also?) I am not avoiding anything. I am ignoring unfalsifiable speculations of a physicist on a biological phenomenon. Using QM to describe biologica...
Emergentist?(whatever that means). No I am a human being that follows and respect the methodical and systematic findings of Science and the rules of L...
You need to understand that every process in the universe demands specific conditions in order to emerge. From a structure to its properties, these co...
I would appreciate that and I would ask for forgiveness from everyone else...= ) Of course it's not wrong. If you generalize a quality just because of...
"matter"? Are you suggesting that it is useful to call all high level features of matter and their individual mechanisms "matter''?( Digestion, Mitosi...
Let me explain some basic things. Consciousness is a high level feature produced by the function of specific biological systems...so its biology. Penr...
I would never listen to a biologist's take on QM so I don't know why people listen to Penrose's take on a biological phenomenon....weird and a logical...
well the side making the magical claim has the burden to provide the evidence for the premises of his arguments. Demanding an argument against a unive...
You could address my critique. Actually, I don't think I'm anything more than organic chemistry, except maybe space as well. — bert1 -I don't understa...
-Your last statement helps me understand why you can not make sense of my thesis. You are committing a fallacy of Ambiguity. You are using "truth" as ...
I will read his comments and if his reasoning is based on the principles of Methodological Naturalism then he will be appreciated. -I don't understand...
We totally agree on that. After all the ideal state of a concept is an observer's creation which in practice he/she strives towards it. (truth, knowle...
Knowledge is just an evaluation term we use on claims/statements. Claims that are in agreement with current facts and have an instrumental value (can ...
This thread demonstrates how useless philosophical conversations can become without a credible epistemic foundation. Made up pseudo philosophical prob...
Comments