If there are no viral particles in the room, then the vulnerable person is already safe. If there are viral particles in the room then the unmasked im...
I am saying that unmasked healthy people protect vulnerable people from getting infected by being in close proximity with them. The protective effect ...
Yes, they work so long as we don't mask (and socially isolate) our healthy vaccinated population. ************** The masking of our healthy vaccinated...
Agent, this is the FALSE premise statement that many of us have been brainwashed to believe. ************ Tobias, this statement is FALSE. If you are ...
Not so - you (and others) are reading WAY TOO MUCH into this very simple analogy. We can have as many bullets/mosquitos/viral particles as we want. Th...
Agent, check the science. In general, healthy immune people ("naked men") do NOT shed/spread the virus. ********** Logically (and contrary to Bad Scie...
Hey you all, many of you are WAY over-thinking (over-complicating) the mosquito/bullet analogy. The analogy was meant to show a simple risk analysis. ...
To help better understand the safety benefits represented in the mosquito analogy, imagine the following -- Instead of a mosquito, imagine there is a ...
The number of mosquitoes (or viral particles) is irrelevant. Doubling the number of people within a given environment cuts the risk in half to any ind...
It baffles me that people close their eyes to simple math in favor of Bad Science. The simple math is -- the more people sharing a viral load, the les...
T Clark, check the science. It is extremely rare for the young (immune) man to replicate and cough up (or "bring in") mosquitoes into the room. In oth...
Firstly, mosquitoes (and viruses) don't necessarily stand still in a room. Secondly, my analogy is based on risk assessment (safety analysis). The mor...
Nils, these asymptomatic people are not necessarily "healthy immune" people. Science tells us that the healthier/stronger one's immune system, the les...
Tobias, check the science. It is very rare for a healthy immune person to replicate and spread the virus. Socially isolating and masking a healthy imm...
Okay, although I absolutely disagree with your interesting viewpoint, I thank you for clearing up my understanding of your view. Thanks again, take ca...
So you don't believe in "herd immunity"? ...in other words, so you don't believe there is protective effect to the vulnerable by integrating immune pe...
So in general (disregarding this particular room example), do you believe that surrounding a vulnerable person with immune (vaccinated) people makes i...
Isaac, does this include healthy people with strong immune systems that have been vaccinated??? From what I've read, the amount of viral replication w...
Hey all, I know everyone enjoys the friendly bashing, but please try to answer this question seriously -- Firstly, imagine a fixed number of viral par...
It is simple statistics and simple logic. 1. The more people that share a viral load within a given environment, the less the risk to any individual w...
Hi T Clark, to help better understand the profound effect (safety) that this would create, imagine a fixed number of viral particles floating around i...
Not once in your emotional rant did you refute my logic. -- can you? -- can you find a logical flaw in my words (other than just saying they are wrong...
To mask or not to mask. Here is my opinion on this topic: ***** Please take OFF your mask to save grandma! ***** --This message is intended for our 'h...
The Dangerous Irrationality of Masking our Vaccinated People Masking and social distancing of our recently vaccinated population is dangerously counte...
******************** We are fast approaching (if we have not already reached) a point-of-no-return. If we don't immediately un-mask every available he...
The ultimate idiocracy of our current covid policy is keeping those recently vaccinated continually masked and social distancing. If we don't un-mask ...
For those of you, like InPitzotl, that have difficulty in understanding the difference between "social distancing" and "herd immunity", I have attache...
If, as InPitzotl and some of you others seem to believe, the only role of the immune person in achieving herd immunity is to break vectors of possible...
InPitzotl, you are very disingenuous. You seem to be more interested in finding ways to insult than in giving a straight answer. I'll try again: Let's...
Sorry InPitzotl, this (your reply) comes across as a creative "non-answer" to me. Either you know how a community of 100% vulnerable can be protected ...
We obviously disagree over the CDC's usage of "person-to-person" in their definition of herd immunity. And just because I disagree with this, does not...
The key phrase above is "In general". Rare exceptions do happen. Do you also believe that immune people (via vaccination or past infection) also shed ...
This is an example of bad science (...science that disregards logic). This virus does NOT spread from "person-to-person", it spreads from environment-...
This is Non-Truth #1. This virus does not spread from "person-to-person", it spreads from environment-to-person. People get infected from being in con...
Yes the government usually makes a mess of things. But if we don't soon implement a strategic (or "surgical") herd immunity approach, then we will onl...
Slowing down infections (aka "social distancing") kills more people than it saves: 1. Social distancing vulnerable people saves lives. 2. Social dista...
False. The protective effects of herd immunity just doesn't happen "magically" because we added more healthy immune people into the mix. There is a re...
This important section, which might add clarity, was not brought over when the OP's were combined: The NON-TRUTHS of Our Current Covid-19 Policy *****...
Firstly, do you believe the concept of "herd immunity" is true? Do you believe there is such a thing as a "protective effect" by mixing healthy people...
Yes, this is especially true if you are an infected vulnerable person who is likely to shed much more of the virus than remove. But then, you would pr...
Lol. Yes, I've noticed! (...and nothing wrong with that on occasion.) On the contrary. My belief is based on the "rational" logical interpretation of ...
People with healthy immune systems develop antibodies, which in most cases, provides better protection than does vaccination. Not so. Most medical exp...
Banno, please point out the specific "lie" that you are accusing me of. Any "unintelligent" person can claim "this is a debunked lie", but without any...
Comments