Bear in mind that antivaxers died for their views, in many cases. That’s commitment, or perhaps paranoia. I recall Desmet mentioning paranoia, don’t y...
I watched 20 minutes of the video and what struck me is that ‘mass formation’ was occurring in the pandemic with antivaxers and the like, people who l...
I suppose the point is that a construct can be seen as a construct and be accepted and entertained provisionally for pragmatic reasons; no believing n...
Weren't we just talking about pro-lifers getting abortions? I suspect the inverse also occurs, pro-choicers not getting an abortion because it feels i...
I afraid this doesn't pan out, simply because we can 'hold something to be true' despite evidence, despite reason, and despite our own propensity to a...
How exactly did they change it? I was thinking of what Isaac said in relation to the location of lost keys and how one could have an equal propensity ...
Hmm, maybe we should switch to people beliefs and try to come up with a real-life scenario where a person has an equal propensity to act in contradict...
Maybe I can help provide a real-world scenario, if I'm following you correctly. A plant has the propensity to bend towards the sun. With mirrors, or s...
Perhaps you're misconstruing what was said. Can you give an example? In my example, there is one set of keys and three places that are imagined they c...
Take the 2020 American presidential election, for instance. Trump was a leader and an authority figure who made a claim that his supporters 'felt sure...
Have I claimed otherwise? What I find most problematic with belief is its meaning as described in the etymology: "be persuaded of the truth of" (a doc...
@"Banno" Having lost my keys, I can imagine them being in three different locations without feeling sure about them actually being in any of the diffe...
Fixed. They could be in various places. I can entertain thoughts of where they might be. I can't feel sure or certain about every place that I imagine...
I still don't understand how that can be the case, and for some reason when I ask about this you do not answer. I can't believe (feel sure) that my ke...
Simply that things, like the location of keys, can be accepted and entertained without feeling sure about them. We can also feel certain about the loc...
The keys could be in many places that you could think of, all of which would be reasonable places for them to be. You can't feel sure that they are in...
You're saying that all reasonable unknowns can be believed (accepted as true; feel sure of the truth of) provisionally. If I've forgotten where my key...
Say that I forgot where my keys are. There are many many reasonable places where they could be. According to you, I must have confidence (beleive) tha...
That means that we are forced to hold all reasonable unknowns to be true. That we are forced to feel confident in them. That doesn't make sense. If yo...
It's relevant because shared belief is the heart of the OP and the reason we're discussing this. Is it a matter of belief or was he simply misremember...
Jane asks, "Where are the keys?" Bob replies, "The keys are in my pocket." "Are you sure? Please check." Bob probes his pockets and says, "Huh, I must...
Comments