Why is revenge excessive? If you punch me in the face, and I seek revenge by saying “you sir, are an asshole”, then its not excessive. Revenge doesnt ...
Why does revenge have to be “even more” than justice? Isnt the difference between revenge and justice a matter of motivation? In fact, I would say tha...
I agree, the traits you describe are dynamic, they play off of each other but in the end its a loop, its locked in. I think you are right it does put ...
It seems a bit strange to say experience is s product of our actions..experience is a product of being conscious, but ya that makes sense. So where ar...
A) agree, but would suggest expanding a bit more. A persons thoughts and feelings are informed by some biology...lots of testosterone leads to certain...
I think omniscience is redundant to omnipotence. Everything is. I’ve never really understood why any other attributes would be included in gods descri...
Well, Muhammad WAS a pedophile. Married and had sex with a 9 year old. If its the truth, it should be fair game to talk about and criticise. I agree w...
Lol, the lack of understanding is yours, entirely. I was just trying to politely withdraw because I despise wasting my time. If you can’t understand t...
I don’t think it is, Unfortunately ive reached my limit on how much more I can break it down. (Not meant to be snide) I understand what you are saying...
You mean to tell me that you cannot determine which thing is better at hammering nails, a hammer or a dead fish? Not without conceding my points you c...
It can be both a preference and objectively better, people trying to accomplish a goal (remember that was my initial posit) tends to create a preferen...
The hard steel, the shape of the hammer head (flat on the hitting part), thin so you can see what your hitting, the wooden handle thats lighter thsn t...
Yes, the machine would be telling you, via the properties of the hammer, what the hammer is good for. Thats besides mt point thiugh, as I started with...
That everything is equally justified if they are subjective human constructs, as they all have the same basis of simple subjective preference. The arg...
Of course it is objectively better or worse, the hammer over the dead fish for hitting nails for example. It is true that we can search for certain pr...
A hammer is objectivly better for hitting nails than say, a dead fish. A person may or may not have a preference to use a dead fish to hit nails, but ...
Just jumping in here since I find what you said interesting, Though i realise your comment was directed elsewhere. How exactly do you mean value here?...
I dont think it does, I think that the omniscience only informs. It is knowledge, it can only effect something by being known if it is known by the ac...
I think I see where we diverge. I dont think of omniscience as granting foreknowledge directly, I think of omniscience as granting foreknowledge based...
Does the GCB necessarily exist before the universe was created? Why couldnt it have come into existence along with the rest of the universe from some ...
Do you believe there is a point at which rhetoric and speech does in fact cause violence, and what sort of evidence wouod satisfy you on this particul...
Greatest conceivable being is not the same as a being of pure good is it? My point was that there are other possibilities than the conclusions drawn i...
You have added words to his, “at least” as likely is not the same as being likely. His initial statements are simple and concise, I do not think I hav...
I do not think you have made headway in your point, except to attempt to define away my objections. You define faith as not in conflict with fact or r...
This is just a different example, illustrating a different point. I understand that not every example will show a conflict, but some do, and that is e...
I feel like I have a good grasp in your point, I just disagree. Also, I didnt say faith was foolish, you are putting words in my mouth there. All I in...
I dont see how 100% knowledge over any other percentage matters, thats a question of accuracy rather than of the principal of what I said. Foreknowled...
That seems like a dubious claim. Can I not have good reasoning but arrive at a conclusion that doesnt coincide with facts? For example, if someone did...
Yes, this is an example of circular logic, the conclusion and the premiss are essentially the same. It starts with the premiss god exists, then goes o...
I dont think 2 follows from 1. It is just as likely to be a lack of insight as it is the good not outweighing the bad. 3 also does not follow from 2. ...
Its not a finite set if you can always add one more. Again, you are misapplying your math principal here. This isnt about the numbers, it is about the...
You arent really talking about a number here, I think you are misapplying the math. GCB cannot be represented by an infinite set, by definition the GC...
I don’t think your equation makes sense. The nature of B precludes the part of your equation that is “B+1”, the “B” in “B+1” could not have been “B” (...
2 simply restates the position my argument is meant to dispel. It still does not follow that gods foreknowledge effects the decision the person is mak...
The position is as incapable of being attacked as it is incapable of defending itself, and therefore is just as easily dismissed as it is proffered. Y...
My point was that you don’t need intersectionality to accomplish your stated goal. That intersectionality is certainly being used in nefarious ways by...
Comments