Hi Ben, I think you provide a viable alternative definition of omnibenevolence, but even granting that, I do not think your argument is sound. Firstly...
(Premise numbering added for visual clarity.) Hi reasonablewave, I believe you may have misread Empedocles' argument, or perhaps Empedocles' could hav...
I'd like to preface this by saying I agree that Christians and other religiously minded people should be encouraging compassionate attitudes towards t...
I don't think you've refuted my counterexample about free will. I can certainly grasp that living life without the ability to do a number of things th...
I have not read the comments in this read that were posted after your reply to me, so I apologize if I bring up anything that you have already respond...
From an evolutionary perspective, groups of humans that cooperated were more likely to survive than groups that competed, and so cooperative social be...
Your argument is phrased a little confusingly for me. I can't quite follow any of the inferences you're making between and within each premises. I thi...
I'd like to object to premises 3 and 5, despite your rebuttals. In your defense of premise 3 you state that, for a being who knows all things, thought...
Again, the specific point I would like to make is that Collins' "rigorous support" for the argument from design does nothing to advance the core debat...
I'm not quite sure I understand what you're saying here. Do you mean that you agree with my assessment that the science does not support his argument?...
I'm not necessarily implying that the Big Bang was random, or that randomness would necessitate lack of design. Specifically, I'm saying that new info...
Comments