Isaac Shmukler

What is the other possibility? (I am afraid that we will continue only later since I have to go now.)

Any intended simplicity is also merely another kind of sophistication.

This is why sophistication and symmetry very often contribute to beauty. A chaotic art is not a disproof to this theory since its chaotic effect is in...

I will try to answer my question and you are welcome to comment. I have found a common factor to the phenomenon of beauty: The extent by which the obj...

Let's look through the entire life of a single individual, why is it that some things are beautiful to his eyes and some aren't?

There could be a cultural factor or some other reasons causing individuals to react differently to the same ballerina.

If that is what you meant to ask. These sub-experiences are reactions, I would say.

An important group is not required, unless one wants it to be importantly beautiful.

Let's talk about one individual experiencing beauty, what is this experience's origin?

Anyways, now that we have defined "beauty" (at least partially), can you help me find its general origin?

Now, I didn't get what you mean.

I agree that we feel that there is a difference between "appreciated" and "beautiful" but we can explain that this is due to the usually similar taste...

Why "appreciated" is not good enough for you?

Beautiful is just like tasty, no one is wrong!

I admit that "according" is confusing and should be omitted. I'm sorry for that.

Beautiful is just like tasty i don't want to be more confusing.

...

If there is a disagreement about whether something is tasty it is really not a disagreement and no one is wrong.

This is like the adjective "tasty."

I mean that beautiful will be always according to a particular beholder.

I should be honest I think that beautiful has many senses. When one says that something that is importantly accepted as beautiful is not beautiful, th...

They agree on a broader sens of beautiful: Appreciated by an important group of people.

I mean that, even if one decided that something isn't beautiful, it yet might be beautiful since someone else decided that it is beautiful.

I agree with that. The beholder decides whether something is beautiful. Although it might be yet beautiful since another beholder appreciates it.

The quality is that it is appreciated just as the example above of "wanted."

Consider the concept "wanted". What is the definition of "wanted"? The quality of things that one wants. It is the same by beauty.

It's clearer to put it this way: This is a quality that is defined through the appreciation of the beholder.

It is a quality of sights and sounds that depends upon the beholder.

Beauty is the quality that hold sights or sounds that give rise to a pleasant feeling. More precisely, it is the quality of sights or sounds that give...

It seems that my initial formulation is far from being clear. I should try to ask this question in a much simpler way: What is more important, the kno...

The suffix -able denotes an ability and the prefix ir- denotes a negation. This means that irrefutable means "that cannot be refuted." I have used thi...

I do! It is only irrefutable using the data currently available. Just as in the examples I already gave. I will give one more: There is life on planet...

Obviously logic and mathematics have statements that are more than reasonable. Furthermore, their negation is even inconceivable: x+y=y+x, if the obje...

I also didn't mean to beliefs that cannot be doubted. I meant to beliefs that might be false. Irrefutable only means that it cannot be disproved using...

By irrefutable I didn't mean that one cannot disprove it even theoretically. Of course, a person can theoretically come back to life and tell us that ...

By irrefutable I mean to negate claims like "it will rain tomorrow" since regarding these type of claims one has enough data to reasonably decide whet...