Bitcoin was hacked, I am sure it was difficult but really the person cannot spend what they stole without exposing themselves, so basically the stole ...
That is what I did when I encountered the question, but do as you like. So let us assume, objectively, that everything is futile. Why should I care su...
We are not conversing about simple yes or no questions. We were debating a very particular yes or no question that is not so simple as you would like ...
If that answer is yes, your position is contradicted, if the answer is no, your position has been contradicted. I pointed this out, and that was my on...
If truth value is a judgment there is a contradiction. It would be the case that there is a truth value in world x when there are no minds, which woul...
Again relative to what? Am I to imagine some cosmic being that judges the value of all of human life? Do I take a consensus of the living and ask them...
That is not my issue though, just because some people find no teleological purpose that justifies their own existence, this does not mean that it is f...
Well I tried to reason with you, but it is your right to believe what you choose. What you don't get to do is claim that what you believe is a truth a...
Truth value is not equal to a judgment and truth does not depend on judgment. If it is true that there are no judgments on world x, then truth value i...
If there are no judgments in world x because there are no minds in world x, that means there is truth in world x even though there are no minds or jud...
That depends on world x. So judgments depend on minds, and worlds. Which contradicts the notion that judgement depend exclusively on minds. Whether th...
There are issues with the blockchain that concern me. The first issue is privacy, it is possible to monitor each transaction of the blockchain. The se...
You said religion is not about the natural world, science is. Religion has no place then, if what you say is true, trying to tell people facts about t...
Most of us will not contribute profoundly to the benefit of all of humanity, yes that is true. But for the 99% we do contribute profoundly to each oth...
This brings up an interesting point, if religion has nothing to do with the natural world, then they should stay out of the classroom. Religion has no...
Science, as compared to other methods, works. That is to say it is the most reliable method for producing applicable knowledge about the world. This i...
You are claiming it is neither true or false that there is no truth in world x. As a consequence it is then neither true or false that truth is exclus...
Been over this already, I have contributed all I care to on this subject, and you can review my previous posts where I have discussed the issues of co...
I did make the case that truth about worlds are world dependent and not mind dependent. I used a proof by contradiction. If it is true about the world...
Sigh It can't be a truth about the world because then it would be a truth that depends upon the world and would contradict "all truth depends on minds...
It is not true of any world that "All truth depends on the mind" If that was true about the world it would be a contradiction. So it is not a truth ab...
Exclusive 1.excluding or not admitting other things. "my exclusive focus is on San Antonio issues" 2.restricted or limited to the person, group, or ar...
I am claiming that it the statement "truth is exclusively mind dependent and truth is world dependent" is a contradiction. If truth is also world depe...
??? I do not claim that truth is exclusively mind dependent so I do not have to provide the diagram of that claim. I provided the diagram from my clai...
I don't see a contradiction here. https://s28.postimg.org/wptzfhdvx/Venn.jpg Perhaps you could point it out if there is one. I do see a contradiction ...
Not in this diagram. https://s30.postimg.org/47vdkt2wh/image.jpg In that diagram truth is NOT exclusively mind dependent. That would be a contradictio...
Then it is not a truth (? is only in F) that some G's are not F's. Which contradicts what is depicted in the diagram, the diagram illustrates that som...
Again 'Truth is exclusively dependent upon minds" Is not logically equivalent to the statement "Truth is dependent upon mind and upon the world" One h...
Note the venn diagram for a conjunction. So the statement "Truth is dependent upon the mind and truth is dependent upon the world" looks like this. ht...
I pointed out that the statement "Truth is exclusively dependent upon minds" is not logically equivalent to "Truth is dependent upon minds and truth i...
This is not equivalent to my example. So if you say "This is exclusively a triangle and it is also a shape" It does not have set membership of exclusi...
If the set of people contains men then it is a contradiction to say. "This product is exclusively for women and this product is for all people" becaus...
Ok but it would be a contradiction to say that it is both. "This product is exclusively for women and this product is for people." The set of people a...
Yes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logical_conjunction Note the truth table https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logical_conjunction#Truth_table So "that man...
If Everest is part of the world, then the peak of Everest is NOT exclusively Everest depedent, because Everest is part of the world, then Everests pea...
Except saying "truth is exclusively mind dependent" and "truth is mind dependent and world dependent" are not the same thing. They are actually differ...
Ok. But then we have the statement "Truth is mind dependent and world dependent." You can't have the statement "Truth is exclusively mind dependent" a...
I don't care about minds. I am pointing out that the truth of the statement "Truth is mind dependent" is not a world dependent truth by definition. Re...
No that is a truth about minds, because truth is mind dependent not world dependent. It cannot be that the statement "Truth is mind dependent" is a wo...
Comments