MoK

Ok, it seems that you are not interested!

My request is not a red herring. We have to start an argument from something. How could we possibly proceed and make any progress in a discussion when...

I have an argument for the Mind. It is not a matter of my faith. I have an argument for the Mind. I start by experience as a phenomenon that exists an...

I asked you what the mind and physical are to you and you refused to answer. I think we cannot make any progress. What is the experience to you? To me...

You define experience as a set of processes. That is not what experience is. When you experience something, it feels something in a certain way to you...

That is a physical process. You can call it perception. I asked you what is experience though. You are the only one with such a claim. Are you a physi...

Not only that. The Mind is the uncaused case.

You need to define perception. The perceptions are not changes in the brain. The rest of your definition is ambiguous at best. Matter by definition is...

I read the rest. But you are talking about conscious and unconscious minds. They need their own separate definitions.

:100: :up:

I asked for a definition of the mind. Saying that the mind is an emergent property is not informative enough.

It is not vague. By event, I mean something that happens. A conscious event therefore is something that happens and affects our awareness. And finally...

What is your definition of the mind?

The change in the state of matter is due to experience. I guess we agree with this. But experience cannot change the state of matter since it is not a...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t5Sd5c4o9UM

So do you agree or disagree? If you disagree then what is the experience to you? How could experience change the brain if it is not a substance?

So you agree that the brain changes by new experiences, whether the experience is perception, thoughts, etc. You however didn't answer my question: Ho...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9E9-L9_S3V0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=di7NMssrqsE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MKk1u5RMTn4

There are many (practically infinite states if we accept that time is continuous) states before the glass breaks into parts. The glass first is deform...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kXNA6zAf8uw

This a gradual process and that requires time for it to happen. There is nothing paradoxical about it.

If you accept that as a change then time is required for it to happen. Let's focus on two states of glass, before breaking and after breaking, let's c...

Are you denying the loss of information during the process of cell division? I didn't say that the broken glass is a process. I said breaking a glass ...

It is a change. The information of DNA is not preserved completely during the process of cell division. This is the cause of aging. No, that is very u...

Accepting that aging is a change then it follows that aging requires time since any change requires time. Aging is a process by itself but can also be...

Correct.

I do, and by becoming ready, I don't mean that she no longer feels love for me. I think that should become a part of education for teenagers. Many tee...

That is just your opinion. People think differently, and that is why insult is considered an offense. So, you are subject to the laws whether you like...

In the same manner, it is not the government's business when someone insults someone else. So who cares!?

I agree but I talk about people who just dump their partners. So again which type of guy you are? Do you dump your partner or try to explain the situa...

What do you think we should do with people who dump their partners? What do you think of dumping?

Why don't you answer my questions?

No, it is not different. Don't you agree that dumping your partner who is in love with you is not correct and that you should do everything you can to...

I already answered that in the case of your girlfriend. Dumping people is not allowed and it is an offence.

Of course not. Do you agree with me in the girlfriend scenario?

Consider that you lost your feelings to your girlfriend but she still loves you. You should still care for her feelings. That does not mean you are fo...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJAfLE39ZZ8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KUmZp8pR1uc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=09839DpTctU

I think so. I think so but it is not considered as a crime.

You hurt people's feelings.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NvR60Wg9R7Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xGcQev48cXU

Let me summarize things, burning the Quran is an offense, and any offense is the subject of punishment.

According to Google: "An offense is a criminal act, while violence is the act of causing physical harm. Violent crimes are a type of offense.".

I see!

Homosexuality does not offend me. Some people feel otherwise.

Why Germany? Did you realize that from my accent? :razz:

I think so. I think so.

I am from Iran. Glad to meet you here!

Violences also defined as actions that are intended or likely to hurt people or cause damage to them. I have no problem using offense instead of viole...