You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

When I look into a blackness what am I seeing?

Benj96 June 08, 2020 at 14:32 1475 views 1 comments
When you remove all the light in my field of vision I still see. I see black. It may not look anything different to when my eyes are shut but all the same i see black everywhere. I am aware my eyes are open and that I am observing black. The information I inherit from this experience is that I am in a place of total darkness. If the eye requires light to define contrasts what am I looking at when no light energy, when no visual information is coming into my eyes?

Is my brain constructing an image of blackness? Is this a conscious default setting when deprived of stimuli? Can we call black a thing? Does it exist? How can something devoid of information exist? If no energy is going into my eye how can I say I am seeing?

One possible theory is that all the information I obtain from "seeing black" is intrinsic to my awareness of prior knowledge and experience. I remember a state which was not black and therefore can extrapolate/ deduce what this experience of absence if light is despite the fact I am receiving no information from the environment. Obtaining information about a state from its opposite. Just as we see an object because we do not see what is behind the object.




Comments (1)

InPitzotl June 08, 2020 at 19:34 #421869
Quoting Benj96
Is my brain constructing an image of blackness?

Yes (see next).
Is this a conscious default setting when deprived of stimuli?

No [link: Tommy Edison Experience, Youtube].

There's variation as well; see here [link: Damon Ross, BBC News article] for a case of visual tinnitus.

It can get complex too: Charles Bonnet syndrome
Quoting Benj96
Can we call black a thing? Does it exist?

I would suggest yes.
Quoting Benj96
How can something devoid of information exist? If no energy is going into my eye how can I say I am seeing?

Well... it's a little more complex than this. When no light is hitting your eye, the photoreceptors in your eye go to a default state; but that default state is actually depolarized to about -40mV; this is the dark current (see also the section on advantages, which describes this a bit more). So no light hitting your eye = photoreceptor voltage potential, which has energy.