You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

Floyd Mayweather vs Conor McGregor

A Son of Rosenthal July 13, 2017 at 16:09 9800 views 41 comments The Lounge
Floyd Mayweather is the legendary boxer who has a record of 49 wins and no losses. Conor McGregor is the most famous UFC fighter who is the former feather weight champion and is the current light weight champion. Both men will fight in boxing in August, 2017. Who will win???

Comments (41)

Baden July 13, 2017 at 16:12 ¶ #86234
Mayweather. Because he's a boxer and they're boxing. There is no suspense here. It's just a cash cow for McGregor.

It's like putting a champion tennis player up against a champion badminton player in a...tennis match.
Agustino July 13, 2017 at 17:02 ¶ #86248
Mayweather. He wouldn't fight if he didn't know he'd win, simple as that. That's an advantage of arranging your own fights.
CasKev July 13, 2017 at 17:15 ¶ #86251
McGregor will win. Age will be a big factor. Conor will be faster and stronger. He has never been knocked out, and has finished 18 of his 21 professional wins by KO or TKO.

Mayweather hasn't fought professionally in almost two years, and hasn't knocked anyone out since 2011. And don't forget - he has a tiny head!
Agustino July 13, 2017 at 17:51 ¶ #86264
Quoting CasKev
Conor will be faster and stronger. He has never been knocked out, and has finished 18 of his 21 professional wins by KO or TKO

They were saying the same about Pacquiao.
CasKev July 13, 2017 at 18:34 ¶ #86317
Pacquiao is an old fart too, who has lost 4 of his last 9 fights.
Wosret August 25, 2017 at 19:18 ¶ #100224
Tomorrow! At this point, I hope that Mcgregor wins. He claims within four rounds. It's pretty ridiculous that everyone (including me) gets so wound up about dudes beating each other up. People also think that the gloves will make a big difference, but they won't. They wear gloves to protect their hands, not their faces. They couldn't hit as hard without wrecking their hands without gloves and taped wrists.

It's all about the gs you deliver to buddy's head, not how hard your hand is. It's about causing their brain to collide with the skull, making them forget often not just the whole fight, but the whole damn day. Get up and keep fighting on instinct while their brains are all scrambled.

The way everyone is expecting Mcgregor to lose makes me want him to win now.
CasKev August 25, 2017 at 19:24 ¶ #100227
Quoting Baden
It's like putting a champion tennis player up against a champion badminton player in a...tennis match.


More like putting the best triathlete currently in existence up against a well-aged champion distance runner who hasn't competed in quite some time in a distance race.

Go McGregor!
Nils Loc August 25, 2017 at 22:44 ¶ #100252
I want one of them to walk away from the fight and disappoint those who would be disappointed by it.

I'm rooting for whoever is a disappointment or a spontaneous pacifist.
Wosret August 25, 2017 at 22:51 ¶ #100253
Hanover August 25, 2017 at 23:20 ¶ #100255
It's all corrupt. The most money is made on a McGregor win so there can be a rematch for even more money; ergo, McGregor wins.
Janus August 26, 2017 at 00:49 ¶ #100267
Quoting CasKev
And don't forget - he has a tiny head!


No, he has a normal head. McGregor has an abnormally massive head. In any case a small head is a smaller target, and says nothing about skull thickness or bone density.
Wosret August 26, 2017 at 01:16 ¶ #100272
"Your little head, and your little core." "Your brittle hands... do your hands ache when it gets cold?" lol.
BC August 26, 2017 at 01:20 ¶ #100273
Quoting CasKev
And don't forget - he has a tiny head!


Zika wasn't around yet.

Probably a result of maternal drug abuse. But he had a fine childhood.

Wikipedia:"When I was about eight or nine, I lived in New Jersey with my mother and we were seven deep in one bedroom and sometimes we didn't have electricity." Mayweather said. "When people see what I have now, they have no idea of where I came from and how I didn't have anything growing up."

It was not uncommon for young Mayweather to come home from school and find used heroin needles in his front yard.[24] His mother was addicted to drugs, and he had an aunt who died from AIDS because of her drug use. "People don't know the hell I've been through," he says.

The most time that his father spent with him was taking him to the gym to train and work on his boxing, according to Mayweather. "I don't remember him ever taking me anywhere or doing anything that a father would do with a son, going to the park or to the movies or to get ice cream," he says. "I always thought that he liked his daughter (Floyd's older sister) better than he liked me because she never got whippings and I got whippings all the time."

Mayweather's father contends that Floyd is not telling the truth about their early relationship. "Even though his daddy did sell drugs, I didn't deprive my son," the elder Mayweather says. "The drugs I sold, he was a part of it. He had plenty of food. He had the best clothes and I gave him money. He didn't want for anything. Anybody in Grand Rapids can tell you that I took care of my kids".[25] Floyd Sr. says he did all of his hustling at night and spent his days with his son, taking him to the gym and training him to be a boxer. "If it wasn't for me he wouldn't be where he is today," he maintains.


McGregor, on the other hand seems not to have had a depraved or deprived life. Didn't get screwed by an Irish priest, didn't have a drunken Irish father who beat him. He

wikipedia:Conor Anthony McGregor[12] was born on 14 July 1988 in Crumlin, Dublin, the son of Tony and Margaret McGregor.[1] He was raised in Crumlin and attended a Gaelscoil and Gaelcholáiste at both primary and at secondary level in Coláiste de hÍde in Tallaght, where he also developed his passion for sport playing association football. In his youth, he played football for Lourdes Celtic Football Club.[13] At the age of 12, McGregor also began boxing at Crumlin Boxing Club.[14][15]

In 2006, McGregor moved with his family to Lucan, Dublin, attending Gaelcholáiste Coláiste Cois Life. Following that, he commenced a plumbing apprenticeship.[16] While in Lucan, he met future UFC fighter Tom Egan and they soon started training mixed martial arts (MMA) together.[17]


He was spoused about 9 years ago and just had a son (well, his spouse actually "had" the child). He speaks Irish fluently, which is surely a plus, and probably speaks English quite well too. Haven't heard him talk. He started a plumbing apprenticeship. Don't know if he finished. I need a plumber. Maybe he'll be free after his match.

I'm betting on McGregor.
Janus August 26, 2017 at 01:23 ¶ #100274
Quoting Wosret
Your little head, and your little core


Ha, McGregor!

fishfry August 26, 2017 at 02:19 ¶ #100276
Quoting Nils Loc
I'm rooting for whoever is a disappointment or a spontaneous pacifist.


Well you know Mayweather's boxing style is as close to pacifist as a prizefighter can get. His body seems to adjust in real time to the entire space of physically possible near-future configurations of the two bodies in the ring. He is always just slightly impossible to hit. His mind/body system has totally figured out boxing. His whole style is that he can't be hit.

Mayweather's a pacifist! But I don't think I'd say that to his face!!
Hanover August 26, 2017 at 19:00 ¶ #100342
Reply to Bitter Crank It was painful hearing about McGregor's life, having been filled with one idiotic Gaelic word after another.
Agustino August 26, 2017 at 19:35 ¶ #100347
McGregor seems to have a big mouth, but to me it seems that Floyd appeared to be more confident.
Wosret August 26, 2017 at 20:27 ¶ #100349
Confidence has nothing to do with your ability to do anything other than get people to believe you. The obsession with confidence, and who's more afraid or lip quivery is so fucking silly.

"A casual stroll through an insane asylum demonstrates that faith doesn't prove anything." - Nietzche

"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts." - Russell

They even have tested it, and shown that people that think they'll do the best on a test do like the worst, and people that think they'll do the worst do the best. The wisdom traditions are all about checking your ego, which is a defense against your vulnerabilities and mediocrities.

Watching people "read body language" and cold-read out a hundred conclusions per minute is fun and all, but a waste of time when their premises are ridiculously flawed, and with such volume they're bound to be right about something, none of which will ultimately matter, as even what they're right about doesn't mean a damn thing anyway.
Agustino August 26, 2017 at 20:42 ¶ #100350
Quoting Wosret
They even have tested it, and shown that people that think they'll do the best on a test do like the worst, and people that think they'll do the worst do the best. The wisdom traditions are all about checking your ego, which is a defense against your vulnerabilities and mediocrities.

With regards to taking tests, exams and the like, I can say this is true based on my experience. I thought I will fail many tests and exams, and I passed them with honors. And there were a few rare exceptions when I felt overconfident, and in one of those cases I even failed.

Quoting Wosret
Confidence has nothing to do with your ability to do anything other than get people to believe you. The obsession with confidence, and who's more afraid or lip quivery is so fucking silly.

But I'm not sure about this. Personally, I'm someone who appears outwardly confident (nobody who knows me in real life would say I'm not confident) but I'm very inwardly pessimistic and totally lacking in confidence on the inside. But I fear that if I didn't appear outwardly confident, then my failure rate would be much greater. Appearances do matter - not to me, but to others they do. And I need to influence others, otherwise almost nothing can be done in the world.

Being outwardly confident but inwardly full of doubt gives you the best of both worlds I think. You're not going to underestimate the obstacles, but you'll still get people to believe you.

But there is a sense in which confidence is very important. And it's important in getting you to act - someone who is very confident on the inside, is very quick to act. That can be an advantage. For me, I'm extremely slow to act. Once I act on an idea or thought I'm unrelenting and determined, but starting something new, etc. I'm slow to make my moves. I like to brood over matters over a long time. Despite this, so far I have found that my success rate on what I aim is quite very high, but I presume it is so simply because I take extreme caution compared with many other people I know.
Wosret August 26, 2017 at 20:50 ¶ #100351
My words and actions are not directed towards the manipulation of the the world to the ends of my desires, but the truth. Does this result in success? It doesn't fucking matter to me if it did or didn't.

Agustino August 26, 2017 at 20:52 ¶ #100352
Quoting Wosret
My words and actions are not directed towards the manipulation of the the world to the ends of my desires, but the truth. Does this result in success? It doesn't fucking matter to me if it did or didn't.

In terms of philosophy sure, but what about, say, in terms of building a family? Are your words and actions in that case not directed towards the well-being of the family instead of to truth?
Wosret August 26, 2017 at 20:54 ¶ #100353
Reply to Agustino

Only someone that doesn't understand that philosophy is lived, and not simply lipped would say "pfft, maybe in philosophy, but what about your real life?".
Agustino August 26, 2017 at 20:57 ¶ #100356
Quoting Wosret
Only someone that doesn't understand that philosophy is lived, and not simply lipped would say "pfft, maybe in philosophy, but what about your real life?".

Well I think at least that I understand that philosophy is lived, but the practice of living doesn't deal in truth, it deals in actions. Those actions are only guided (but not wholly determined) by truth.
fishfry August 26, 2017 at 23:40 ¶ #100372
There's a lot of philosophy in this event. It's the philosophy of hype. Of "events." This is not a boxing match in its normal sense. Mayweather retired undefeated, but that was two years ago. He hasn't thrown a punch at a real opponent in a long time.

McGregor isn't even a boxer. He's an MMA fighter. And even he's retired.

So this is a spectacle for the masses, who are going to pay ninety-nine bucks each to watch this exhibition. What does this say about the masses? They are not interested in actual excellence, or competition. Only in the spectacle. Then what of philosophy? Would a philosopher say that the very falseness of this event, its lack of fundamental integrity, renders it an object to be scorned and criticized?

Or would they just take the hedonist line and lay down their ninety-nine bucks like the rest of the rubes just to watch the show?



Baden August 27, 2017 at 00:54 ¶ #100382
Quoting fishfry
So this is a spectacle for the masses, who are going to pay ninety-nine bucks each to watch this exhibition. What does this say about the masses? They are not interested in actual excellence, or competition. Only in the spectacle. Then what of philosophy?


fishfry August 27, 2017 at 01:51 ¶ #100390
@Baden, This is good stuff. I'll look into Debord some more. Thanks for the pointer.
Baden August 27, 2017 at 02:16 ¶ #100393
Shawn August 27, 2017 at 03:08 ¶ #100399
I have some links; but, they're under heavy traffic and not working as well. Anyone have a good link to the fight?
Shawn August 27, 2017 at 03:20 ¶ #100401
K, this works pretty well.

http://www.vipbox.live/boxing/485533/8/money-belt-:-floyd-mayweather-vs-conor-mcgregor-12-rounds-super-welterweight-live-stream-online.html
Shawn August 27, 2017 at 04:55 ¶ #100412
Stamina won the match for Mayweather.

But, McGregor won on points until the last two rounds.
Baden August 27, 2017 at 05:03 ¶ #100415
:-d

30 million for McGregor. 100 million for Mayweather. They both win. The people who thought it was a real fight lose.
Wosret August 27, 2017 at 05:16 ¶ #100419
As expected, but not as hoped. Everything worth watching is a spectacle. That's what a spectacle means...
Shawn August 27, 2017 at 05:18 ¶ #100420
Reply to Baden

It was a real fight from McGregor, much more than from Mayweather, until round 6 when Mayweather took control of the match from McGregor, by just outlasting him and fighting smart. Most of the commentary, until round 6 was something of the sort: *Mayweather, is a shadow of himself or isn't fighting like he usually does*.

In reality, he just outlasted McGregor.
Baden August 27, 2017 at 05:27 ¶ #100425
Reply to Posty McPostface

So, he played with McGregor for a few rounds then when he felt like it, beat the crap out of him. That sounds like business not sport. Anyway, whatever, I'm not a fan.
Shawn August 27, 2017 at 05:28 ¶ #100426
I felt like McGregor was playing with Mayweather from round 1-5 until Mayweather just saw that it was a chance to end it after McGregor got tired after round 5.

Fact that McGregor lasted so long, didn't get KO'd and was tied on points for the majority of the fight shows that he's not all talk and show.

Edited: Mixed up something.
Baden August 27, 2017 at 05:34 ¶ #100428
Reply to Posty McPostface

Well, either you're irrevocably naive or I'm irrevocably cynical. So, dead end.
Baden August 27, 2017 at 05:37 ¶ #100429
You know as much as I hate bullfighting, there is at least a cultural element to it. This was just bull fighting.
Shawn August 27, 2017 at 05:39 ¶ #100430
Quoting Baden
You know as much as I hate bullfighting, there is at least a cultural element to it. This was just bull fighting.


Yeah, the bull does most of the fighting though, so gotta praise or commend the bull for being the real fighter.
Wosret August 27, 2017 at 05:39 ¶ #100431
It was as expected. McGregor doesn't have great stamina, look at his fights with Diaz. When he can't knock them out within the first few minutes he gases out, and even his sparring partners said that he didn't want to train for stamina, and wanted to quit when he got tired. Diaz said that he could punch hard for like six minutes, and then he wouldn't be as dangerous.

Mayweather played it smart, and played defensively without barely throwing a punch in the first few rounds, waiting for him to lose energy, and get past the point where Mcgregor could actually throw dangerous shots, and then closed in.

Though I will say that Mayweather claimed that he wouldn't play it defensively, and would come after him from the get go, but didn't.
John Days August 27, 2017 at 06:41 ¶ #100461
Mayweather looked like he could go another 10 rounds by the end of the fight.

All the pre-fight psychological games were interesting, where they posture shirtless and get up in each others faces to trash talk etc. I wonder how much of that is actually effective.
Agustino August 27, 2017 at 11:47 ¶ #100490
Quoting Baden
So, he played with McGregor for a few rounds then when he felt like it, beat the crap out of him.

Well, yeah, that's kind of an accurate description of it! >:O >:O >:O