Given the limitations of communication online, as I actually said that it was not meant to be a snide comment, then I rest my case as there's no furth...
So, I'll try and restate the topic subject to the question as to why the reader thinks Wittgenstein called Godel's Incompleteness Theorems, a logical ...
Sure, if all you wanted to point out was my misunderstanding of Godel's Incompleteness Theorems then you made your point. Rest assured your mockery of...
I don't mean to be snide; but, if you haven't acquainted yourself with the halting problem, then it would clarify any confusion about how definitions ...
I think that what one can figure from stating psychology in this way is that by having a body of knowledge upon which we can formulate bedrock beliefs...
It was hardly a mistake, as some might think it was. Wittgenstein stated in the Investigations that many of his thoughts had been continued and expand...
So, one may be able to do so in some other formal language? I'm of the understanding that for a complexity class size to be complete and consistent, s...
Not to disregard what you said; but, thank you for the clarification. I edited that post which you addressed because it was inaccurate. There are so m...
Yes; but, returning to what was said in the OP, then I believe that if logic is tautological, then the only constraints on systems of logic are the wa...
I'd like to add to my previous post, that the implications of incompleteness have been only demonstrated by incorporating new procedural rules into a ...
I always thought the solution to the problem of certain logical systems needed to compute undecidable problems, is solved by appealing to greater comp...
I do not like stating this in formal systems like Peano Arithmetic; but, rather in terms of decidability. By framing the question in terms of decidabi...
Yes, well I think you are referencing Rosner? Can you provide the reference? Yes, I would like to point out that I am not denying the logical validity...
Whatever works. I've seen this countless times of someone pointing out a logical fallacy and the other person just deflecting it. Anyway, thanks for t...
Here, I hope you can look at the article on ontological commitment entailed by universal quantification for "concepts": https://plato.stanford.edu/ent...
If concepts are not things, then they do not have any ontology. The existence of a universal, which concepts would not have, according to what you are...
Yes, well, this is where I agree with universal quantification and would subscribe to some form of ontology to what concepts are and how they derive t...
Yes, concepts are used in different ways. The way we use words is largely defined by grammar, and that's just a factual definition. So, I don't unders...
There's no need to beg the question. If you're looking for a specific answer, then go ahead, provide one. Sure; but, words aren't objects. I'm mostly ...
Again, I am not interested in the complexity of the external aspect of a concept, this is something that Austin described with speech acts and stuff l...
Sure; but, if we're to talk about how Wittgenstein saw it, then I would like to mention his concern with how rules are followed and obeyed. I think th...
Yes, well, every concept is defined by what rules govern their use in a language game. I don't think these rules exist outside the hypothetical realm ...
It sounds oversimplified, and there's much more to say; but, sure, by having a common grammar we are able to understand even concepts. From the inner ...
I never really approached this question the way others do. I've always held that by obeying the same grammar, which allows people to coherently formul...
Is there a loophole in this rule regarding using Gemini? Gemini is Google's AI algorithm that condenses a search result to a paragraph or two. Since G...
Yes, dare one say this approach was almost taken to "scientific" standards. Yet, I feel as though it was a work guided by sheer intelligence, to state...
Here is the quoted passage from the Investigations on what, seemingly, Wittgenstein continued in his methodology between his earlier period and latter...
I believe that what Wittgenstein was alluding to, in modern terminology, was the study of syntax and linguistics. In those fields, what Wittgenstein s...
I believe he meant it both ways at the time. Although people consider the first analytic philosopher as Bertrand Russell, I think the logical positivi...
I think, with what you said in mind, Wittgenstein was very strict, in the Tractatus, about drawing a line between science and philosophy, for reasons ...
I think that the practice of philosophy and the philosopher are one and the same, according to Wittgenstein's ethos. Yes, well the bewitchment of our ...
I don't consider ChatGPT an authority on issues; but, sometimes it can help inform an ill-construed thread about how the issue pertains to whatever qu...
Yes, this is something that is ambiguous about the Bible. Does God hand out evil as punishment or does this whole Satan guy do it instead or for Him, ...
Yet, evil exists, and is persecuted by God. Thus, God, who allowed evil to manifest in the world - must have disliked evil for it to be persecuted by ...
Yes, they are very fun animals. Too bad their meat is tasty. Look at these pigs, they're so pink and happy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=44LJAFrUss...
Comments