Julianne Carter

I’d like to critique your argument, specifically your use of the analogy of a tidy room to demonstrate the idea that God is responsible for the order ...

I’d like to provide a critique of your assertion that miracles are not evidence of the divine, and the counterexample that you use to illustrate that....

Interesting points about the role of Islam in this.

I would like to provide a critique of your claims that a theist has no evidence outside of their own belief, that nobody knows if God really exists, a...

I'd like to critique your argument, specifically the premise that reality is always better than the imagination, and that therefore God must exist in ...

I think that this argument has good potential, but there are a few points that I would like to critique, specifically regarding P1 and P2. P1 states t...

I’d like to critique two objections that you pose to Jackson’s argument: the first regarding Jackson’s assertions about Mary’s knowledge, and second, ...

This argument raises some intriguing points, and I’d like to critique them. You assert that God “never has nor never will strive because striving is a...

In order to critique this argument, I'll begin by restating it. Essentially, your assertion is that: 1. If God created the physical world along with t...

I'd like to make a critique of this argument. One issue is the association of a God with omnipotence. This argument has the implicit premise that a Go...