^But do you feel a sense of joy? like really 0 joy from giving money to poor people, You don't feel joy because you help people. Really? The Fact that...
^Hmmm more like Walking is a physical activities because it depleted energy. Is like Thinking is an mental activity because it produce thought, or Lik...
^You know it beforehand, Can we say it like this then, You want to give the poor dude money because you want to Help him, even though it will worry yo...
^Hmmm, the definiton of mental activities is "It is activity of the mind resulting in a collection of thoughts" can I say it is mental because those p...
So, you don't regret the fact that you give the money. Assume that it is true That's mean you don't feel displeasure if you don't give it. By worry wh...
Che! It seems I wont be able to proof PE. I found an article that state that "Unconscious Mental Activity" indeed happen, Contrary to what most of us ...
^Ahh that's it :D that's why I'm having trouble following you, because why are we arguing whether is it mental or not? Like at the basic , what is you...
^ It will be long, but that the "physical behavior" is called Contextual Priming. "contextual priming is a mechanism that provides still more precise ...
^You are having trouble because if PE was true then Charity is only an act of selfish which I can respect. But think of it this way, it is not more so...
^You're asking if because the the action of (From my previous post) is link to the post about Hammer Gripping, in which both are the example of Uncons...
^ Further supporting this notion of natural contextual tuning of one’s behavior to the present environment, cognitive research indicates that action-r...
1 of it, Taken from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2440575/ > Thus, as a default option or starting point for your own behavior, blindly...
^I agree that PE is unfalsifiable (for now), because it should be a conceptual not empirical. Because PE is a Tautology. The thesis of psychological e...
^ Well for now, then rebbuting point by point, I think is better to look at the core,1 by 1, one at a time which is 1) A man can find the action itsel...
^Yes, I think we can rooted by testing themselves mean to know more about them self, if they know about themselves they became happy. Some want for a ...
^Why do you think they want to embrace that hardship? is it for the hardship sake, or because they desire another thing that could be get from that ha...
^Hmmm again ( / w \ ) you could rooted to pleasure. K how's this then, give me a "Motivation" to do something, that couldn't be rooted to "happiness" ...
^ I agree,You can say that. But you can rooted "Duty" to "Pleasure and Pain", But you can't exactly rooted "Pleasure/Pain" Because when you are left w...
^Fair enough, But let's talk Novelty right now, that paper is done in 2004, in 2004 people still debating that. Now, is 2018 and people still debating...
^Yes, and again, Up until now, there are still no evidence that that One Person exist. Because when you "Theory Worshiping" You can break down those c...
^Well, I'm talking about PsychologicalHedonism though, but point taken. But no, that's not a strict hedonist. I would call that stupid hedonist. Becau...
^Very Well, Then we need a research that does that right, or at least the paper from a people who know this better. at least any evidence to support t...
"In the empiricist view, one can claim to have knowledge only when based on empirical evidence (although some empiricists believe that there are other...
^Well, a smart people choose "Higher Pleasure" and unwise people choose "Lesser Pleasure". We drink bitter medicine, because we want to avoid the bigg...
^The thing with evidence is. You can disproof a theory if you give a disprove evidence. You can also proof a theory if you give an evidence to proof. ...
^Umm, why is that wrong exactly, "Interpretation" like that is needed and used you know, Psychologist who use Psychoanalysis does this. When their pat...
^What if I say if we look deeper, the thing with people with "Duty" is they feel happy when "They Done their Good Duty" (A Dopamine Release because of...
^Yes, that is Indeed the problem. But let me make an affirmation of your statement, if I'm wrong about it, feel free to correct it. Your view is "God ...
^ I elaborate, in the rebuttal below. ^No, it would contradict God Character (The Righteous Character, and He is no God if He contradicts His Characte...
^That's why Philosopher, Politician, And Parent have trouble with a concept called "Freedom To Choose" ^ To remove it, mean God will become a Corrupte...
^Yes, it is sad, Like in court, If we sin, we need to "Pay" something so that those sin could be forgiven. Like in real life case, if you murder someo...
^Yep, I'm implying, according to the Judeo-Christian view, no Good Things you do, or even if you have your life marked by Good Things. That fact (the ...
^ The H with that tradition, if a man SO DIRE IN NEED TO DRINK, suddenly found himself in a church at mass, and at that time you only have holy water,...
^YES, yes, that's the reason why Judeo-Christian said to you "No matter how good you're, it is not enough" Yes! ^In that regard, there is a need to do...
Comments