You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

SophistiCat

Comments

Here is one that has an actual philosophical background. Serenade after Plato's Symposium is probably my favorite of Leonard Bernstein's works. Though...
October 22, 2025 at 01:24
Welcome to the forum! It is only exponential if the rate remains constant, and even then it will never become infinite. Anyway, if your point is that ...
October 15, 2025 at 15:55
No problem, and thank you for your response (I am not usually so impatient...). I have listened to some of Emerson's podcasts before, even though I am...
October 14, 2025 at 00:08
'Artificial' is not the same as 'unnatural' or 'supernatural', even though all of these words are contrasted to 'natural'. Artificial means made by hu...
October 13, 2025 at 14:31
Since the OP won't answer my question, can anyone else explain what he is talking about? @"Count Timothy von Icarus"? What does it mean for an experie...
October 13, 2025 at 00:04
And this "Notturno" is just impossibly gorgeous... https://youtu.be/-kq4GcsIG5w?si=4mL2TVikaYtWPhR0
October 12, 2025 at 13:25
Huh, I was just listening to Chopin's nocturnes in Sokolov's rendition the other day: https://youtu.be/R26K_gn5Sv8?si=2paqVAALgCIJfpuO
October 12, 2025 at 13:02
You ask us to assume this for the sake of an argument, but the rest of your post proceeds as if this was the only live option, save for "two unsatisfy...
October 12, 2025 at 00:21
I am not seeing your point, but whatever. You are entitled to your prejudices.
October 11, 2025 at 15:24
Unlike handing it to a human editor, which is what authors have been doing for yonks?
October 11, 2025 at 14:18
Well, it looks like you've already gone deep into the rabbit hole. There is a disturbingly rapid accumulation of reports of "AI psychosis", in which A...
October 10, 2025 at 00:42
Welcome to the forum! Don't be discouraged by the lack of prompt feedback - you are not being "shadow-banned," it's just that not all threads attract ...
October 09, 2025 at 00:25
I'll leave it to you to figure out. But first, you need to understand that if your definition implies that you perform a miracle every time you tie yo...
October 07, 2025 at 10:55
I believe that I can prove that a pig is a kind of dog. A dog is an animal with four legs and a tail. A pig is an animal with four legs and a tail. Th...
October 06, 2025 at 19:20
Of course, but the point I was trying to make was that the question of cognitivism vs non-cognitivism is an analytical question that does not really g...
September 29, 2025 at 02:01
When asked their opinion on an ethical question, non-cognitivists do not literally say "boo!" or "hurray!" do they? In any event, whatever language th...
September 21, 2025 at 21:17
You are right, this is a very personal list. Not even a recommendation, more like a fact of Calvino's biography. For that reason, it doesn't sit well ...
September 12, 2025 at 20:46
I think emotivism can meet the open question challenge. A straightforward response would be to cache it out in terms of degrees of belief. That is to ...
September 09, 2025 at 02:23
OK, but I don't see how this follows: What do you mean by "me becoming human"? Before you were born, was there Dogbert protoconsciousness inhabiting n...
September 07, 2025 at 23:47
Likelihood, in its usual sense, is the probability of something being the case given a theory of how things work. So, for instance, the likelihood of ...
September 07, 2025 at 20:50
The question in the OP is much too broad to be interesting, since the word "system" has multiple meanings, and those meanings are in turn quite genera...
August 25, 2025 at 20:46
Well, as I said, "social physics" may be a new discipline, but the phenomena that it studies and the uses to which it is put are as old as society its...
August 13, 2025 at 10:15
It is not clear to me what your worry is: is it simply the fact that our choices can be predictable, or is it that this predictability can be exploite...
August 11, 2025 at 23:36
I was just citing a perfect cipher as a proof of concept. Regardless of the intention of the sender, when all you have is a single message, it is enti...
August 08, 2025 at 00:27
The message need not even be nonsense to be indecipherable. There is such a thing as a perfect cipher, e.g. a one-time pad.
August 07, 2025 at 22:10
It occurred to me that there is a parallel here with some realist and anti-realist positions in metaethics. One influential but controversial position...
August 04, 2025 at 00:54
To my mind, identity is a concept with fuzzy boundaries, but at the same time, invariance over time and space is an important part of it; identity is ...
August 03, 2025 at 20:24
We all go through an imperfect transporter, literally every moment of our lives. Your body is not physically identical to itself from one moment to an...
August 03, 2025 at 15:17
Not what I asked.
August 02, 2025 at 14:15
"Fake" is not a negation. The negation of "is a painting" would be "is not a painting," rather than "is a fake painting." What does "fake fake" mean, ...
August 02, 2025 at 13:07
In fact, we never do ask such a question. That's not a speculative thesis, but an observation about actual causal talk. Under normal conditions, ice f...
August 01, 2025 at 01:39
Don't feed the troll spammer.
July 30, 2025 at 00:16
First of all, Aristotle and Darwin were not answering the same question. Aristotle was offering a broad and rough classification of different types of...
July 30, 2025 at 00:13
Yes, in the most general sense, "cause" and "reason" can be used interchangeably, and Aristotle's four causes are better understood as a classificatio...
July 28, 2025 at 00:30
Causation is a useful everyday notion, but it is perhaps best thought of as a heuristic shortcut, rather than a sharp feature of the world. If you ask...
July 27, 2025 at 20:34
There are established usages of the word 'causation', both in ordinary language and in specialized domains. Capturing these usages in a single, all-en...
July 27, 2025 at 16:30
Mass shootings aren't a real problem. Well, not compared to all the other shootings. If you wave a magic wand and end all mass shootings in the US onc...
July 26, 2025 at 02:02
https://images.saatchiart.com/saatchi/63358/art/10709871/9772341-NMUMKGQV-7.jpg Not this (or so it says :))
July 17, 2025 at 21:27
I think you are jumping to answers too quickly. Let us slow down and try to understand the question first. The mark of higher consciousness (as distin...
July 17, 2025 at 01:18
Hello and welcome to the forum! This is a meaty first post, but I would like to start with a clarifying question. Just what do you mean by a choice be...
July 16, 2025 at 00:21
What are you expecting from this discussion? The position that you outlined is pretty much orthodox contemporary panpsychism. You could have just writ...
July 15, 2025 at 16:38
Not sure what your wiki reference is supposed to add here. So, it's a Hong Kong newspaper with a dubious reputation. The journo is referencing anonymo...
July 12, 2025 at 11:30
It would, yes, but the contention that China's top diplomat made such a blunt and frank declaration to the EU's top diplomat sounds extremely implausi...
July 11, 2025 at 22:04
So, what happens if nature violates its laws? Does it get a ticket? This obvious parallel with human-instituted laws is unfortunate (and it's probably...
July 07, 2025 at 11:22
I know that, but I note that you keep evading the questions that challenge that thesis. That's not the criticism, at least not from me. The criticism ...
July 06, 2025 at 16:08
We do, of course, actively discover order when we look for it, be it in our natural environment or in artificial constructs. But the other kind of pat...
July 06, 2025 at 15:25
I don't think that the question of determinism vs indeterminism is relevant to teleology. Again, if you think of the most ordinary examples, although ...
July 05, 2025 at 17:22
Yes, I meant it in the way the OP problematized the issue: "no particular outcome is necessary." A species may experience selective pressures, but its...
July 05, 2025 at 14:21
I wonder why you picked astrology as an example, rather than astronomy? Would you consider them more-or-less on the same footing, and if not, why not?
July 05, 2025 at 00:17
I understand that this is your view, and this is what prompted my questions above (and likewise, @"Patterner"'s questions). Do you have any thoughts o...
July 05, 2025 at 00:13