DifferentiatingEgg

You know full well your concept is predicated in fallacy and continue to defend it is disingenuous, and more or less a passive insult to everyone who ...

Hehe, well, to be fair, Nietzsche says reading is a vicious activity for someone in their prime... and I was trying to give the impression of heavy ha...

Who said anything about Hegel? We're talking of the double orbit of Heraclitus, geesh, the incitation of opposites to higher and higher births. And it...

I gave you a taste of yourself? I don't see you that way, but I don't really care that you do or don't agree. But now you know how you appear. Appeara...

Not really worried about agreeing with a man who resents Nietzsche all because he's no good at understanding Nietzsche's philosophy. Being in agreemen...

Not much to talk about other than your argument being predicated in fallacy. Especially the Is-Ought. That you've perpetuated the farce of this discus...

Nietzsche pretty much details Jesus as a master moralist in AC 33 and 39 and the only true Christian :wink: Nietzsche's fight wasn't against Christian...

Aye he comes with the dithyrambs instead! The dithyrambs are literary music, meant to incite a person into a certain creative self abnegated state whe...

Amor Fati is Nietzsche's equation that replicates the Glad Tidings of Jesus Christ. And we can see from AC 39 and 33 precisely how highly Nietzsche re...

Aye, but we killed that way of life...thats what Nietzsche means ... and the rise in Nihilism from the death of that way of life is what concerned Nie...

the funny bit being really that you were too short sighted to see how your insult fell flat. Nietzsche praises their architecture actually.

...Those are through the lens of your Christian values. Not Nietzsche's values which reflected much from the ancient Grecian culture.

You stole all my other points, and with such legit stylistics! :sweat: Nietzsche was the first to unmask the Judaeo-Christian morality system. As far ...

That's putting it lightly. In the prologue to Beyond Good and Evil Nietzsche declares the most protracted error of Plato was dogmatism and that came t...

Yeah, so, you do use Is-ought fallacy as per post 1. Nothing more to really discuss here.

Ah, see, I knew there was an Is Ought Fallacy in there somewhere... "Existence is, thus it ought to be good."

, so are you by saying "good should be" is more along the lines of maximizing good but minimizing bad? If so then I can see what you're saying. Cause ...

then you're not really making an argument just making a hypothetical that couldn't happen. If Bad shouldn't exist then niether should Good since they'...

And you said be = exist. Thus good should exist bad should not exist (to you) You have a fundamental problem because bad exists. We observe human natu...

How can bad not exist when what is good and what is bad is determined by what is within us? You can't reconcile the devaluation of Good by removing th...

You've not presented a counter argument. Make a p1 and p2 and C that necessarily follows.

My man, I proved it logically in my P1 P2 C statement. Good and Bad should be. Since you can't have good without bad. You're trying to sneak around th...

It's idealic, you're pretending good should be and thus bad wont be. You're trying to kill off half of human nature by saying it shouldn't exist. It w...

The highest presentment of humanity seems always to be through crime. Oedipus, Prometheus, Adam and Eve. For some, what is "good" is literally that wh...

No, because this means what shouldn't exist is "bad." It "shouldn't" but it does. And without that which shouldn't be there would be no Good. Due to a...

Well scams inherently feel bad but can be aimed at doing great things. A person who donates for x but that donation goes to y. There are historical ex...

They exist together or not at all is my point. And what's good for me may be bad for you. Can you have a "Good" without defining "Bad" if valuation is...

The whole error of the OP is in your definition of "good." It's merely an occasion sentence. Further morality also measures what is bad too. And what ...

Again you're dishonest, I allowed for your own room for interpretation to your own perspective. But when you declare that as Nietzsche's own then you'...

You are as stupid as you are dishonest. You asked for the quotes idiot. Pretty simple it logically follows that if you dont want sourced quotes dont s...

Can you though? You forgot that you even asked for direct quotes cause you got inflamed. Then you tried to insult me for not having a sensible interpr...

Im on a forum about philosophy, that doesn't make me a philosopher. But I'm sure as hell more of one than you are language or not. I don't mind meetin...

:lol: You're not very good with logic are you? You got butthurt the moment I corrected your notion of Nietzsche's philosophy aiming at long life and h...

I gave you my interpretation straight away. That feeling of excitement, of feeling alive from living dangerously. And I gave you the aphorisms to show...

The point is, you blustery gust, is that your philosophy doesn't mean shit when we are discussing Nietzsche's philosophy. :wink:

You're silly, an interpretation doesn't mean taking something to not even a legitimate bastardization, and then declaring what people think of Nietzsc...

I really didn't want to do this, but the reply feels relatively indignant especially with that dogshit you wrote at the end there attempting to insult...

Here's what Quine says about it in Pursuit of Truth Chapter 3 Meaning § 20: "The difference between taking a sentence holophrastically as a seamless w...

I literally just used what you taught me in conversation... someone throwing a red herring in a debate because I mispoke on an accusation but didn't c...

He was, but I'm not very read on him, so it was an interesting insight. I'll be getting around to writing a large piece about Nietzsche here soon that...

I appreciate that answer as it gives quite an informative reference towards Nietzsche's "Will to Power," and what he had been considering.

What does this imply about the body then?

I was referring to that event in the OP. Apologies for the poor clarity there.

You're doing it, right here, right now... There is no right or wrong approach to it truthfully.

The inherent limitations of logic allow for it to collapse inwards upon itself forming a self-referential (fractal, more or less) cave (Godel). I'm of...

Have you tried analytic philosophy? A good deal of it is about overcoming this very notion which means very very little in the grand scheme of things....

Hey, just cause Nietzsche details his values doesn't mean you can't hold life and pleasure at a higher value. Nietzsche equates life to the will to po...

Renaming the apple.

We can start with Thus Spoke Zarathustra Prologue Section 3 that expresses the sensation caused by the "Lightning" through reification we can empathiz...

Ah, very well, please permit me the time to produce a detailed (but straight forward) account for you, if you would. This way I give a more complete p...