You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

For Starters, A Moral Crankshaft And Then...

TheMadFool June 17, 2020 at 08:13 1500 views 3 comments
For me, a device of extraordinary ingenuity, a product of unparalleled genius, is the humble crankshaft. If I'm correct, what it does is nothing less than miraculous - translates linear motion into rotational motion. It's found in all engines and converts the linear motion of the pistons into, ultimately, circular motion of the wheels.

Imagine evil is represented by the linear motion of the pistons and good by the circular motion of the wheels. Is it possible at all to invent and put into action a moral crankshaft which converts all evil thoughts, speech and deeds into good? For those with different "tastes", the converse maybe more appealing.

The fact that the analogy is not perfect is not lost on me but I'm sure everyone will know, without the slightest difficulty, what I'm getting at.

Comments (3)

180 Proof June 17, 2020 at 10:58 #424603
Quoting TheMadFool
Imagine evil is represented by the linear motion of the pistons and good by the circular motion of the wheels. Is it possible at all to invent and put into action a moral crankshaft which converts all evil thoughts, speech and deeds into good?

Sounds like an analogy for (xtian) theodicy - which is an apology for divinely permissable -teleological - "evil". Historical, as well as intellectual, track-record is highly problematic at best.
unenlightened June 17, 2020 at 11:30 #424606
Sounds like the invisible hand, whereby greedy selfish people do what we want them to do in order to enrich themselves.
TheMadFool June 23, 2020 at 20:00 #426986
Quoting 180 Proof
Sounds like an analogy for (xtian) theodicy - which is an apology for divinely permissable -teleological - "evil". Historical, as well as intellectual, track-record is highly problematic at best.


I didn't intend to get into religion. While I'm reluctant to fully endorse the belief that the ends justify the means, what I'm proposing here seems to lend support to it. Weapons are the first thoughts that come to mind - they're uneqivocally evil - their purpose to kill/maim but they can also be used to protect the weak and vulnerable. Another way of putting it is, can evil ever be a force of good?

Quoting unenlightened
Sounds like the invisible hand, whereby greedy selfish people do what we want them to do in order to enrich themselves.


Have a look at my response to 180 Proof.