You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

What is trolling exactly?

frank June 01, 2020 at 18:36 7625 views 33 comments
I've been cautioned yesterday and again today that I've been trolling and that I'm due to be banned for it. The moderator was Baden and he first said I should only post in the lounge until I was mature enough to engage in intellectual conversations on the main board. Then he changed his mind about that, but still threatened banning.

That's left me just a tad confused. My behavior is worse than average on this forum? I actually thought I was one of the more sane ones. What am I not seeing? Really, help me out:

What's trolling?

Comments (33)

frank June 01, 2020 at 18:40 #419061
So I'll give my half-assed answer. I thought trolling was when a person comes to a forum with no other plan than to derail conversations. IOW, they aren't engaging honestly.

What else is it?
Baden June 01, 2020 at 19:12 #419080
No, I didn't say you're due to be banned nor did I suggest that you're generally badly behaved. Yesterday, you called a post bullshit and then when asked for a reason said you didn't even read it. I can't think of a more trollish thing to do than that. It seems disingenuous to me you wouldn't recognize that, but fine.

Today, you came up with some excuse which I said I don't care about and that you (posters in general) don't troll on the site or you get banned. Period. That's a statement of fact regarding the rules not a statement of my intention to do anything. But whatever, feel free to continue this with someone else. I've already said I'd leave moderating you to others (if that happens to be necessary). That's all I have to say about it.
frank June 01, 2020 at 19:15 #419089
Reply to Baden
Cool. Could one of the other moderators lay out a definition of trolling used by this site? I was told I'd be banned if I trolled anymore and I honestly don't know what that means.
Baden June 01, 2020 at 19:27 #419098
Quoting frank
I was told I'd be banned if I trolled anymore


As above:

Quoting Baden
I said I don't care about and that you (posters in general) don't troll on the site or you get banned. Period. That's a statement of fact regarding the rules not a statement of my intention to do anything... I've already said I'd leave moderating you to others.
frank June 01, 2020 at 19:36 #419102
Reply to Baden There's a fair amount that's unclear here.

The post I didn't read was your attempt to draw me into a debate that I wasn't interested in. I read enough of it to discern that.

You PM'd me to tell me you were warning me about trolling. You were then bizarrely belligerent toward me as if you trying to make me angry.

When I asked Hanover to enter the conversation you said that he wouldn't "save" me.

Since I'm not getting any clarification, I take it that the trolling charge was just part of the harassment.
unenlightened June 01, 2020 at 19:45 #419106
As an ex admin, and ex mod, my axes are all well ground and my hatchets buried, along with the bodies. Trolls come in many flavours, but the essence, I would say, is to be a wind-up artist. The trick is to provoke the anger of the other, and then get all righteous about it. The best troll is adept at producing invisible flames.

Sometimes misunderstandings can be interpreted as trolling, so one has to look for a pattern of behaviour, rather than over-interpret a brief exchange. Sometimes trolls will make a big wind-up thing about what is and isn't trolling. Sometimes mods can behave like trolls.

Sometimes ex admin/mods indulge in a little light trolling by way of illustration.

frank June 01, 2020 at 20:46 #419124
Reply to unenlightened
Have you ever thought of writing a sequel to Alice in Wonderland?

I think there might be a sign in this of the difference between systemic and nonsystemic: people bring things into the light of day because they care and they think others care.

Under heavy systemic oppression people dont ask questions because there's no point. Disregard becomes internalized: I don't speak because I dont matter even to myself.
praxis June 01, 2020 at 21:08 #419134
Trolling is deriving amusement, or perhaps in some cases rubles, from riling up an unsuspecting audience. Good hooks are anything that questions a person's morality, status, intelligence, consistency, and things of that nature. Good hooks are subtle and practically force a response. Bad hooks are pathetically obvious (think @Chester) and easily ignored.
frank June 01, 2020 at 21:13 #419136
Reply to praxis :up:

People can troll by accident? Half consciously?
praxis June 01, 2020 at 21:14 #419137
Baden June 01, 2020 at 21:16 #419138
Reply to praxis

The systemic oppression is so heavy here we haven't yet banned @NOS4A2 and @Chester. We may have to up our game.
praxis June 01, 2020 at 21:18 #419139
Reply to Baden

That's just plain favoritism. :razz:
Punshhh June 01, 2020 at 21:19 #419140
Reply to frank I think the problem is your surrealist turn of phrase. It can catch people out and they think it's something else.
frank June 01, 2020 at 21:21 #419141
Reply to Punshhh Are you serious?
Baden June 01, 2020 at 21:22 #419142
I'm sorry I was mean to frank everyone. When he said he was calling Hanover for help with a sad face emoji, it sounded like a joke and I responded with an lol. The idea of Hanover saving anyone sounds inherently amusing to me. But apparently my response was harassful oppression, so I apologize.
Baden June 01, 2020 at 21:24 #419144
And I'm sure frank's PMs to me claiming he was concerned I was drunk were not an attempt to annoy me so he could claim he was being harassed. I need to see the good in people more.
frank June 01, 2020 at 21:25 #419145
Reply to Baden It's not everyday somebody hands you an opportunity to show some character.

Baden June 01, 2020 at 21:25 #419146
Reply to frank

I think we just don't understand each other tbh. That's all there is to it.
frank June 01, 2020 at 21:35 #419149
Eh, the whole PM:

Baden: You're on a warning now for trolling.

frank: Ok.

Baden: Maybe just stay out of the thread seeing as you can't even handle reading posts.

Baden: As I'm sure you'll understand, it's pointless people responding to you as you may not even know what they said. Go play in the lounge or something.

frank: Gosh.

frank: Serious question: are you drinking right now?

Baden: No, it's not a serious question,frank. It's not any more serious than you pretending to read my post and then calling it bullshit. Go play in the lounge for a day or two. You can come back when you've grown up. This thread is on serious matter and I'm not going to let you troll it.

frank: Ok. Bye.

frank: @Hanover: Baden is harrassing me. :sad:

Baden: :lol: You don't get to troll my thread. Hanover can't (and is unlikely to try) to save you. Good try anyway.

An hour later:

Baden: Tell you what, you can post there if you want but do not respond to any of my posts. Talk to posters you want to engage with in an intellectually honest way only.

frank: Ok. Baden, you suggested that black citizens should take up arms to protect themselves from the police. I see gun shot wounds on the regular, so I found your comment to be incredibly offensive.

Yesterday I had two of them: one GSW to the abdomen and one to the chest. I honestly dont comprehend why you are the one taking up outrage here. It makes no sense at all to me except if you're intoxicated. So it was a serious question.

But I agree. You and I should just ignore one another here on out. We have nothing to gain through discussion.

7 hours later

Baden: I don't give a damn what you find offensive, you don't troll or you get banned. Period.

Baden: And by the way, fdrake said exactly the same thing I did about communities arming themselves and your response to him was "nice talking to you", so please don't continue with the disingenuousness. You were just being petty.

frank: I'm sorry. Be well, stay safe.

praxis June 01, 2020 at 21:36 #419150
Quoting Baden
he was concerned I was drunk


To be fair, you are Irish, right?
Baden June 01, 2020 at 21:37 #419151
Reply to praxis

:lol: It all makes sense now.
Baden June 01, 2020 at 21:43 #419153
Reply to frank

As I said, frank, I realize now you were genuinely concerned about my well-being in asking me if I was drunk as you were the time when you said you thought I sounded stressed and all the rest was just a misunderstanding on my part. And, of course, this thread is a genuine attempt to uncover the systemic oppression on this site. As I've indicated, I won't mod you anymore and actually I shouldn't mod anyone I interact with, so you have my apologies and please do keep fighting your good fight.
frank June 01, 2020 at 21:45 #419154
Quoting Baden
so you have my apologies


That
is some motherfuckin character.

:blush:

edit: translated from American: thank you. you're awesome.
Baden June 01, 2020 at 21:46 #419155
Reply to frank

Thank you, frank. :up:
NOS4A2 June 01, 2020 at 21:53 #419159
Reply to Baden

I will do all I can to abide by the rules, and I recognize and respect your authority to police this forum as you see fit. But I can honestly say I have never nor do I intend to troll anyone. I just enjoy grappling over ideas with people who I assume can think. Perhaps there is a fine line.
Changeling June 01, 2020 at 22:00 #419161
@frank predator is the trolliest troll on here.
Changeling June 01, 2020 at 22:03 #419163
Whereas, @Frank Pray is a pillar of society.
praxis June 01, 2020 at 23:07 #419176
Reply to NOS4A2

Fortunately for you then, a lack of self-awareness doesn't violate the Term of Service.
frank June 01, 2020 at 23:22 #419182
Changeling June 02, 2020 at 03:12 #419246
Reply to frank According to the franchise, aliens from distant planets/galaxies just look like people but with weird mouths.
Outlander June 02, 2020 at 03:14 #419248
frank June 02, 2020 at 03:45 #419265
Quoting Professor Death
According to the franchise, aliens from distant planets/galaxies just look like people but with weird mouths.


Plus they work out a lot. Bad luck on the mouth, though.
Baden June 02, 2020 at 04:10 #419276
I'm guessing we can close this now as the main issue seems to have been resolved.