You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

Mayanexus - An experimental research technique

Blurrosier October 03, 2019 at 17:19 3575 views 9 comments
I'm working on a method of research that I would love opinions/feedback on, a method that, I hope, may be found to be of use to similarly inclined individuals.

Using Numbers, the Mac spreadsheet program, as a timeline, one can develop/refine their conception (?) of our history by means of situating "important" figures within their historical context. The cells enumerated vertically, the top row being 1 and the bottom row being 2019, such an important figure's representation spans vertically from the year they were born to the year they perished. Thus, Karl Marx's "bar" stretches from 1818 down to 1883, with Engels' bar, spanning 1820-1895 and situated next to Marx's, beginning two cells below the top of Marx's and ending twelve after the end of Marx's.

In each cell of a figure's bar, a note, with no apparent length/character capacity, can be added, allowing the grapher to integrate their notes on Marx's "On the Jewish Question" into its respective cell on his bar.

The vertical axis denoting time, the horizontal is a bit more dynamic, in this case denoting content-of-thought, as perhaps a more broad way of saying field or subject matter. Of course, this dimension seems, to me, to be more subjectively inclined (?), seeing as the works of Marx and Spivak may seem more related to the grapher than the works of Marx and Said (to use perhaps too thin and arbitrary an example). However, I've found that such conflicts, if persistently contemplated, seem to coalesce (?) into a natural (?) structure, perhaps irrespective of the grapher's intentions.

In any case, I felt the need to do this largely because of my innate difficulty framing events and people along a macro, or a micro, timeline, and this, as a project, has significantly strengthened such a weakness. I've found that there is, in fact, a limit to the amount of cells permitted in a single spreadsheet, a discovery which, in retrospect, perhaps should not have come as a surprise.

Also, not sure how to best share these files - but this seems promising:

https://megashare.megahd.com.br/29Qb (numbers)
https://megashare.megahd.com.br/29Qd (excel)

If there is any interest in viewing/editing, but difficulty downloading, either of these files, please let me know and I can figure out other ways.

Here are some screenshots:

User image

User image

User image

User image

User image

User image

User image

User image

User image

User image


Anyway, seeing how much this has streamlined my understanding (in both extensive and intensive capacities), I would like to hear what others may have to say about it. Perhaps it's much more a personal project that I happen to be proud of than something with any epistemic/academic potential, or perhaps others merely have an easier time framing people/events in their historical context than I do. In any case, feedback would be wonderful. In my eyes, as close to this as I am, and as much time I have put into it as I have, here are the potential benefits from such a method:

-juxtaposition between fields/disciplines/etc; connections and parallels drawn, influences and movements mapped.
-increased familiarity (which, even uninformed, I believe is worth something) with such figures/idea gained by moving/reorienting them along the horizontal axis, pairing them in different clusters, etc.
-perhaps the ability frame as much of our recorded history a possible, as embodied by its players, onto a single spreadsheet, and thus the refining of ones macro-image of history.

A lot of the benefit comes from the creating process, rather than the mere utilization of it as a product of someone else's. It forces the grapher to organize (?), or, in any case, arrange figures in their ideal positions, which perhaps is always an ongoing task, seeing as how people, and their ideas, develop.

Having just joined this forum minutes ago, and perhaps not being sufficiently familiar with the content of the various categories, I thought it acceptable to post this in the political philosophy section, seeing as it has a largely Marxist slant.

Comments (9)

Atlas August 20, 2020 at 18:51 #445006
@Blurrosier
Doesn't look like the downloads work anymore, any chance you could give me a new link?
I would PM this instead, but the button is greyed out for me on profiles, probably because my account it new.
Blurrosier August 20, 2020 at 22:26 #445077
Just uploaded this to google drive, which should work. It is a numbers file, so if you need it in Excel, just let me know.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iRjN2x0GNnMb2vY26-6kcdIqfbUldJzi/view?usp=sharing
Atlas September 16, 2020 at 14:27 #452822
@Blurrosier

Thanks, could I get the excel version instead?
(Sorry for taking a while to check back, been busy)
Blurrosier September 22, 2020 at 02:22 #454684
@Atlas

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1TcNWvU0vpHkL1h0PCX7v2x-veI7h4-qi/view?usp=sharing

This should work, if not let me know.

In converting it to excel, some of the images and background colors in the cells were lost. Not sure what else changed.
Atlas September 28, 2020 at 18:57 #457112
Reply to Blurrosier Thanks, I sent a request to download the file.
Atlas September 29, 2020 at 20:12 #457366
Reply to Blurrosier The pictures, although nice, aren't that big a deal. However, it seems that a lot of the notes have been broken as well :sad:

This is still a really cool idea though, I wish I had a mac so I could see the full thing.
Blurrosier September 29, 2020 at 22:32 #457406
Yeah I feared that would happen. I might just start a new one on Google Sheets, which I think would prevent this kind of sharing difficulty in the future. If I get that one running, I'll share it with you.
Blurrosier September 29, 2020 at 22:33 #457407
The loss of notes is a drag, as I had excerpts from various papers/texts, and had them all organized in this kind of manual tagging system. I'll see what I can preserve from the old one when I make the new one.
Atlas October 05, 2020 at 14:54 #459014
Reply to Blurrosier I'd definitely be interested in getting a copy of that! Going for a more widley shared format than .numbers might be good if you're looking to share spread it around as well.
Good luck!