You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

How many fingers do you see?

TheMadFool August 04, 2017 at 05:32 4150 views 9 comments
This is a painting by Michiel van Musscher. It is titled as Portrait of a Lady with her dog and a maid

My question is: How many fingers do you see, including the lady and her maid, excluding the dog.

PLEASE LOOK CAREFULLY

User image

Thank you for your time.

Comments (9)

Sir2u August 05, 2017 at 02:42 #93179
16 fingers and 3 thumbs.
That will be $20 for the account of digits.
TheMadFool August 05, 2017 at 03:36 #93192
Quoting Sir2u
16 fingers and 3 thumbs.


Can you look carefully at the maid's right hand. The finger(A) between the thumb and index finger is not right. If you zoom in you'll see that A doesn't align with the middle finger as it should.
Sir2u August 06, 2017 at 02:58 #93548
Quoting TheMadFool
Can you look carefully at the maid's right hand. The finger(A) between the thumb and index finger is not right. If you zoom in you'll see that A doesn't align with the middle finger as it should.


That is not her finger.
It is treat that she is trying to tempt the dog with.
TheMadFool August 06, 2017 at 03:04 #93554
Quoting Sir2u
That is not her finger.
It is treat that she is trying to tempt the dog with.


:-} it's a fine interpretation. I didn't think of that.

It looks like she's snapping her fingers to get the dog's attention AND why does the ''treat'' look like a finger? And she's not looking at the dog
Sir2u August 06, 2017 at 03:42 #93562
Quoting TheMadFool
It looks like she's snapping her fingers to get the dog's attention


With her middle finger?

Quoting TheMadFool
why does the ''treat'' look like a finger? And she's not looking at the dog


Who knows, maybe it is!!!
TheMadFool August 06, 2017 at 04:33 #93574
Quoting Sir2u
With her middle finger?


How else can we snap our fingers?
Sir2u August 06, 2017 at 04:51 #93577
Quoting TheMadFool
How else can we snap our fingers?


I don't do it like that, I have both fingers together. Anyway nowadays I only use my middle finger for .............. I'll let you guess about that.
TheMadFool August 06, 2017 at 05:00 #93578
TheMadFool August 06, 2017 at 10:39 #93613
Quoting Sir2u
Who knows, maybe it is!!!


If it's a finger it's either a mistake or deliberate.

It can't be a mistake because the rest of the painting is done in meticulous detail and anatomically correct.

So, it has to be deliberate.

Now, why would the painter paint an extra digit?