You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

Responsible citizenship

Athena January 15, 2026 at 03:56 575 views 10 comments
My local news station has frequently followed my suggestions for news stories, and I am writing to encourage you do the same.

We need to remind those who give us news that their job requires them to investigate the stories, vet them, and then tell us the whole story without bias. Our reporters are essential to defending our democracy, and they need help realizing how important they are.

Today, only 1 out of 5 supports Trump taking Greenland for security reasons. We need to reduce that number, and the way to do that is be sure everyone knows that at the start of the Cold War, the US made an agreement with Greenland and established a base there, defending all the countries that are part of NATO. There is no need for us to take Greenland away from Denmark. Not with the already established united effort to defend the allies and the US military presence that is already there.

Please, encourage your local reporters to investigate, vet, and present the whole story. No argument necessary. Just better information.

Comments (10)

LuckyR January 15, 2026 at 06:25 #1035429
A wonderful, yet archaic opinion. Alas, here in the Post Truth era the purpose of "media" is to conduct "research" to find "data" that supports the pre-determined (and convenient) "conclusion" that was arrived at before the exercise started.
Tom Storm January 15, 2026 at 07:34 #1035432
Reply to LuckyR There's always been a war on truth in the media, a feature I’ve observed for decades, and it was even worse when we had consistent enemies like godless communists, war protesters, and drug users to hate with impunity. It’s somewhat more expertly organised than before, using tools borrowed from earlier sensationalist, untruthful media barons like Beaverbrook, Hearst, Pulitzer, Harmsworth, and, more recently, Murdoch.

Quoting Athena
we need to remind those who give us news that their job requires them to investigate the stories, vet them, and then tell us the whole story without bias.


I guess I’ve never entirely subscribed to the view that there is a truth which mirrors nature, or a position on an event that is without bias. I agree that stories are often slanted in particular directions and that they might suit a particular narrative, but I recognise that my version of a given story or event does the same thing. Because it reflects my values, I tend to think of it as “more truthful”.

What I want from the media are stories that reflect complexity and, as you say, something like a 'whole story', with context and a sense of balance. But one problem with journalism is that the public enjoys outrage and clickbait. I’m not sure there’s much money in balance. While I don’t think we can remove bias, I think we can do better by providing more sophisticated, less sensationalised accounts of events.
AmadeusD January 15, 2026 at 18:57 #1035512
This really is a lounge thread, Athena.
LuckyR January 16, 2026 at 05:55 #1035644
Reply to Tom Storm You're correct that media has always slanted their stories towards their bias. But that was commonly through omission. Now in the Post Truth era, out and out untruths or lies are pedaled as true. There's a difference.
Tom Storm January 16, 2026 at 06:15 #1035646
Reply to LuckyR There's not staggeringly different, that’s why I mentioned famous and popular publishers from 100 years ago who printed lies and defamations every single day. And it wasn't by omission, it was blatant phoney narratives. Hearst and Pulitzer famously made up atrocities during the Spanish-American War of 1898, helping to sway the public. And God knows how many individuals were destroyed by fake news. Leo Frank was famously lynched by a mob when newspapers wrongly accused him of murder in 1913, and in the 1980s there was the notorious Central Park Five case where media reported on the guilt and criminal intent of some Latino and Black kids who were later proven innocent. There are endless historical examples of this. Mainstream media often used to print lies and untruths with cavalier disregard for the truth. Which is not the same thing as saying that all journalism has always been bad.
LuckyR January 17, 2026 at 06:33 #1035823
Reply to Tom Storm Yes, it was common before "professional" journalism standards (the Society of Professional Journalists released their first code of ethics in 1973). After that (until the current Post Truth era) was notable for bias mostly retreating to the omission bias I referenced. Of course, exceptions made headlines, like the Central Park 5, but did so because they were exceptions. Now lies from officials and their online media mouthpieces are routinely reported, but no longer attract headlines, instead shrugs, because of the erosion of the value of truth.
Tom Storm January 17, 2026 at 06:49 #1035825
Reply to LuckyR And part of the problem is that so many members of the public no longer seem to care for truth or accuracy, or only in 'my truth,' while the rest seem to be ideologically driven, self-righteous partisans of the left or right. So what hope do we have?
Athena January 17, 2026 at 13:45 #1035864
Well, folks, let us all trash the world and deny any responsibility for what is happening, because someone in the past did a bad thing, so there is no damn reason to do the right things. I hope that by the time this morning is over, I find a post that does not make me totally miserable. Wow, I never before realized what a miserable group of people you are. Thanks a lot for helping me realize the truth.
LuckyR January 18, 2026 at 05:26 #1036047
Reply to Tom Storm Oh yes. To be clear, in my experience the Post Truth era applies mainly to the populace and the media just provides what sells.
AmadeusD January 19, 2026 at 19:34 #1036290
Reply to Athena This tracks with your penchant for simply bashing anything you dislike. It is not surprising, given your stated worldviews rest on the assumption that everyone is wrong about everything you like.