You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

Nourishment pill

Deleted User March 21, 2024 at 18:56 3825 views 22 comments The Lounge
This user has been deleted and all their posts removed.

Comments (22)

javi2541997 March 21, 2024 at 19:33 ¶ #889744
Reply to Deleted user Your multiple choice object reminds me of a dietary supplement. It can help me whatsoever because it contains all the nourishment I need. I guess I would miss the taste of food per se. For example, I would use the nourishment pill in this way: I usually take tomato with olive oil for breakfast every morning. Although it is a good combination to start the day with, I know it doesn't hold all my mind and body needs, so in addition to my breakfast, I will take a nourishment pill to get vitamins, Taurine, Caffeine, etc.
Tom Storm March 21, 2024 at 22:47 ¶ #889796
Reply to Deleted user I am not a big fan of eating. I eat a couple of meals a day and sometimes just one. I enjoy 'recreational' meals but mostly eating is drudgery for me. If I could just take a pill I would love that. I told my mum this about 30 years ago. She laughed and told me that my grandfather had made the same point 30 years earlier.
180 Proof March 21, 2024 at 23:53 ¶ #889813
Quoting Deleted user
take the pill and eat every now and then

:up:
Vera Mont March 22, 2024 at 01:11 ¶ #889825
The preparation of food is sometimes rewarding; the cleaning up afterwards is a chore; the acquisition of ingredients is expensive and requires an effort, but not without its good moments.
The sharing of regular, scheduled meals is worth the effort; the pleasure of good food is a bonus. Of course, the pill could be tailored to specific dietary needs - but is it? Dining out on special occasions is something to anticipate and cherish; the odd spontaneous restaurant lunch or picnic outing is fun.
Medication is necessary, but I don't think we could make a daily occasion of taking a pill together.
Sir2u March 22, 2024 at 02:54 ¶ #889842
I'm with Vera on this one.

:up:
Tom Storm March 22, 2024 at 06:20 ¶ #889861
Quoting Vera Mont
Medication is necessary, but I don't think we could make a daily occasion of taking a pill together.


I don't generally eat meals with others as it happens. My partner and I maintain separate homes - I could never live with someone. Fortunately she feels the same and it has worked for many years. We eat together 2 or 3 times a week.
Deleted User March 22, 2024 at 13:48 ¶ #889951
This user has been deleted and all their posts removed.
Sir2u March 22, 2024 at 13:53 ¶ #889955
Quoting Deleted user
Some folks said they wouldn't take the pill. I wonder why :chin:


If it was a necessity then obviously everyone would take it, But it is not, therefore why deprive oneself of the pleasures attached to the ritual of eating.
Vera Mont March 22, 2024 at 13:56 ¶ #889956
Quoting Tom Storm
We eat together 2 or 3 times a week.


Would you still take the pill when you're together?
How about family gatherings at Thanksgiving and Christmas, or social events, like weddings and charity fund-raisers? Or just plain dinner parties with friends and colleagues? So many human bonding rituals are centered on the sharing of food.
Many people would not want a pill, simply because they enjoy eating; some even enjoy cooking, baking and selecting ingredients, never mind the pleasure of growing vegetables and fruit.
Deleted User March 22, 2024 at 14:04 ¶ #889962
This user has been deleted and all their posts removed.
Vera Mont March 22, 2024 at 16:31 ¶ #890019
Quoting Deleted user
I wanted to imply that you get all the negatives without getting the positives.

The negatives are optional. We can choose a wholesome diet and eat in moderation, just as we can choose to imbibe alcoholic beverages in moderation. The positives include far more than physical nourishment. Our bodies are constructed to use food: I wonder what would happen to the digestive system if it were deprived of substantial material to process.
Tom Storm March 22, 2024 at 22:04 ¶ #890075
Quoting Vera Mont
Would you still take the pill when you're together?


Yes, we often joke about what a drag having to rustle up a lunch is. I can see us popping a pill in the car together then going about our business without the need to disrupt our activities with a sit down meal. Wonderful.

Quoting Vera Mont
How about family gatherings at Thanksgiving and Christmas, or social events, like weddings and charity fund-raisers? Or just plain dinner parties with friends and colleagues? So many human bonding rituals are centered on the sharing of food.


Well, I am a little different to some people. I don't generally attend parties or dinners. Last dinner party I went to took place years ago. But I do sometimes go out to a restaurant with a friend. I have already written that I would reserve eating for the occasional 'recreational' meal. So if I wanted to celebrate something with good food, I would happily eat then.
Sir2u March 22, 2024 at 23:50 ¶ #890094
Quoting Deleted user
When I said "You can still eat stuff, but it would not give you any needed nourishment and would come with all the negatives of eating",


When I said it is not necessary I meant that taking the pill is not necessary because food still is available. So if I am not taking the pill I would still need nourishment even if it came with all the negatives of eating. But it would also have the benefits I mentioned

Quoting Deleted user
I wanted to imply that you get all the negatives without getting the positives.


You meant to imply but did not do so, so it does not count.

Quoting Deleted user
Wouldn't eating then be like smoking or at least like drinking beer?


Only if I ate and drank more that I needed excessively. But I would have a shitload more fun doing it than you would swallowing a pill.

Sir2u March 22, 2024 at 23:52 ¶ #890095
Quoting Tom Storm
So if I wanted to celebrate something with good food, I would happily eat then.


Quoting Deleted user
Wouldn't eating then be like smoking or at least like drinking beer?



Deleted User March 23, 2024 at 12:28 ¶ #890179
This user has been deleted and all their posts removed.
Vera Mont March 23, 2024 at 14:43 ¶ #890210
Hard to imagine sufficient fat and fiber packed into a pill one could swallow.
Today there are pills to provide the vitamins we need, which leaves just the pesky issue of caloric intake. An adult typically needs about 2000 calories per day, and even the most concentrated source (pure fat) can't make that many calories fit into a single pill.

Another down-side: employers would cut lunch hour to 2 minutes a day.
Sir2u March 24, 2024 at 00:33 ¶ #890317
Quoting Deleted user
The benefits being pleasure.


That is what life is all about, if you don't enjoy it what is the point of living it.

Quoting Deleted user
Or you could take a pill and avoid every downside of eating (bloating, toxins, phytic acid, heavy metals etc).


:chin: You forgot to include wear on teeth, wasted time cooking, having to use a truck to take the food to the shop, having to sit down for a few minutes to put food in your mouth, having to take a shit once in a while and probably a whole bunch of other reasons you should not eat. :smirk:
Sir2u March 24, 2024 at 00:34 ¶ #890318
Quoting Vera Mont
Another down-side: employers would cut lunch hour to 2 minutes a day.


Ain't that the truth. :rofl:
Deleted User March 24, 2024 at 12:20 ¶ #890373
This user has been deleted and all their posts removed.
Sir2u March 26, 2024 at 01:37 ¶ #890892
Quoting Deleted user
True, I remember reading that eating also damages DNA.


Sex to, maybe you could come up with a pill to stop the need for that as well.
Deleted User March 26, 2024 at 02:21 ¶ #890906
This user has been deleted and all their posts removed.
Hanover March 27, 2024 at 21:03 ¶ #891527
I would only eat the pill if I could still get scurvy. It's the only pleasure I have.