You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

Memetic Suicide

Agent Smith May 05, 2022 at 04:25 3575 views 19 comments
Suicide: Self-termination, a person takes his/her own life.

Memetic suicide: Self-refutation; an idea shooting itself in the foot; sawing off the very branch it sits on.

Examples of people suicide:

1. Harakiri/Seppuku (Samurai code)
2. Sylvia Plath (the Sylvia Plath effect)
3. Alan Turing
.
.
.

Examples of memetic suicide

1. Relativism
2. Logical positivism
.
.
.

Some ideas (memes that self-destruct) are like the ouroboros (snake eating itself) or like Marvin Minsky's useless machines.

Comments (19)

Angelo Cannata May 05, 2022 at 04:52 #690954
It depends how you conceive them. Anything can be considered self-destructive from perspectives that, in turn, can be considered self-destructive as well. As a consequence, even your OP can be considered self-destructive. The same way, somebody who is going to commit suicide can think that the real self-destructive ones are those who are going to stay alive. This is relativism, that you considered suicide.
javi2541997 May 05, 2022 at 04:52 #690955
Quoting Agent Smith
Harakiri/Seppuku (Samurai code)


While Harakari/Seppuku tend to be poetic and aesthetic. I see "memetic suicide" as unreasonable without any context, like it seems to appear when we are debating and suddenly we accidentally commit a self-refutation
Agent Smith May 05, 2022 at 05:18 #690961
Reply to Angelo Cannata :ok:

From a military strategist's POV, all personnel & equipment must be provided with a self-destruct button/cyanide capsule. Idea Wars!

Quoting javi2541997
While Harakari/Seppuku tend to be poetic and aesthetic. I see "memetic suicide" as unreasonable without any context, like it seems to appear when we are debating and suddenly we accidentally commit a self-refutation


Thesis & Antithesis cancel each other out and voila! Nuthin'!
Hillary May 05, 2022 at 06:13 #690981
Why does relativism kill itself?
Hillary May 05, 2022 at 06:18 #690982
Reply to Angelo Cannata

Interesting approach! So actually you commit suicide by staying alive? And by killing yourself you enter new life?
Hillary May 05, 2022 at 06:21 #690983
I've committed memetic suicide a 1000 times at least. I stick to the last meme though.
Agent Smith May 05, 2022 at 06:25 #690984
Quoting Hillary
I've committed memetic suicide a 1000 times at least.


Join the club mon ami! But I have a feeling I've died more times than you! I'm a pro at commiting suicide, political, philosophical, romantic, it's my schtick! :sad:
Hillary May 05, 2022 at 06:37 #690990
Quoting Agent Smith
I'm a pro at commiting suicide


:lol:

That's for sure a meme committing suicide...

What would be the reason for a meme to autodestruct?

Angelo Cannata May 05, 2022 at 07:08 #690996
Reply to Hillary
I thinkn it shouldn't be difficult to imagine situations perceived this way. Do I need to make examples?
Hillary May 05, 2022 at 07:21 #691000
Reply to Angelo Cannata

You mean serial big bangs? Being born in every one (or less) of them?
unenlightened May 05, 2022 at 07:36 #691006
Quoting Agent Smith
Marvin Minsky's useless machines.


Back in the sixties, we had to make one of those for a physics project. The joy of liberal education!
Agent Smith May 05, 2022 at 07:38 #691007
Quoting Hillary
What would be the reason for a meme to autodestruct?


"It simply can't bear to exist", from a psychological POV. It must be suffering in extremum.
Agent Smith May 05, 2022 at 07:39 #691008
Quoting unenlightened
Back in the sixties, we had to make one of those for a physics project. The joy of liberal education!


Can you teach me how to make one? How good is yer memory? Just some tips & pointers will suffice.
Hillary May 05, 2022 at 07:53 #691010
Quoting unenlightened
Back in the sixties, we had to make one of those for a physics project.


Yeah, I think I read about that school that exploded...
unenlightened May 05, 2022 at 08:01 #691015
An electric motor and a spring, basically. The difficulty is in getting the forces balanced so that the motor operates the finger with the strength to flick the switch while also tensioning the spring enough to pull it back afterwards. If i remember I had a very small toy motor geared down with a worm thread, and a coil spring from god knows where. But you could use a spiral spring too. The finger is just mounted on an axle that makes a 1/4 turn each time, and the lid works by gravity. Wooden box -easy to fit the bits to; an old cigar box in my case with the top cut in half and hinged.
Angelo Cannata May 05, 2022 at 09:13 #691047
Reply to Hillary
A suicide like a kamikaze might think that he is going to get the real life, while other ones who are too scared or decide not to sacrifice their life can be considered cowards by the kamikaze, remaining in a kind of life that actually is death. So, in that case, from that perspective, the coward who doesn't sacrifice his life like the kamikaze, is tbe one who is committing the real suicide, which is, depriving himself of the real true life.
Agent Smith May 05, 2022 at 09:16 #691048
Quoting Hillary
Back in the sixties, we had to make one of those for a physics project.
— unenlightened

Yeah, I think I read about that school that exploded...


:rofl:

Quoting unenlightened
An electric motor and a spring, basically. The difficulty is in getting the forces balanced so that the motor operates the finger with the strength to flick the switch while also tensioning the spring enough to pull it back afterwards. If i remember I had a very small toy motor geared down with a worm thread, and a coil spring from god knows where. But you could use a spiral spring too. The finger is just mounted on an axle that makes a 1/4 turn each time, and the lid works by gravity. Wooden box -easy to fit the bits to; an old cigar box in my case with the top cut in half and hinged.


Muchas gracias!
unenlightened May 05, 2022 at 11:07 #691059
Reply to Hillary There was a film about it, called "If".

https://www.imdb.com/video/vi1190773529/?playlistId=tt0063850&ref_=tt_pr_ov_vi
Hillary May 05, 2022 at 16:16 #691185
Reply to unenlightened

Not hard to tell which side I'd be on... Rick the rebel!