You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

How do certain songs make us nostalgic?

camuswetdream March 02, 2017 at 21:09 2775 views 3 comments Philosophy of Mind
I suppose this may be a question for psychologist to ponder, but I was wondering what your thoughts on this topic are. There are, to me at least, a great deal of songs that bring back floods of memories and emotions that can be described as nostalgic by nature. Some songs are so strong in this respect that they bring painfully vivid images of the past to my mind's eye of the times in which these songs were of relevance to my daily life. Why and how do you think this is the case? If you don't believe this is the case, please explain yourself.

Comments (3)

jkop March 04, 2017 at 02:12 ¶ #59081
Quoting camuswetdream
..songs that bring back floods of memories and emotions...


Hearing a sound can be like seeing a photograph of the past. As such it functions as a symbol in which you can recognize things and events of which you have memories; the sound evokes those memories, and nostalgia is typically a positive attitude to them.
BC March 04, 2017 at 06:19 ¶ #59095
Reply to camuswetdream Just as an odor can trigger very strong memories that have been silent for decades (or memories can trigger the experience of the odor), so it is with music: Music (like odor) is often remembered with strong emotional ties to other memories. A particular song might awake an odor, a very vivid picture, the feelings that went with it.

Music, places, people, things, odors, feelings... all kinds of memories, are linked in sometimes unpredictable ways. They are linked by literal physical connection among neurons. Sometimes the connections make sense, and sometimes are baffling.
TimeLine March 04, 2017 at 09:45 ¶ #59107
Quoting camuswetdream
Some songs are so strong in this respect that they bring painfully vivid images of the past to my mind's eye of the times in which these songs were of relevance to my daily life.


I am interested in why you say painfully vivid images. Why should you find pain as something you need to avoid? My absolute favourite album when I was young was 'The Distance to Here' by Live and I remember just how unique I was and how the album reflected my state of mind so many years back. As you get older, priorities and desires change so I see nostalgia - however the memories are induced whether it is musical or not - as an opportunity to reflect and remember where you went wrong and where you can improve.

When I went back to listen to the album recently, I realised I stuffed up later in life because I sacrificed my freedom consciously because I was lonely, so while trying to be like others I paid the price. When I listened to the lyrics of the album, I remembered who I was again and I have never been happier.

Give no mercy to your fear.