You are viewing the historical archive of The Philosophy Forum.
For current discussions, visit the live forum.
Go to live forum

I Never Was by Benkei

Baden August 02, 2021 at 14:52 1850 views 13 comments Short Story Competition
"Don't press that... "

The air decompressed with the sound of a paperback softly falling closed, instantiating as a subsonic tremor, so slight that nobody would remember hearing it a moment after it passed through the universe, filling up what went missing. The door to the lab opened and a dark-haired, Asian girl stuck in her head and looked twice. Nobody was there.

On the floor was a black, leatherbound notebook and a cheap BIC pen lying across its open page. She tried to pick up the notebook but couldn’t. Squinting, she noticed it was translucent and fading quickly. She started reading:

[i]Time travel was possible, he said. I believed him. So after I graduated from university with a physics degree I became his lab assistant. Professor Steinberg was obsessed with time travel. Now, years later, I realise I confused his obsession with intelligence and brilliance. He wanted to converge a segment of worldvolume into the same spacetime. That segment being himself because only an egomaniacal narcissist thinks that’s a good idea. I’m just here to take notes.

If all goes well he’ll meet himself at the exact same time and place where he was before. Sounds like [s]deja[/s] déjà vu when described like that but in reality it would be time travel. So déjà [s]vècu[/s] vécu really. Ah, screw French, I’m always struggling with the accents. Anyhoo, I’m writing this because we’re about to start our test and I’m afraid things won’t go as planned. It would be nice to know something will survive in this time even if things do go wrong. So I worry, because there are still too many unknowns. We saw particles disappear in our time, suggesting the worldline had collapsed on itself but we never found evidence where those particles went.

After what we thought were successful convergences of worldlines and worldsheets, Steinberg is ready to try it on himself. He generated enough exotic matter two years ago and through quantum entanglement created a “negative copy” of himself that, as he moved forward, would move backward in time. Or that’s the idea. By forcing a convergence of the worldvolume through a localized wormhole within the specific frame of reference of the lab, the negative copy, the self of four years ago and the present self would all be in one place. The four year old self would be nullified by the negative copy, resulting in the present self remaining in place at the convergence two years in the past. Sounds great in theory.

We’ve tested so often I dream about the tests – each slightly different but eerily familiar and entirely realistic. Come to think of it, I always had a sense of being there before. It got so bad I was daydreaming for a while too. I can’t even recall how often I misplaced things because of it. I’d place my laptop on a chair only to find it on a desk in the spot where it was when I dreamt about it. Or the other way around, I can’t really recall. It’s all a bit blurry really. Well, gotta go and flip a switch.[/i]

The notebook and pen deconstructed in what could only be interpreted as a puff of non-existent smoke and appeared in a way as if it snuck up on you unawares, like an effervescent wave under a cloudy, moonlit night. But since it’s just a notebook and a pen and you didn’t notice it until you became aware of it, it really had been there all along. And so it was for the girl. She tried to remember where she was going. She looked around.

Nobody was there. On the floor was an empty notebook and a pen.

“Huh, I swear I saw that before”.

Comments (13)

180 Proof August 02, 2021 at 20:58 ¶ #574623
So Gödel didn't starve himself, he'd just always thought he'd already eaten. :smirk:
Jack Cummins August 02, 2021 at 21:20 ¶ #574628
I think that it is rather surreal, and the use of the notebook works, with the notebook almost appearing as a character present, in contrast to the underlying idea of 'nobody'.
_db August 02, 2021 at 23:53 ¶ #574679
Pretty spooky :eyes:

I enjoyed reading it.
Nils Loc August 03, 2021 at 19:08 ¶ #574977
"It’s all a bit blurry really. Well, gotta go and flip a switch.


No! Don't flip the switch. Don't ever mess with time. You'll be trapped in a Christopher Nolan movie.
Noble Dust August 04, 2021 at 23:13 ¶ #575496
A fun little mind bender, had to read it twice.
god must be atheist August 06, 2021 at 01:32 ¶ #575981
Quoting Baden
We’ve tested so often I dream about the tests
:100:

I don't know what happened there. I did not comprehend the story, so I can't make a critical comment on it. Sorry. My ineptitude, not yours.

Amity August 06, 2021 at 09:50 ¶ #576075
Quoting Baden
"Don't press that... "

Got my attention !
Anytime we are told not to do something, guess what...?

Quoting Baden
The air decompressed with the sound of a paperback softly falling closed, instantiating as a subsonic tremor,


Sucked right in.

Quoting Baden
a dark-haired, Asian girl stuck in her head and looked twice. Nobody was there.


First character: what is she up to in this secret lab, unauthorised entry ? Started reading a translucent and disappearing notebook...turns out to be that of a graduate lab assistant of Prof obsessed with time travel. Where are they ?

So far, I care about where this is going, and lab guy's trouble with French 'accents' was fun. Typical scientist, huh ? Even as he worries about what's gonna happen when the time travel test is starting...

Quoting Baden
By forcing a convergence of the worldvolume through a localized wormhole within the specific frame of reference of the lab, the negative copy, the self of four years ago and the present self would all be in one place. The four year old self would be nullified by the negative copy, resulting in the present self remaining in place at the convergence two years in the past. Sounds great in theory.


Whoosh...way above my head. But philosophically interesting, I suppose. Issues of changing selves and whotnot... Love the 'sounds great in theory'...it's the practice, real life that counts...or not.

Quoting Baden
We’ve tested so often I dream about the tests – each slightly different but eerily familiar and entirely realistic. Come to think of it, I always had a sense of being there before


Hmmm...already lived through the time travel experience and been affected...

Quoting Baden
Or the other way around, I can’t really recall. It’s all a bit blurry really. Well, gotta go and flip a switch.


Oh no...back to the beginning...Don't do it !!!

Love this:
Quoting Baden
The notebook and pen deconstructed in what could only be interpreted as a puff of non-existent smoke and appeared in a way as if it snuck up on you unawares, like an effervescent wave under a cloudy, moonlit night.


Is that what happened to him and the Prof ? But the girl...is still returning...

Quoting Baden
And so it was for the girl. She tried to remember where she was going. She looked around.
Nobody was there. On the floor was an empty notebook and a pen.


Back to the beginning, again...and again...
Quoting Baden
“Huh, I swear I saw that before”.


I enjoyed this story. The title 'I Never Was' - draws the mind in...pondering...and wondering...

Thanks to author for sharing :cool:

















Hanover August 08, 2021 at 01:07 ¶ #577116
I got the gist, but the denseness of the text was overly complex, so I found myself skimming. It was written in a language I don't speak, so it required me much effort, and I'd suspect I missed something. It's a short story for physics students.
thewonder August 09, 2021 at 17:35 ¶ #577932
Reply to Hanover
I liked the language and the usage of a set of notes to deliver the story. If you just let the scientific jargon fly over your head, it's a very enjoyable read.
thewonder August 12, 2021 at 16:24 ¶ #578957
Reply to Jack Cummins
The notebook being the record of events to have come beforehand, I think, was really clever. You're, like, reading the story that the story is about. It still boggles my mind.
Benkei August 23, 2021 at 14:14 ¶ #583376
Reply to Hanover But how believable would the story be if the note taker spoke more accessibly?
Benkei August 23, 2021 at 14:50 ¶ #583387
Reply to 180 Proof I actually got the idea from Richard Feynman's The Character of Physical Law, where he describes how these laws are basically symmetrical, in that sure, entropy increases, but nothing about the law stops it from decreasing. I can shake a bottle with mixed, coloured balls and when I stop shaking, they will be neatly ordered. From that symmetry and entanglement, I came to this "method" of time travel where the entangled "worldvolume" would switch places. Except of course, something always has to die in my stories...
180 Proof August 23, 2021 at 15:06 ¶ #583395
Reply to Benkei Of course. :up: